Thoughts on this list for girls?

[RiteAid]

This is my girl shortlist:

Dorothy
Harriet
Tabitha
Clara
Juliet

I have a favourite but won’t say which in case it sways things!

I think Tabitha and Juliet are really sweet! Clara I find a bit overused at the moment, and Harriet and Dorothy a bit too far on the frumpy side.

I like them all apart from Juliet. Favourite is Tabitha.

Clara, Dorothy and Harriet are my favourite from your list. I know a few girls with the names Clara/Klara or Harriet ranging from age 2 to 16, and a 15 year old Dorothy.
Harriet and Dorothy both have a variety of nickname options too e.g. Harry, Hattie and Dot, Dotty, Thea.

Tabitha is darling. Also, I know a cat called Juliet and a dog called Harriet, so I don’t know why people keeping going on about Tabitha being a cat’s name. I also love Dorothy.

I really like Juliet! 😍

Juliet and Harriet are my favourites.

I like Clara and Juliet best, then Harriet

Juliet is my favourite.

Dorothy - nope sorry, really don't like it, very old fashioned and I am not sure it was ever a pretty name, Dotty for a nickname is hideous
Harriet - sounds extremely upper class to me, makes me think of horses for some reason
Tabitha - cat
Clara - like it - simple, elegant
Juliet - like it - prefer the spelling Juliette but having seen what someone says about the nickname of Jules I am looking at it a bit differently.

In order

Clara
Juliet
Tabitha
Harriet
Dorothy

Harriet - hands down. 🙏

Clara or Harriet.

Thank you everyone!

My favourite is Dorothy but I worry about the perception of it being too old fashioned (though it’s probably overdue for a comeback!) my second favourite is Harriet, which may be a safer choice. But I really like them all.

I really like Tabitha and Harriet. Clara and Julia perfectly nice. Dorothy sounds middle-aged.

I love them all except Tabitha (sorry - cat's name for me)
My favourite is Juliet (ette for preference)
I know a little Dotty who's about 4 - very cute.

Dorothy does sound very old I think. Harriet (Hattie) is more classic and timeless.

I like Dorothy best. Dottie and Dot are lovely.

Love Harriet. Dorothy second favourite, then Clara. Juliet Ok, don’t like Tabitha - knew sisters called Tabitha and Catherine and they were known as Tabby and Cat.

Just noticed your latest post OP - Dorothy is lovely, please go for it!

Clara

Love Harriet and Tabitha. These are on my list too (along with Henrietta and Arrietty).

😊

@RiteAid I know two delightful girls under 5 called Dorothy....one nicknames Dot/Dotty and the other Dolly.

It's a lovely name!

I like them all. You have excellent name taste. Would you consider Dorothea? It's what we should've called DD, but we got side tracked. It would've totally suited her better.

If Dorothy is your favourite you should use it @RiteAid it's already coming back so don't worry

Love Tabitha and Clara. Like Juliet a lot. Secretly love Dorothy, but wouldn't be brave enough to go for it. Harriet, I find both dull and dated.