If we like Seth...

[parsnipsbuttered]

DH and I have had a girl's name picked out for months, but if this one turns out to be a boy, we're a bit stumped.
We both tend to like strong, simple, timeless (possibly biblical) names like Seth, Jude, Finn, Sam(uel), but can't seem to agree on just one.
Can you suggest any other boy's names that we might like along those lines?
Family middle name has already been chosen and surname is a very common one-syllable British name.

Quinn
Otis

I’m thinking surname like lee?

Usually a shorter surname goes better with a longer surname.

All your names sound great! I love Samuel.

Jonah
Isaac
Nathan
Jeremiah
Caleb
Elijah
Gabriel

Flynn
Nate/ Nathaniel
Eli/ Elijah
Asa/ Asher
Jude
Isaac
Ethan
Ezra

Thanks all, some lovely suggestions.
Our surname seems to work with both long and short names so don't think that needs to be too much of a consideration.
Other possible contenders include Dylan, Sol, Elis, Gabe but not one is really standing out.
Keep firing ideas at me. The perfect name is out there somewhere!

Jed (Jedidiah)
Abe (Abraham)
Jacob

Saul
Silas
Miles
Issac
Jed
Marlowe
Wilf

Strong simple classic possibly biblical but not commonly used these days:
Mark
James
Simon
Peter
...easy to spell and instantly recognizable and yet none are in top 100 for 2017.

Gah!
I meant John, not James (too many!)

Micah
Flynn
Nate
Art
Ephraim
Leo
Moe

Zach
Zeke

Joel

Seth is a great name, it’s a shame whichever one of you doesn’t like it!

Tom (not Thomas)

Thomas would most likely be the middle name

Jabez?

Amos
Eli
Caleb
Saul
Jonah
Isaac

Brett
Seb
Toby
Noah
Jake
Blake
Jett

Thanks for all these ideas. Our long list is getting longer!
Names that we like but already used by close friends and family include Alfie, Noah, Barney, Ethan, Jacob, Ezra.
Looks like we're leaning towards classic names but with a bit of a contemporary feel.
I like Jed, and also Seb or Jem but think they work better as nicknames, and I'm not keen on the longer full names for them.
Keep these great suggestions coming!

Marcus
Raphael
Tobias (Toby)
Lucas
Reuben
Monty
Zac/Zachary
Elliot
Max/Maxwell
Keir

Josiah

Cain. Aaron. Caleb. Luke. Jonah. Noah. Gabriel. Mark. Elijah. Saul
Zachariah. Moses

I like simple, strong, timeless names too and think all of the ones you've mentioned are great.

Our son is 2 now. Our shortlist (not in any particular order) was:
Elan
Jake
Laurie
Saul
Seth
Evan
Moss
Jory
Casey
Dylan
Jody

It took us forever to choose and we didn't settle on a name til he was about 3 weeks old (some family members found the wait intolerable!!)

We ended up using one of the list above and we have absolutely no regrets. Good luck!

Adam

Tobias?