Which ones are good?

[BlueCheese23]

Polly
Poppy
Ella
Isadora
Ruby
Matilda
Candy
Amelie
Frieda
Scarlett

I only like Scarlett

Do not name your child Candy!!!!
The rest are fine.

Amelie.
Polly is ok but I feel like it should be short for something.

I really like: Polly, Ruby, Matilda and Scarlett. The only ones I dislike are Candy and Frieda.

I like Poppy and Ruby.

I like Matilda & Ruby.

I dislike Poppy, Candy & Frieda.

Matilda and Amelie are both nice. I LOVE Frida but not so much with the 'e' in as it turns it into "fried-a" in my head! Candy is awful, please don't use that!

Most are lovely. Candy is awful. Sounds like a stripper. Frieda looks ok written down but I think it sounds a bit of an old lady's name when said aloud. Reminds me of Bert's wife in The Archers.

They are all fine except Candy, which makes me think of the old man in Of Mice and Men.

They are all lovely apart from Candy

Agree with pp's on Candy unless it nn for Candace (and even then ).

Frieda

Thanks guys, so far! I think I'm just going to wait for more reply's!

Love Isadora and Matilda. Polly, Poppy and Ruby are fine. Really dislike Scarlett.

Polly - cutesy, but OK. It's a diminutive of Mary.
Poppy - I like this - nice flower.
Ella - bit bland.
Isadora - OK-ish, but a bit frilly.
Ruby - really like.
Matilda - OK.
Candy - no.
Amelie - no. Twee.
Frieda - yes. Similar vibe to Matilda but more unusual.
Scarlett - OK-ish, but I'm not wild.

Polly - like
Poppy - like
Ella - ok
Isadora - don't like
Ruby - ok
Matilda - ok
Candy - don't like. Cindy is nicer
Amelie - don't like
Frieda -don't like
Scarlett- ok

I like Ruby but DGD1 is Ruby so I'm a bit biased, however from your list I also like Polly, Poppy, Matilda, Amelie and Scarlett.

Please don't call her Candy

I like Ruby and Scarlett best from your list

Poppy Freida Matilda.

I like:

Ella
Isadora
Matilda
Amelie

Polly - Bit dated but fine
Poppy - It’s ok, very popular!
Ella - Nice, although I’d prefer Elle
Isadora - Interesting, quite unusual
Ruby - Ok
Matilda - Really like this and nn Tilly
Candy - This is the only bad one on this list to my mind
Amelie - Nice
Frieda - Very nice, not very popular
Scarlett - I do like it but it’s a bit of a guilty pleasure for me

Overall my favourites are Ella, Matilda and Frieda

Scarlett
Isadora
Poppy
In that order

Isadora and Matilda.

I like Freda but not Frieda. Also maybe consider Freya?

Matilda
Amelie

Twee, cutesy, childish, not good = Polly, Poppy, Candy

Ok = Ella, Scarlett, Amelie

Nice = Frieda, Isadora, Ruby, Matilda