First thoughts on whether these are boys or girls?

[CocoPorridge]

If you heard the following names but didn't see the child/know any other details, would you assume they were boys or girls? You haven't seen the names written down so spellings make no difference.

Frankie
Ronnie
Charlie
Sidney/Sydney
Morgan
Riley
Jordan
Ashley
Aubrey
Addison
Emerson
Mackenzie
Phoenix
Brodie
Brogan

Frankie - Boy first, though I do know a baby girl named Frankie
Ronnie - Boy, though I do know a woman called Ronee
Charlie - Boy though could be nn for Charlotte
Sidney/Sydney - Boy definitely
Morgan - Boy
Riley - Boy definitely
Jordan - Boy
Ashley - Boy
Aubrey - Boy
Addison - Girl
Emerson - Boy definitely
Mackenzie - Boy
Phoenix - Either
Brodie - Boy
Brogan - Boy definitely

All of those names shout "BOY" to me, except Morgan , Ashley and Phoenix, which I'd class as truly unisex.

I'd consider all to be unisex names (maybe with the exception of Riley and Brogan), but my first impression on hearing the name would be...

Boys: Ronnie, Charlie, Riley, Jordan, Ashley, Emerson, Phoenix, Brodie, Brogan

Girls: Frankie, Sydney, Morgan, Aubrey, Addison, Mackenzie

Girls:
Frankie
Ronnie
Sidney/Sydney
Morgan
Riley
Ashley
Addison
Emerson
Mackenzie

Boys
Charlie
Aubrey
Phoenix
Brodie
Brogan

Logic: in my experience people use "unisex" names for girls more than for boys, because patriarchy: there is nothing in the world worse than having someone think your son is a girl.

Frankie Boy
Ronnie Boy
Charlie Boy
Sidney/Sydney Boy
Morgan Boy
Riley Girl
Jordan Boy
Ashley Boy
Aubrey Girl
Addison Girl
Emerson Boy
Mackenzie Girl
Phoenix Boy
Brodie Boy
Brogan Girl

Having not read previous answers I would say:

Could be either:
Frankie
Ashley
Phoenix

Girls:
Sydney
Mackenzie
Brodie

Boys:
Ronnie
Charlie
Sidney
Morgan
Riley
Jordan
Aubrey
Addison
Emerson
Brogan

Frankie - Girl
Ronnie - Boy
Charlie - Boy
Sidney/Sydney - Boy
Morgan - Boy
Riley - Boy
Jordan - Boy
Ashley - Girl
Aubrey - Girl
Addison - Girl
Emerson - Boy
Mackenzie - Boy
Phoenix - Boy
Brodie - Boy
Brogan - Girl

My answers are based on kids I know with those names. Except Emerson, never heard of it but it makes me think of Emmet and Elmer both of which I think to be male.

Frankie - boy
Ronnie - boy
Charlie - boy
Sidney/Sydney - girl
Morgan - girl
Riley - boy
Jordan - boy
Ashley - girl
Aubrey - girl
Addison - girl
Emerson - girl
Mackenzie - boy
Phoenix - boy
Brodie - boy
Brogan - boy

Now I've read the thread I was amazed how many people think Aubrey is a girls name. Then I googled. Looks like the Americans are up to their usual tricks using traditional male names for girls.

this is Aubrey

and

this

Frankie - boy
Ronnie - boy
Charlie - boy
Sidney/Sydney - probably girl
Morgan - 50/50
Riley - 50/50
Jordan - boy
Ashley - girl
Aubrey - girl
Addison- girl
Emerson - girl
Mackenzie - girl
Phoenix - 50/50
Brodie - boy
Brogan - boy

Frankie b
Ronnie b
Charlie b
Sidney/Sydney b
Morgan b
Riley either
Jordan b
Ashley b
Aubrey b
Addison b
Emerson b
Mackenzie b (But we know a g)
Phoenix either
Brodie b
Brogan b

All boys, although I have known girls called Morgan and Sydney, Frankie, Charlie, Ashley and Jordan.

I only thought Aubrey was a girl because of teen mom

Ewan the Aubreys I know/know of are a drag queen, four year old girl a female cat and one of the Moms from teen mom has a daughter called Aubrey.

I have a friend who has a little girl called Aubree

I consider them all to be boys' names - my dad's name and a friend's son's name are in there - but, if I heard that somebody had recently given one of those names to a baby, I'd probably assume it was a girl and the parents were jumping on the celebrities naming their daughter James bandwagon.

All boys except for Frankie and Ashley. I don't like any of them but I'm aware that'd not what you're asking!

They're all originally boys' names but I have known girls called Frankie (Francesca), Ronnie (Veronica), Charlie (Charlotte) and Morgan. I know of girls called Jordan and Mackenzie but have never met any.

Frankie - girl (might be because I know one)
Ronnie - boy
Charlie - boy
Sidney/Sydney - first spelling boy, second spelling girl
Morgan - girl
Riley - don't know!
Jordan - don't know! Genuinely unisex I think
Ashley - boy
Aubrey - boy
Addison - boy
Emerson - boy
Mackenzie - girl
Phoenix - boy
Brodie - boy
Brogan - girl

Ashley, Addison, McKenzie and Brogan are all girls to me.

The rest are really boyish and I'd be surprised to come across a girl called it.

I have a strong aversion to girls being called names ending in 'son'. It just seems wrong to me!

Frankie - Girl
Ronnie - Boy
Charlie - Boy
Sidney/Sydney - Boy
Morgan - Girl
Riley - Either, more likely girl
Jordan - Boy
Ashley - Girl
Aubrey - Girl
Addison - Girl
Emerson - Boy
Mackenzie - Either, more likely Boy
Phoenix - Boy
Brodie - Boy
Brogan - Girl

Frankie - Either
Ronnie - Boy
Charlie - Either
Sidney/Sydney - Girl (though my grandad was Sydney)

Morgan - Girl
Riley - Boy
Jordan - Either but leaning more towards boy.
Ashley - Either
Aubrey - Boy
Addison - ?
Emerson - Boy
Mackenzie - Either (know one girl & one boy)
Phoenix - Boy
Brodie - Girl ( but know a boy)
Brogan - Girl

All going by personal experiences I guess!