Final two names - Aidan or Isaac?

[PumpkinSoup21]

Which should we go for and why? Aidan or Isaac.
DS is three weeks old and I can’t decide which suits better.

Definitely Isaac - fab name.

They are both lovely so in my view you could just pick one out of a hat and be fine.

My personal choice would be Aidan of those two. I like it because of the meaning, the Celtic background, and the fact that it's a bit more unusual.

Isaac
It was on our list and I still like it 15 years on.

Love Isaac.

Both lovely choices but I would go for isaac

Aidan is great... if you've given birth to a 40 year old man.

Isaac

I love Aidan, it's a little more unusual

@JustWonderingIfYou I laughed out loud.

I much prefer Aidan.

I would go with Aidan

Aidan

Isaac

Aidan

Aidan all day every day

Aidan is lovely! A beautiful Celtic saint's name. Isaac also lovely but Aidan is more unusual right now.

Ignore the 40 yr old man comment - I get that about my son's (completely normal, common as anything) name, but I just let it wash over me!

Isaac.
I prefer Aaron to Aidan.

Issac
Mainly because Aidan is on the rise so I think Issac will be more unusual for a baby born now, it’s also a slightly more classic option (assuming you in England) as it’s been in popular use for centuries so it won’t date, whereas Aidan will a bit.

I loved Isaac until someone pointed out the I suck thing. Sorry OP. Also, you'll get a lot of people writing Issac which would get on my pips.

Isaac for sure, there can't be many Isaacs around, can there? As a kid I was usually the only person in my year at school with my first name, so there wasn't for example Katy 1, Katie with the e, Katie 2.

As a MN said above I too think Aaron over Aidan.

There's loads of Isaacs around. I have an Aidan and an Isaac.
Both will get spelt wrong all the time. Obviously I'm biased but I think they're both lovely names.

Aidan

Aidan by far.

Isaac

Aidan by a country mile!