Sister for Theo

[Baby20222]

DC2 due in a couple of a weeks and we're still completely stuck for a girls name, it's tougher than I thought! We want something pretty, but not toooo popular. Our DC1 is named Theodore, we call him Theo.

Names we love that are just too popular: Amelia, Isla, Eve, Matilda, Lyra, Ella

Names we love, but not that keen on the potential nicknames: Florence (Flo, Flossie, don't mind Florrie so much), Clementine (Clemmie, Clem)

Names that we love, but don't work with our surname (too botanical!!): Poppy, Lily, Hollie

Any suggestions gratefully received!!

Theo and Martha.

Ayla
Lila
Otille (non. Tilly)

Lola

Jacinta.

The Theodore I know has a sister named Millicent/Milly. I always thought they went together really nicely. Really Theodore is a nice name which could fit with lots of different names for a sister. I would choose something that’s equally as versatile.

Eleanor
Olivia
Isabelle
Lucia/Lucille
Caitlin
Emily/Emilia
Harriet
Liliana

Theo and Genevieve
Theo and Iris
Theo and Katie
Theo and Lucille
Theo and Violet

If you like Ella then maybe Gabriella?

Rosalie
Rebecca
Adeline
Annie

Leah

We have a Theo if he had a sister she would have been Harriet (Hetty)

Eloise

Florence , Violet or Caitlin. 💕💕💕

Theo and Bethan
Theo and Cara
Theo and Georgia
Theo and Lottie
Theo and Xanthe
Theo and Zara

Meredith

Jasmin
Roxanna
Iris
Rosa

Penelope
Tabitha
Cora

Theo and
Lois
Polly
Dana
Alexis
Erin

Vienna !

Edda

Honestly I love Theo with Lyra or Isla off your list - I wouldn't over think the popularity thing, just pick a name you love. I've only met one kid with each of those names (a 3yr old Lyra and a 9yr old Isla) and you could easily pick another name that accidently becomes popular in a year or two.

If you really want to avoid them though other ideas:
Maia
Zara
Cora

I think I just really like names ending with -a to go with Theo!

Theo is massively popular, so the obvious choice is Sophia.
Theo shows up lower in the top baby names because some are registered as Theodore
Sophia is the same, with the Sofia spelling also popular

Jane
Elizabeth
Mary
Kitty
Lydia
Emma/Emily
Anna/Annie

Alice? A lovely name at any age.

Similar in sound to those you like:
Esme
Eliza
Lydia
Ida

other ideas of similar vein - ie longer, pretty, quite traditional

Penelope (nell?)
Jemima (jem)
Camilla

Theodore and

ivy
iris
clara
edith
esther
rosalie
harriet
henrietta
juliet
sadie
olive
ottilie
penelope
nancy
delilah
beatrix
violet
scarlett