Lucy, Sophie, Holly &....?!

[Allpink]

Looking for a sibling name for Lucy, Sophie & Holly.
Open to suggestions.
Currently considering

Zoe
Lily
Chloe
Amy
Poppy
Emiliy ( not convinced - would likely end up using Millie )
Ellie ( OH loves but I’m not so keen as feel it’s a little nick name-ey)

I like Lily, Chloe, Zoe and Ellie but all are very popular.

Penelope
Ivy
Sadie
Lacey
Addie

Alice

I like Amy best from your list. Think it 'goes' best too.

Other suggestions: Clara, Sadie, Laura, Rachel, Charlotte (could be Lottie for short), Nina

Zoe from your list, Anna also great

Love all your names! I'm one of them and the other 2 are on my list 😆
From your list: Chloe.

If you like Millie, it works. Ellie does too. (keeping the ee sound)

Others I like are Isobel, Jessica, Charlotte, Nicole, Erin, Ava & Isla

Abby/Abbie or Rosalie/Rosily jumped to mind from seeing the thread title

Charlotte came to mind first for some reason!

I’d find Ellie a little too close to Holly.

Emily and Poppy are lovely though. Your girls have great names.

Eliza

Chloe 😍

I came to say Maisie, see a lot of others have said it, but thought I'd still comment anyway :).

Thanks you all so so much for your responses and suggestions. We really appreciate it. We are not rethinking our name choices and considering Alice & Emma. Alice has always been a favourite of my husband and I’m beginning to think it’s a nice fit too.
Thanks you all!

Lucy Sophie Holly and
Daisy
Elsie
Maisie
Rosie
Nancy

Annie.
Darcey
Penny

Alice and Emma are very nice - both are a similar English classic style to the rest of the sibset (and 2 syllables so that "matches" too!) . With the other girls names I like Alice the most when written down, as it has the same ending as Sophie (so you have 2 "e" names and 2 "y" names with the siblings!); but when you listen to the girls names said all together there are a lot of "L" sounds so Emma works better in that respect. Another very similar style possibility to consider is Charlotte (as pp suggested?)

Katie

Anna
Katie
Josie
Frankie
Penny
Natalie
Kayleigh

Oh, I can't believe I forgot the lovely Anna! If you can't decide between Emma and Alice, then Anna is a perfect middle ground (and is my personal favorite of the 3 too - so beautiful and elegant).

@Allpink

Thanks you all so so much for your responses and suggestions. We really appreciate it. We are not rethinking our name choices and considering Alice & Emma. Alice has always been a favourite of my husband and I’m beginning to think it’s a nice fit too. Thanks you all!

That should read that we are NOW * reconsidering our options ! Oops! Many thanks once again

I like Zoe from your list. The others all merge too closely into the (lovely) names you already have.

How about:
Phoebe
Nancy
Ivy
Leonie
Tess

Wait - you can't have Holly and Ivy.
Forget Ivy.

Isla?

Ahh I want to be your friend as I can just imagine 4 gorgeous girls! I do hope you let us know what u choose. I think you should stop people in their tracks a bit.. not with something obviously unmatchy of the other names or novelty like ‘storm’ but your names are beautiful and the next will slot in most likely with a perfectly predictable name (nothing wrong with that) this is not about shock factoring but rather giving this little girl something slightly less traditional so she can live up to her name and be quite extraordinary...maybe something with sass or something brave that expands your family right out of its beautiful box...(in saying that I absolutely love Katie, Fleur, Alice,Grace....and Emily is usually Em which is soft) Annabelle, Juliet, ,Skye

Without reading the thread I thought Emma immediately! Good luck with whichever you choose, you have already chosen such beautiful names

I like Zoe best from your list, but my first thought when I read your other girls names was Rosie - I love the -y, -ie, -y and then another -ie ending.

Thanks you all so so much for your responses and suggestions. We really appreciate it. We are not rethinking our name choices and considering Alice & Emma. Alice has always been a favourite of my husband and I’m beginning to think it’s a nice fit too.
Thanks you all!

Great news - those were my suggestions too

I thought Amy before I even saw your list.