Help narrow the list please

[Olthe]

Choices are:

Tabitha
Harlow
Indie
Eliza
Penelope
Eden
Florence

Thank you

Tabitha - a bit old fashioned
Harlow - don't like, prefer Harley
Indie - meh
Eliza - plain, boring and dated
Penelope - strongly dislike
Eden - love
Florence - love

So yeah, Eden and Florence would be my picks.

Tabitha and Eden are my faves. Both lovely

I love Florence ❤️

Eliza and Eden are my favourites!

Tabitha- reminds me of a witch! Maybe an 80's show where the witch character was called Tabitha? I also think of Tabby, like a cat.

Harlow- I thought this was a male name? It sounds masculine to me and the one I dislike the most.

Indie- Bit hippy, but I do like different, less common names. What about Indiana or India?

Eliza- Its ok

Penelope- I like it, and also Penny

Eden- LOVE! I had this on my shortlist. Different, without being really out there.

Florence- Flo, always remind me of the period tracking app or a 90yr old lady. I think its becoming more popular again, but not a fan.

I like Eliza and Florence best

I think Eliza is by far the nicest.

Ditch the naff ones - Eden, Harlow and Indie - and choose from the classics.

Love Tabitha, second choice would be Eliza.

Tabitha or Penelope. Beautiful names.

We know a few male Eadens and Edens if that bothers you.

Tabitha - Nice, makes me think of Bewitched
Harlow - NO, I live near Harlow in Essex, it’s not a nice place at all.
Indie - Love (short for Indigo?)
Eliza - Love
Penelope - No
Eden - Quite like this, different without being bonkers.
Florence - We have a guinea pig called Florence

What letters/sound is the surname?

Quite like Tabitha and Florence always works.

Eden or Penelope

Tabitha lovely
Harlow would be chavvy round here and ugly i think, sorry
Indie ok? Very popular currently
Eliza lovely
Penelope ok
Eden ok. Again? Very popular
Florence lovely

Tabitha - My ex's dog was named this so I can’t see it as a human name anymore
Harlow - Reminds me of Harlem in NY, and that’s not a good connection
Indie - Sounds like you wanted the name India but it was too popular already
Eliza - I love this one
Penelope - Sadly I speak Spanish and pene is penis
Eden- Love it
Florence - Its a bit popular for my taste but I feel it’s a timeless and beautiful name

Florence, Eden and Eliza are my picks

Thank you for the opinions!
Ha, I certainly wouldn’t want my child’s name referencing a penis in any language so thanks!

Tabitha: I like
Eliza : really like
Indie: feels incomplete
Penelope: really like
Eden: boy's name not my fave
Florence: ok, rather we'll used if that bothers you
Harlow; a new town in Essex or surname to Jean , either way not a very nice first name imo.

Tabitha - not sure why but I hate this name
Harlow - no
Indie - no
Eliza - ok
Penelope - ok
Eden - meh, don’t love or hate it
Florence - overused

Tabitha, Eliza or Penelope.

I hate Florence, it's quite an ugly sounding, cumbersome name somehow. I can't explain it. I hear it and a little part of me thinks "Eww". And given everyone's obsession with NNs these days, she'll probably be called Flo. Which is even worse.

Harlow is inoffensive but not my style. Disclaimer: I've never been to Harlow.

Eliza, Tabitha and Penelope are pretty and suit all ages and all walks of life.

Indie is half a name. Reminds me of all those daft middle class hippie-wannabes who called their DDs India years ago.

Eden makes me think of the Garden of Eden story about how women are sinners and must be kept under wraps for their own good. I acknowledge I am probably in the minority with this PoV.

I love them all apart from Eden and Harlow!

Tabitha - just think of a cat and then think of the horrible rude word Pussy and think it could be used as a taunt?! Ha. Probably just me being odd.
Harlow - nah really downmarket
Indie - love love love
Eliza - love love love - favourite!
Penelope - love love love
Eden - love
Florence - love - favourite!

Eliza, Eden or Florence

Tabitha - quite nice
Harlow - awful, chavvy
Indie - meh... India is OK
Eliza - nice
Penelope - lovely
Eden - tacky
Florence - lovely

Eliza
Penelope
Florence
Tabitha

In that order. Were there any other proper names?