Thoughts on this list for girls?

[RiteAid]

This is my girl shortlist:

Dorothy
Harriet
Tabitha
Clara
Juliet

I have a favourite but won’t say which in case it sways things!

Harriet is my favourite, Clara and Juliet are also great. I don’t love Dorothy or Tabitha but I don’t hate them either. Lovely list!

Harriet or Clara

Love Juliet. Classically beautiful x

Love Clara, Juliet would be second.

Harriet, Clara and Juliet I love the other two I don’t!

I love Clara if I had another rig would be on my list! There is something nice about Tabitha despite the cat connections. Also like Juliet.

In order:
Dorothy (second the suggestion to consider Dorothea)
Tabitha
Harriet
Clara
Juliet

tabitha sounds like a cat.
harriet is good, also dorothy.
not so keen on clara, sounds like a pretentious claire.
juliet could get teased, where's romeo...or you did for him.
would you consider Lucy. simple but sounds bright and cheerful.
all the best.

I would rate them in this order

Tabitha
Juliet
Clara
Dorothy
Harriet

This order for me:

Tabitha
Juliet
Clara
Harriet

No to Dorothy

I like Harriet, Clara and Dorothy - Dorothy is my favourite

Not keen on Tabitha as I dislike Tabby. I like Talitha though nn Tallie

Not a fan of Julie, it seems such a serious name

Dorothy - Nice. Good nicknames.
Harriet - Try-hard.
Tabitha - Lisping posh girl.
Clara - Good strong name.
Juliet - Wishy-washy.

Tabitha , dorothy it's good Juliet also nice clara, Harriet not that much.

Harriet is one of my absolute favourites but unfortunately my husband didn't like it. Tabitha would be my least favourite, not sure about my in betweens

My largest tortoise was named Tabitha. I really like the name.

I like Juliet the best.

Dorothy - nice, but prefer Dorothea
Harriet - didn't used to like this but it has grown on me. Good choice
Tabitha - not keen
Clara - best of the bunch
Juliet - not keen and can't really understand its popularity tbh

I like Clara the best from your list. In my opinion Harriet was a bit over used a few years ago. Not overly keen on Dorothy but probably wouldn't mind Dotty or Dot for a NN. Don't really like Tabitha and Juliet is okay!

I love Dorothy/Dot/Dottie/Dolly, but ever so slightly prefer Dorothea, which gives the additional option of Thea.
I am a fan of The Wizard of Oz and also of both Dorothea Lange and Dolly Parton, though!

We have a Harriet, Nicknamed Hattie.

Her name gets lots of compliments and I haven't met another one locally

OP, Dorothy is the one I was going to say I wasn't that keen on. However, the main thing is for you to choose a name which you love. My DD has a name which is derided on MN for being "posh". However, it's my favourite name of all time ever (for a girl), and I am glad every single day of DD's 16 years that I chose it. She has come to terms with it, too.

Actually, OP, Dorothy has the advantage that it's relatively unusual. The other names you mention were all very well represented at my DD's junior school (all girls, so lots of girls there). Hattie was particularly popular.

Dorothy - 1, love Dot as a nn
Harriet - 2, love Hattie as a nn
Tabitha - no
Clara - no
Juliet - don't like Jools so a no