Sadie or Nancy

[Popeye44]

Hi,
ive narrowed my name choices down to Sadie or Nancy.

which one would you go for?

and what middle names?

thanks!

Nancy, though Sadie is really nice.

Nancy June
Nancy Elizabeth
Nancy Clementine
Nancy Elinor
Nancy Elise
Nancy Isobel
Nancy Elowen
Nancy Gabrielle
Nancy Juliet
Nancy Rosalind
Nancy Lucille
Nancy Estelle

I much prefer Sadie. Lovely name

A few middle name ideas (I would avoid the usual Sadie Rose, Sadie May, Sadie Grace)

Sadie Imogen
Sadie Àdelaide
Sadie Rebecca
Sadie Lucille
Sadie Laura
Sadie Patience
Sadie Diana

I like unexpected middle names

I love both of those names! I slightly prefer Sadie.

Sadie Freya
Sadie Catherine

Nancy Charlotte
Nancy May

Both lovely but I order Nancy
Nancy Mae/May

Nancy!

Sadie sounds like sadist.

Sadie. I've never liked Nancy.

Sadie Marianne
Sadie Harriet
Sadie Beatrix

Sadie, I dislike Nancy.

Nancy from those too, but honestly don’t love either

Neither really. Sadie like sadist like already mentioned above. Nancy not that nice. What about Lacey? Maddie? Nadia? Nadie (from Nadia, meaning hope) could be a nicer and a compromise between these two names.

Sadie rose
Sadie beau
Sadie Mae
Sadie Jude
Sadie viola

Just off the top of my head, I think it's a very feminine but strong name I love it

My DD is a Sadie Rose! Love love love the name and we rarely meet other Sadies (although both times we have their middle name has been rose too! So maybe be more original 🤣)

I like both, but I prefer Sadie

Love both

Honestly my 2 favourite names,don't know which one I would pick but then I didn't need to as I had 2 boys.....

I wanted to call my DD Mercedes (but I didn't) so she'd have been "Sadie" as her real life name .

(And I knew a really lovely horse called Sadie )

Sadie ( but I don't do middle names )

Sadie for sure

Sadie Rose
Sadie Jane
Sadie Louise
Sadie Christie
Sadie Ruth
Sadie Marie
Sadie Margot

Sadie rose was the first name that popped in my head, it's beautiful!

I"ve only known dogs called Sadie, so Nancy.

Nancy

Definitely Nancy. I had a lovely goat called Nancy. She was beautiful.

Nancy by a mile.

Sadie always makes me think of a hard bitten older woman with cigarette mouth and a grubby fake fur jacket.

I like them both, but a pp suggested Sadie Catherine, and to me that just has a gorgeous feel to it.

I named my daughter Catherine so always nice to see when it's mentioned, I always worried it might be a bit out of favour these days

I really don’t like Nancy, so Sadie. But not with the usual Rose/Grace/May.

Sadie! I don't like Nancy at all.

I think Sadie goes well with a longish middle name-

Sadie Alexandra
Sadie Florence
Sadie Eloise
Sadie Antonia
Sadie Catherine
Sadie Beatrice
Sadie Meredith
Sadie Elizabeth