Isabelle or Katelynn?

[Cosmic1988]

We are from Arizona.

Love both Isabelle and Katelynn

Which do you prefer?

Katelynn

Hate Izzy as a NN and it is way too common.

Katelynn sounds lovely, has lovely NNs and is not as common

Thank you. I love the way Katelynn sounds! Really dislike the Caitlin/Katelyn pronunciation (something like Kat-eh-lynn) which I know is really bad!

Caitlin is pronounced slightly differently in Ireland, but I know several Caitlins with no Irish roots who pronounce their name Kate-lin.

Katelynn.

I prefer Isabelle.

Isabelle

Isabelle by about billion times. Although Isobel is a way nicer.

Isabelle

Isabelle. Can't stand made-up names.

Both are nice but I agree that Isabel//Isabelle/Isabella is a bit dull due to overuse.

Every name was made up at some point

Katelynn is horrid!

I would pronounce Caitlin and Katelynn the same way but I have an Irish accent.

I like both, but slightly prefer Isabelle.

I like Caitlin (pronounced exactly the same way as Katelynn) but not Katelynn as it's made up. Isabelle is also nice. I'd go for Caitlin but if you won't spell it the normal way then Isabelle.

I'm biased towards Caitlin as it's DD1's middle name

We're Scottish and pronounce it Katelynn

Caitlin and Katelynn may be pronounced the same, but if you were keen on the nickname Kate then Katelyn works better imo.

Prefer Isobel to Isabelle and Caitlin to Katelynn - and out of the two, Caitlin.

Isabelle. (Caitlin second)

Isabelle. Belle as a nn is really sweet.
I personally don't like Katelynn

Isabelle.

Isobel. classic and beautiful. Katelynn looks as though you didn't know how to spell Caitlin.

Isabelle is lovely
Katelynn is Caitlin spelt badly as pp says
Caitlin is a lovely name though

In all fairness, Katelynn isn't Caitlin spelt differently.

Caitlin is a full name said completely differently and Katelynn is Kate and Lynn together to form a name said a different way.

Isabelle.
Sorry strongly dislike Katelynn.