Active discussions

Best Amazon Prime Day deals: Mumsnet favourites

Best Amazon Prime Day deals:
Mumsnet favourites

Shop now

Please or to access all these features

Talk
Baby names

Find baby name inspiration and advice on the Mumsnet Baby Names forum.

Original poster

Liberty or Elodie?

54 replies

Lumay · 26/07/2019 22:10

DD is Esmé, what do you think of Elodie or Liberty as a name for another girl? Does it go with Esmé? Or other suggestions! Thanks xx

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
Set a reminder
Moonflower12 · 26/07/2019 22:11

I like Liberty.

Honeyroar · 26/07/2019 22:12

I'm not sure. They both sound like makes of caravans. Sorry!

DramaAlpaca · 26/07/2019 22:12

I prefer Elodie, it's very pretty. But I think it might be just too similar to Esmé.

I don't like Liberty much, but Libby is nice.

MondeoFan · 26/07/2019 22:14

I like Elodie as both same letter think it goes well Esme & Elodie

TFSRM · 26/07/2019 22:22

Neither are particularly nice

KronksSpinachPuffs · 26/07/2019 22:23

Elodie :)

AllTheProsecco · 26/07/2019 22:28

I love Elodie and we have a Libby who is Elizabeth but could also know a Liberty who is Libby.

username1724 · 26/07/2019 23:00

I love both, Liberty/Libby just about wins for me though

TemporaryPermanent · 26/07/2019 23:01

I like Liberty more than Elodie but they're both nice.

dogshitcars · 26/07/2019 23:12

Both dire. You did ask.

AverageMummy · 26/07/2019 23:16

Don’t really like either but I don’t think Esme and Elodie work well as siblings - they’re extremely alike

Lydia or Melody are a mix of the styles you like?
Other suggestions: Alba, Olivia, Cassia

Lobsterquadrille2 · 26/07/2019 23:23

I like both but Liberty is more of a contrast with Esme.

Tillygetsit · 27/07/2019 00:02

Liberty is better as I think same initials sound a bit twee. Gabrielle?

coatlessinspokane · 27/07/2019 00:03

Elodie for sure

Equatoria · 27/07/2019 00:04

Of the two I prefer Elodie.

Shadow1234 · 27/07/2019 03:25

I love both. Elodie is a very pretty name, but maybe a bit too much with Esme.

Derbee · 27/07/2019 03:59

I love both names. Although I wouldn’t have two children with the same initial. I know from experience that as they get older, they will constantly be opening each other’s mail etc.

Much nicer to have different E Smith and L Smith rather than 2 E Smiths imo

Lunablue765 · 27/07/2019 05:51

Hello my first Is called Elodie I think it's a very pretty French name keep in mind you will get people say ooh like melody but without the M 😏 used to drive me crazy. But of your two choices I'd pick liberty as it flows better alongside esme x good luck picking a name is so hard x

GenerationYmember · 27/07/2019 07:25

I love Elodie. Beautiful.

Liberty not really keen, Statue of Liberty springs to mind and I am not a fan of Libby.

eurochick · 27/07/2019 07:39

Elodie is lovely. It was one of our top three names for a girl.

HeronLanyon · 27/07/2019 07:44

Agree not same initial - I have experience of this within family and it can be a pain.
Liberty and Esme feel very different to me. I think they’re the kind of names where each may wish they had the other or wonder why the difference.
I like both. Just not together I think.

TheRedBarrows · 27/07/2019 08:05

Both lovely.

Liberty goes better with Esme.

user1493494961 · 27/07/2019 08:26

Liberty.

SheChoseDown · 27/07/2019 08:28

Liberty!! I knew one growing up, she was a total character. Its a fab name, nn libby

Original poster
Lumay · 27/07/2019 14:51

Thank you all so much for your opinions and being honest! I am really struggling to find a girls name to go with Esmé, that is both pretty but also unique! We like Amelia and Olivia also but feel they’re a bit too common but i agree my worries are with Elodie it is too similar and Liberty is too different! Hmmm back to the drawing board I think any more suggestions welcome Smilexxx

OP posts: