Love a perspective on these girls' names

[TheFinale]

Jemima
Tabitha
Martha
Eliza
Lydia

These are the ones I love. All of them! What do you think?

I like Eliza.

The rest, not so much. Lydia is okay I guess.

Exactly what chinlo said!

I like Eliza and Martha (my DD's name is similar to this) IMO the others are a bit "horsey" Sorry

Eliza is lovely, Martha or Lydia at a push, no to the others!

I like Eliza. Not so keen on the others I'm afraid.

I love Tabitha, Martha and Lydia, but all of them are nice names :)

I like Eliza, Lydia and Martha best. And Jemima least.

I love Jemima, Tabitha and Lydia. Have considered all three in the past for my DC.

I really like all of them! We must have similar taste op.

Favourites are Martha and Jemima. Least favourite is Tabitha.

In this order,
Love Jemima (Jem).
Tabitha
Martha
Eliza
Don't like Lydia.

Love Tabitha. And really like Martha.

Eliza! Not mad keen on the others.

I like them all except Martha.

Like Martha and Lydia

I don't like Martha or Eliza. I like Tabitha, Jemima and Lydia in that order.

Tabitha always sounds like a cats name to me (DM wanted to call me Tabitha but DF refused as he's had a cat with that name! must thank him for that one day)

My DSis is a Jemima so I'm biased towards that name

I like Eliza and Lydia.

Martha is average.

Jemima Puddleduck. Tabitha Twitchett. did you not read Beatrix Potter?!

I like Martha and Lydia. Lydia is a lovely name.

I only like Eliza.

I love Jemima and the only thing holding me back is I don't like Jem and I bet that would be the most used nn?!
But we do have similar tastes, I also considered Martha and Eliza. Not sure on Tabitha and Lydia is pretty.

I am so old, I think of Jemima from PlaySchool, I just don't think it's a pretty name.

Out of all of these, I would pick Tabitha myself.

Martha- I know one, it's not for me, tbh.

I really like Lydia, but none of the others I'm afraid!

Jemima - rag doll, Puddleduck,
Tabitha - cat/kitten
Martha - the moaner in 'Martha and Mary' story in the Bible.
Eliza - sly
Lydia - Chlymydia

I'm really sorry, they are all actually lovely names but you did ask. I have known girls with all these names and they were all jolly pleasant people.

I don't like Alice either because it rhymes with malice, although I know it's a very nice name and once again I've known nice ones ( although not the horrid Alice at school who challenged me to a fight! But I digress....

Tabitha is the nicest, I knew a very cool one once and I never think of it as a cat's name.
Don't like the others, I'm afraid, especially Martha.

Eliza is nice, not keen on the rest, especially Jemima which I think is awful (sorry). Tabitha is a cat name and Martha is very plain. Lydia is ok.