Imogen or Jasmine?

[Honey2]

As the title says which do you prefer?

Imogen

Jasmine

Jasmine

I really like both, but I think Jasmine just pips it.

Love both but jasmine slightly more

Both are actually really nice. I would probably choose Imogen but I also really like Jasmine.

Thanks! Just to throw another one in the mix - what do you think of Scarlett??

Would pick Imogen out of the three, with Jasmine as second choice.

Scarlett isn't in the same league as the other two, not at all. Totally different style too.

Both lovely names. If people were to shorten them, would it put you off? Most likely Immy and Jazz/Jazzy? Just maybe something to think about. I know of girls with both these names and everyone shortens them both.

Still prefer Imogen.

Jasmine and Scarlett are a bit dated.

I like Jasmine, don't really like either of the others.

Definitely Jasmine

Imogen was my first pick for a girl :) ended up with a boy though!

Jasmine - a happy, strong name
Scarlett - has character
Imogen - weedy and whiny

Like all three.

Imogen 100%

Jasmine

Imogen
Scarlett

Imogen

Definitely Jasmine! Cute and jazzy!

I've always thought Imogen was a pretty ugly name... reminds me of engine oil.

Scarlett is a bit meh.

Thanks all,

So a NO for Scarlett then... I make that 6 for Imogen and 8 for Jasmine.

How about with these middle names -

Imogen Lilly
Imogen Mae
Imogen Esme

Jasmine Ada
Jasmine Mae
Jasmine Eliza

Love Jasmine

I’d pick Jasmine Eliza

Jasmine

Imogen is so harsh and unfeminine

I love all three but if I had to choose
Scarlett
Jasmine
Imogen (simply because I don't like Immy as a nickname)

Your middle name choices
Imogen Lily
Imogen Esme
Imogen Mae
(Although I'm not keen on any of them)

Jasmine Eliza
Jasmine Ada
Jasmine Mae

Scarlett.