I'm not keen on most "in/faddy" names and also nicknamey/cutesy/surnamey/hyphenated names. Also there seem to be a lot of "sameish" girls names around....Lilly, Tilly, Milly, Molly, Holly, Polly etc.. Ava, Eva, Evie, Emily, Amy, Amelia, Emilia, Amelie, Annabel, Isobel, Arabella/Isabella/Annabella/Ella/Bella/Elle/Ellie which, although pretty kind of blend into one...
It seems to be increasingly fashionable to find an unusual name which I find a little pretentious and possibly unfair for the child (particularly boys as for some reason I think girls can carry slightly more unusual names..). I understand if people genuinely like a certain name which happens to be unusual but find it odd that people seem very anti certain names just because of popularity (as if a reflection on them) even if they love a certain name...Go with the name you love whether it's popular or unusual!
Personally I like classic, timeless, "stand-alone" names such as Oliver, William, Benjamin, Charlotte etc...many mumsnetters seem to be anti such names due to their popularity. IMO you should choose your favourite name whether popular or not otherwise you might regret it especially when in a few years time different names are Top 10 etc...
Anyway we all have different tastes and opinions and I have been labelled a conformist on this website for my choice!