Baby girl name - which one?

[MummyJune2017]

Baby girl due in Jan. We love long names that can be shortened to lots of different nicknames, currently torn between Genevieve and Dorothy.
Currently have a Josephine, what do people think?

I think Josephine and Genevieve are a bit of a mouthful.

Josephine and Dorothy sound lovely together.

Josephine and Genevieve feel a bit OTT together so I'd go with Dorothy. Although they're all a bit rhymey.

I love them both. What would you be using for short?

I went to school with a Dotty - Dorothy.

I prefer Genevieve

LOVE Genevieve, and think it goes well with Josephine.
Strongly dislike Dorothy. I went to school with one and always thought her name was so very twee.

Dorothy

Changed my mind:

I prefer Genevieve. Just think it's a bit much with Josephine.

I prefer Genevieve but agree its too much with Josephine. I don't like Dorothy or any of its derivative forms.

I'd choose Genevieve.

Dorothea nn Thea?

@MummyJune2017 I have a Genevieve, we fell in love with the name fairly late on in pregnancy (didn't know what we were having), it already is shortened to Gen or Vivi. We love it and get lots of comments on it being a lovely name (of course they could just be saying it to be nice)

Genevieve is lovely. Dorothy is very twee.

Genevieve

Genevieve is lovely. Vivienne or Madeleine sound nice with Josephine too.

Dorothy.

I’ve met three baby Genevieve’s at my 6 month old daughters various baby classes recently if that’s the type of thing you are concerned about! Same for lots and lots of Willow’s and Lyra’s!

We have a Francesca, who we call Frankie

Dorothy by a mile and more

Dorothy.
Genevieve is too much of a mouthful with Josephine.

Genevieve has too many 'e's, it looks messy.

Dorothy is awful.

Any others on your list?

If you like three syllable names..
Imogen
Violet
Annabel

Genevieve

What about Elizabeth?

Or Jocelyn