Dylan or Edward??? :)

[TimeLoop]

Middle name is John. We are registering him soon, so really need this decided!!!

Two very different names.... Edward gets my vote.

Are they? In what way? :)

I have a Dylan so I'm obviously going to say that! More options for nicknames with Edward though if that's important to you.

Definitely Dylan, I have one too. 😄

I prefer Edward. Congrats!

I think they're really different too.

Dylan for me.

Gosh that's a tough one! Both are lovely names! I'm going to say Dylan because i have a gorgeous nephew called Dylan. But I do love all the nickname options for Edward!

Out of the 2 I would say Dylan but I also love the nn Ned for Edward.

I agree that they're really different. If you have any Welsh connections, I'd choose Dylan. If not, Edward.

Dylan.

Dylan Edward John surname sounds great

Very different names. I would go for Edward

I like both! Would go with Edward though

I love them both, they're both on my list. But, in your case I'd choose Dylan, purely for the fact that 'JEDWARD' are John and Edward.

Edward, by a mile. Really contrasting choices which is unusual on here.

Edward is one of my all time favourite boy names, so I'd definitely go for that.

I'm not mad about Dylan.

Edward - classic, sophisticated and timeless.

Dylan for me.

Definitely Edward.

Both are nice. But really like nn Eddie

Dylan is a fave name for me

Dylan John could be DJ!

Edward... although I may be biased

Dylan for me but I am biased. Edward is inoffensive though. For me Edward is traditional, solid, maybe slightly unadventurous. Dylan used to be a bit more unusual (outside of Wales) not so much these days but round here comes across as a bit more modern/non traditional

I agree with those who say Edward and all
It's diminutives are traditional, solid. Dylan as well as very Welsh is modern. Depends what you want to connote.