Vintage feeling girls names

[Papyrus]

It seems like only last week I was here trying to name DC4, and you all had some amazing suggestions!

I am 33 weeks with DC5.

We have a DS and three DDs.

If a boy DC will probably be Ivan Stanley or George Stanley.

This baby was extremely unplanned - youngest is not quite 12 months, and we seem to have run out of girls names.

Possibilities include
Mabel (on shortlist when DD3 was born last year)
Imogen
Grace

All ideas welcome. DH and I must be the most indecisive people on the planet, and need all the help we can get!

Go for Violet- who is going to know/care that it was 'used' before?

I love Henry!

Ooo I love Mabel, also love Grace (dd2 second name) sorry I don't like Imogen. I also really like Agnes and think either.Mabel Agnes or Mabel Grace would b lovely.

I LOVE Mabel lots. DH vetoed on my list!!
What about Emmy/Emmie?
Florence
Lucinda
Cassie
Flora

My gorgeous six week DD is Daphne. Something different but not unknown and almost everyone does a double take and tells us it's a beautiful name. We also loved Violet though.

I know a 6 year old Mabel and I think it is a great name. I love your boy's choice too, Ivan Stanley. Great names.

I think Ida will become the new Ava (whoever suggested Ida)

Verity and Constance are lovely too. I wish I'd called my DD1 Verity.

Pearl. Just Pearl love it, one of my kids middle names

Elsie
Edith
Bertha
Gladys

DD2 came home from nursery today insisting we call new baby Clara, after new best friend. Pointed out that she already had a sister called Clara, to which she said 'they can share'

So what are your thoughts on Clara1 and Clara2?

Tess? Abigail?

Isadora again? :o I really really love that one...

Bethan?

I love Isadora too Yank. Do you think I could get away with it, already having a Clara?

Oh definitely. And it has such great nn potential..Isa, Dora, Ida, Sadie...so beautiful!

I love Rosemary.

If you love Isadora, how about Theodora (or Dorothea)?

Myrtle
Polly
Lucy
Agatha
Betty
Jill
Janet
Susan
Mary

I think with your existing girls' names (all lovely btw) I would go for Martha, Sally, Nellie, Nancy or Mabel.

Oooh yes, Mary is lovely and I don't know why nobody uses it!

Bronte

I like Imogen from your choices

Iris, Margot or Honor are all lovely too.

Right with much discussion with DH last night and pouring over this thread. This is our new shortlist.

Boy: George Stanley/Ivan Stanley - probably going to go with George.

Girl:
Mabel Agnes - still possibly my favourite
Grace Agnes
Isadora Agnes
Rosalind Agnes
Mary Agnes - DH's choice, I'm not sure
Clemency Agnes - If it was down to me I'd name a DD Clemency like a shot. But DH refuses to consider it.

Thanks for all your suggestions so far, its been really helpful

God our shortlist has got longer than in the OP. We're supposed to be narrowing down!!!!!

Rosalind Mary

Oooh, all lovely. I say George for a boy. :)

Mabel, Isadora, Mary, Rosalind and Clemency are ALL fabulous. Sorry, I'm of no help!