Sadie or Nancy

[Popeye44]

Hi,
ive narrowed my name choices down to Sadie or Nancy.

which one would you go for?

and what middle names?

thanks!

[mathanxiety]

Nancy, though Sadie is really nice.

Nancy June
Nancy Elizabeth
Nancy Clementine
Nancy Elinor
Nancy Elise
Nancy Isobel
Nancy Elowen
Nancy Gabrielle
Nancy Juliet
Nancy Rosalind
Nancy Lucille
Nancy Estelle

[17caterpillars1mouse]

I much prefer Sadie. Lovely name

A few middle name ideas (I would avoid the usual Sadie Rose, Sadie May, Sadie Grace)

Sadie Imogen
Sadie Àdelaide
Sadie Rebecca
Sadie Lucille
Sadie Laura
Sadie Patience
Sadie Diana

I like unexpected middle names

[MissPocket]

I love both of those names! I slightly prefer Sadie.

Sadie Freya
Sadie Catherine

Nancy Charlotte
Nancy May

[Jubileeeeeeee]

Both lovely but I order Nancy
Nancy Mae/May

[ChagSameachDoreen]

Nancy!

Sadie sounds like sadist.

[SycamoreTall]

Sadie. I've never liked Nancy.

Sadie Marianne
Sadie Harriet
Sadie Beatrix

[DramaAlpaca]

Sadie, I dislike Nancy.

[CormoranStrike]

Nancy from those too, but honestly don’t love either

[timoteigirl]

Neither really. Sadie like sadist like already mentioned above. Nancy not that nice. What about Lacey? Maddie? Nadia? Nadie (from Nadia, meaning hope) could be a nicer and a compromise between these two names.

[PaddleBoardingMomma]

Sadie rose
Sadie beau
Sadie Mae
Sadie Jude
Sadie viola

Just off the top of my head, I think it's a very feminine but strong name I love it

[WhatsHoppening]

My DD is a Sadie Rose! Love love love the name and we rarely meet other Sadies (although both times we have their middle name has been rose too! So maybe be more original 🤣)

[Blowyourowntrumpet]

I like both, but I prefer Sadie

[TreeP0se]

Love both

[Rebelmcstreettuff]

Honestly my 2 favourite names,don't know which one I would pick but then I didn't need to as I had 2 boys.....

[70isaLimitNotaTarget]

I wanted to call my DD Mercedes (but I didn't) so she'd have been "Sadie" as her real life name .

(And I knew a really lovely horse called Sadie )

Sadie ( but I don't do middle names )

[threecupsofteaminimum]

Sadie for sure

Sadie Rose
Sadie Jane
Sadie Louise
Sadie Christie
Sadie Ruth
Sadie Marie
Sadie Margot

[PaddleBoardingMomma]

@WhatsHoppening

My DD is a Sadie Rose! Love love love the name and we rarely meet other Sadies (although both times we have their middle name has been rose too! So maybe be more original 🤣)

Sadie rose was the first name that popped in my head, it's beautiful!

[VeryQuaintIrene]

I"ve only known dogs called Sadie, so Nancy.

[DogsAndGin]

Nancy

[TheYearOfSmallThings]

Nancy by a mile.

Sadie always makes me think of a hard bitten older woman with cigarette mouth and a grubby fake fur jacket.

[Isausernameavailable]

Definitely Nancy. I had a lovely goat called Nancy. She was beautiful.

[ladygindiva]

I like them both, but a pp suggested Sadie Catherine, and to me that just has a gorgeous feel to it.

[PaddleBoardingMomma]

@ladygindiva

I like them both, but a pp suggested Sadie Catherine, and to me that just has a gorgeous feel to it.

I named my daughter Catherine so always nice to see when it's mentioned, I always worried it might be a bit out of favour these days

[GreatCuppa]

I really don’t like Nancy, so Sadie. But not with the usual Rose/Grace/May.

[pitterypattery00]

Sadie! I don't like Nancy at all.

I think Sadie goes well with a longish middle name-

Sadie Alexandra
Sadie Florence
Sadie Eloise
Sadie Antonia
Sadie Catherine
Sadie Beatrice
Sadie Meredith
Sadie Elizabeth