Baby girl name - which one?

[MummyJune2017]

Baby girl due in Jan. We love long names that can be shortened to lots of different nicknames, currently torn between Genevieve and Dorothy.
Currently have a Josephine, what do people think?

Definitely Dorothy.

Dorothea nn Thea?.

Nicer than Dorothy but I'm scarred by Middlemarch. Probably means nothing to most people though!

Love both, and both are perfect with Josephine. If I had to pick it would be Dorothy.

I love Dorothy, it's on my list. Could be Dot or Dotty

I prefer Genevieve but Dorothy goes better with Josephine

Evangeline
Catherine
Annabella
Samantha

I love Genevieve. I like Dorothy in a vintage chic kind of way. I feel Dorothy works better at Josephine's sister.

I have always loved Dorothea.

Not keen on Dorothy - it feels dated to me, unlike the more classic Josephine (Dorothea or Theodora is marginally better but I still don't love it). Genevieve is lovely and would be my choice but is a tiny bit "soundalike" to Josephine.

Other suggestions to match Josephine (long classic names that have several shortenings):
Adaline (Ada, Addie, Allie)
Caroline (Carrie, Callie, Caro)
Charlotte (Charlie, Lottie, Callie)
Cecilia (Cece, Cissy, Lia)
Beatrice (Bea, Tris, Trixie)
Madeleine (Maddie, Lainey, Della)
Helena or Eleanor (Nell, Leni, Ellie, Ella)
Elizabeth (there's dozens! but I'd be tempted by Beth for the Little Women pairing)
Louisa (Lola, Lulu, Lou)
Catherine (Kitty, Kate, Cathy, Trina)
Georgina (Gigi, Gia, Georgie, Ginny)
Harriet (Harry, Etta, Hattie, Hetty)
Alexandra (Lexi, Sasha, Xandra, Alex)

Not keen on either but not genevieve

Love Genevieve. Don't think it's 'too much' with Josephine (love that too) if you are shortening the names for everyday use.

Genevieve. I love Evelyn/ Eve for short.

Definitely Genevieve.

LOVE Josephine and Genevieve together. Not OTT, they sound perfect together!