School is forced to drop Halal Christmas meal plan
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
« Previous
« Previous
Next »
Next »
View Gallery
Published Date:
18 November 2006
By Paul Whitehouse
A HEAD teacher who planned to serve only Halal chicken at her school's Christmas lunch has backed down after a protest from parents which attracted the backing of an MP.
Twenty per cent of pupils at Oakwood Comprehensive in Rotherham, South Yorkshire, are British Asians and head teacher Jan Charters said the idea had been intended to extend a spirit of inclusion throughout the school.
Under her plan pupils would hav
ADVERTISEMENT
e had the option of a sausage rolled in bacon served with the chicken, but parents objected to the scheme claiming it would undermine the traditional British Christmas.
They were backed by Labour MP Denis MacShane who said no child should be asked to eat food which did not match their convictions and called on the school to offer a choice on the festive menu.
His request has been accepted and children will now be able to order turkey and a vegetarian option in addition to chicken slaughtered following the Muslim Halal principle as part of the £1.75 meal.
Dr MacShane said: "No child should be obliged to eat food that is contrary to their personal convictions or religion.
"Schools should offer a choice and not allow the joyous celebrations of a Christmas dinner to become a divisive issue."
The head teacher explained the situation by saying: "This was an attempt to extend the spirit of inclusion which would allow Muslim children to sit down and enjoy a meal together.
"It is very frustrating that people find motives which are not present and we will not now be doing this."
The Halal method of slaughter is decreed by Muslim law but is controversial because it is performed with a single cut to the throat, which has been criticised as inhumane by independent advisory group The Farm Animal Welfare Council.
They have called for that slaughter method to be banned on the grounds it can cause severe suffering to animals.
However, the school's food suppliers insisted the technique was humane.
Ms Charters added: "The way in which the catering company works, and I believe it is the case in other schools, is that quite extensive amounts of meat will be Halal.
"We secured assurances that the slaughterhouse we were dealing with was correctly certified to be killing humanely and all animals were stunned
"When we discussed the Christmas dinner we said that there was nothing to stop anyone from eating the main course because it was Halal although the Muslim pupils will not eat the sausage and bacon rolls.
"Chicken is chicken as far as I am concerned but there will also be other choices on the menu apart from a Christmas meal," she said.
Parent Rachel Johnson, from Kimberworth, who has two daughters at the school, said: "This is not a racial issue. Why can't the non- Muslim kids enjoy traditional Christmas fare?
"Why can't we have a choice of chicken which suits everyone, Muslims and non-Muslims? We bend over backwards at Eid to eat traditional Muslim food, so why should we have to change our Christmas tradition?
"This is a multi-racial, multi-religious school and should be catering for the needs of everyone not just the Muslim section."
Rotherham has 16 comprehensive schools, with 14 using in-house caterers and offering a choice between Halal and conventionally slaughtered meat.
Coun Mahroof Hussain said: "Christmas is an important time in everybody's life in Britain and we should celebrate it.
"If we are talking about food maybe we should have choice but that is a decision for the school governing body.
"I support the head teacher's aim in getting all students together at Christmas in a spirit of unity ? Muslims, Christians and people of no religion," he said.
YOUR VIEWS:
S. Blyth, Milton Keynes: "I can't see what the fuss is about. It's not as though the Muslims would object to everyone eating bacon butties to celebrate their festivals, is it?"
Stephen Jessop, Brighouse: "Neither adults or children should be forced to eat halal meat. My children were horrified when they learned how the animals were slaughtered. This aside, from a business point of view you are limiting who can supply the meat and giving certain suppliers an unfair advantage. I understand the sentiment but just as Muslims only eat halal meat others and their children should not be forced to eat it."