Please help. Can't choose baby girl name.

[Giraffe14]

Please help. Only a week to go until our baby girl arrives and we aren't settled on a name yet!

We have either

Hadley Evelyn
Or
Hallie Evelyn

i have just had a little girl and name her Evelyn her middle name is Jane
Other names we liked for her were

Alice
Grace
Jasmine
Lilly
Esme
Ella

Hadley is lovely. I always had a yearning for Elodie.

I've never heard Hallie, so I'd go for Hadley probably. Evelyn is a fave of mine, lovely. I've always liked Hattie but couldn't use it.

Thank you. We love Evelyn but like more unusual first names

Where are you all from if you don't mind me asking?

I'm the opposite. I have never heard of Hadley as a girl's name but have heard of Hallie. I think it's pretty. I would think of Hadley more as a boy's name (I live in the SE).

Hadley.

Like Hadley Hemingway.

Have only heard Halle (without the i), as in Halle Berry. There is an actor (male) called Hadley Fraser, so people might think your DD is a boy. It also reminds me of Tony Hadley (Spandau B). But it is your choice in the end, go with what you feel.

Hadley

Hallie makes me think of halitosis

I prefer Hallie from your choices

Hallie is lovely

I don't love either. What about Hetty?

Hallie can be mispronounced - I teach a few and they are variously "H-alley' 'Harley'. 'Holly' and Hayley.

I like Hadley. Not Evelyn as first name though there are millions of them

Hadley just makes me think of Tony.

Hallie is lovely! A bit like Ellie but with a twist making it more unusual but not too out there.

I love Hadley. Young people won't know who Tony Hadley is

Not keen on either to be honest. Would take Hallie over Hadley though, sounds very male and like the make of a bike or something. But then I like quite flowery, -ia/ -a names for a girl.

I think I slightly prefer the flow of Hallie Evelyn. Just a thought though - are you pronouncing it EEvlyn or EHvlyn (French style). With a first name ending in an ee sound I would be inclined to use EHvlyn as it's easier on the tongue.

Neither Hadley nor Hallie are nice. They're both very 'of the moment'. Hallie sounds slightly made up, tbh, and Hadley very masculine/surnamey. Sorry.

Evelyn is nice. Could that be her first name?

Hallie is nicer than Hadley. I have a 2 year old cousin named Hallie.

Hadley (Heather fields: lovely association. Hemingway's wife also).

Hallie is gorgeous