Lucy, Sophie, Holly &....?!

[Allpink]

Looking for a sibling name for Lucy, Sophie & Holly.
Open to suggestions.
Currently considering

Zoe
Lily
Chloe
Amy
Poppy
Emiliy ( not convinced - would likely end up using Millie )
Ellie ( OH loves but I’m not so keen as feel it’s a little nick name-ey)

Charlotte
Martha
Alice
Ava
Kate
Anna
Laura
Madeleine
Imogen
Isla
Norah
Lydia

From your list I think Amy is the best choice with the siblings. It has the most distinct sounds while still perfectly fitting the style, (and it is lovely). Lily, Emily and Ellie sound too like Holly. I would use just Millie as the full name rather than Emily. Poppy is nice but similar sounds to Holly. Zoe and Chloe are nice, but feel a different style to your girls' names to me. I think Ellen or Ella would fit better and be less nicknamey than Ellie.

I'm sure these are repeats at this stage, but I like these with your family:
Alice
Daisy
Maisie
Violet
Pippa
Tess
Tessa
Peggy
Rosie
Rose
Annie
Mary
Ivy
Edie
Maggie
Flora
Grace
Gracie
Katie
Fleur
May
Anna

Congratulations!

Amy, Zoe & Chloe are a bit 80s IMO

Lily is a bit overused

Poppy & Ellie are nice

Other suggestions:
Evie
Molly
Annie
Elsie
Abbey
Daisy
Ivy
Jessie
Katie
Lori
Marnie
Maisie
Rosie
Sally

Sadie
Eliza
Stella

Callie
Aurora
Jessie
Marnie
Tilly

Claire
Jane
Eve
Grace
Kate

I read the title and instantly thought Emily. I also like Amy and Poppy from your list. PP suggestions of Daisy, Imogen and Alice are also a nice fit.

Lovely names op. I think ellie or chloe flow best. Also love lily

Belle goes nicely imo

i quite like Lily and Chloe

Phoebe goes nicely 🙂

Lily off your list

Jessica
Esme
Megan

Lucy, Sophie, Holly and Alice
Lucy, Sophie, Holly and Katie
Lucy, Sophie, Holly and Daisy
Lucy, Sophie, Holly and Evie
Lucy, Sophie, Holly and Phoebe
Lucy, Sophie, Holly and Maisie
Lucy, Sophie, Holly and Rosie
Lucy, Sophie, Holly and Annie

Poppy, Amy or Emily from your list

I prefer a single syllable name with all those two syllable ones. Feels more like finishing a list!
So
Eve
Rose
Fay
Or
Anne

First name that came to me was Poppy.
I do like Millie though

@user1493494961

From your list Poppy or Emily. I wouldn't have Holly and Ivy and I don't think Wren fits at all. I know siblings Lucy, Sophie and Alice and I always think how nice they sound.

Holly and Ivy are the only matchy names I like but tbf I am a huge Christmas fan so I accept it’s probably on the loopy side!

Ellie is nice I agree with DH but you need a name that doesn't end in ie or y.

Alice or Charlotte.

Or go with a name like Ellen, Elowen, Eloise, Eleanor, Elizabeth etc

(However bare in mind names starting with El are a bit trendy atm).

Zoe
Lily - live but wouldn't give two girls L
Chloe
Amy
Poppy - lively
Emiliy ( not convinced - would likely end up using Millie )
Ellie ( OH loves but I’m not so keen as feel it’s a little nick name-ey)

Lucy, Sophie, Holly and Jemma.

I think all your suggestions would work well, Chloe and Poppy are my favourites Phoebe could work too

Alice, from your list - Chloe

My instant thought was Lucy, Sophie, Holly & Marnie!

Lovely girls names by the way!