Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I being unreasonable about our division of labour?

83 replies

nostability · Yesterday 21:38

I’m 37F, work full-time from home and my husband is 44M. We don't have kids. He does a couple of late shifts a week alongside consultancy work.

Financially, he pays the rent, council tax, water and around 70% of our basic groceries. I pay rent for my office room, the remaining groceries, for any premium groceries for my personal use/health products/supplements, luxury toiletries, household purchases including appliances and furniture, and I usually cover most of our holidays apart from his fuel/driving costs. We keep our finances separate.

Household-wise, I do pretty much everything. I clean the house, including deep cleans and cleaning on the go, cook his dinners every day, do all the laundry and bedding and generally keep everything running. His regular household job is taking the bins out and that's about it. If he ever uses the kitchen, I have to clean up after him. Water splashes in the sink, table wipes, dusting etc - basically all cleaning on the go is my task.

The issue is that he thinks I should be doing more. He expects

  • breakfast made and served to him every day, including days while I’m working and on shift, wouldn't even make a cup of tea for himself without resenting me if I didn't do it for him
  • his clean clothes folded and put away
  • ideally his meals brought to wherever he is in the house
  • hosting his friends and family a couple of times a month which I can't, as it eats into my time to recharge for work

He also wants more say over what I cook, would like me to host his friends and family more often and is unhappy that I don’t spend much time with some of his family because of a difficult history between us. He wants me to be the bigger person and forgive - I can not after repeated and ongoing attempts by his mother to break my home. He wants me to increase my capacity to face toxic behaviour even though he knows my mental health is messed up because of this.

He gets annoyed when I ask him to do basic things for himself. His response when I say I don’t have the bandwidth is that I should increase my capacity to do more around the house. At the same time, he feels I should contribute towards rent and household bills. My position is that if I’m expected to contribute significantly more financially, then the domestic workload also needs to become much more equal. He doesn’t agree and has actually said that

"Doing household chores makes me feel more like a housemate than a husband" - which I think was quite telling.

The immediate argument is that I’ve told him I’m not going to interrupt my workday to make and serve him breakfast when he is capable of making it himself.

Am I being unreasonable? And from the outside, does our current split of finances + household labour seem fair?

OP posts:
EatingSky · Yesterday 21:40

This dynamic sounds abusive. You aren’t a housewife, and even if you were serving him breakfast and hosting on his day so would be unreasonable. I think you’ll find you are happier if you dump this man.

MellowSubmarine · Yesterday 21:41

Divorce this man.

takealettermsjones · Yesterday 21:41

This is a joke yes?

MidnightPatrol · Yesterday 21:41

Hahahah

You wouldn’t see me for the dust flying as I ran out the door.

fivefoottwowitheyesofblue · Yesterday 21:43

Come on. Surely you can see he's completely unreasonable.
Please leave him asap.

bozzabollix · Yesterday 21:43

Let his mum split you up, she’d be doing you a favour, he sounds like a monster.

No that division of labour absolutely takes the piss.

Thunderdcc · Yesterday 21:43

For me, fair would be:

50/50 on housework
Financial split based on earnings

Ie the two wouldn't be connected. Then if he didn't want to do his share, or he wanted a housekeeper, he could pay for someone else to do it out of his leftover money.

parietal · Yesterday 21:45

he is so utterly unreasonable and misogynistic that it is hard to believe.

start looking up divorce lawyers. get good evidence on his salary and finances because he will try to take as much as he can.

CoffeeBeansGalore · Yesterday 21:45

Send this selfish, lazy specimen back to the 1950s.

SeriouslyGotTheTshirt · Yesterday 21:48

If you need to ask whether it’s unreasonable for him to expect you to serve him breakfast, then I’m sad to say you are extremely downtrodden. This is not normal. I’m sorry but the healthiest option may be to split. For him to even ask you to serve him breakfast every day is really quite unbelievable. Who does that? I don’t think I had my breakfast made for me by anyone else beyond the age of about five!

InterestedDad37 · Yesterday 21:48

Does he want you to wipe his arse when he's had a dump? That's about all that's left!
Get rid, pronto 👍

Notthisagainyouidiot · Yesterday 21:50

I think you need to take a measured approach to this. First tell him to fuck right off, then start divorce proceedings. Or the other way round.

PepsiBook · Yesterday 21:50

Disgusting. Why are you with someone who treats you so poorly?

missymousey · Yesterday 21:51

Wtf?! Even if you weren't working and contributing financially, this would be unreasonable! When does he make and serve you breakfast?!

If you're married, you're a team. You take pleasure in doing things for each other. This is madness, he wants a servant not a spouse!

Sherararara · Yesterday 21:53

Why do people even ask these questions?

OrangeSlices998 · Yesterday 21:54

Massive ick. Why do you have to serve him? Is he a nice man, because he doesn’t sound it. I’d be getting a cleaner at a minimum and stop waiting on him and doing his laundry.

Or you can be with a man who respects you

Beer3000 · Yesterday 21:55

So many things wrong with this. Did you ever even like each other?

Why does he think you are his slave? Why aren't you paying basic bills if you are working full time?

Jimmyjumpy · Yesterday 22:06

This is a joke right?

Iloveacurry · Yesterday 22:09

He wants a maid! Has he got any redeeming qualities?

Totaldramallama · Yesterday 22:17

I voted yabu because why the fuck are you still there? You don't have kids tying you to him and you have your own finances, these are the two main reasons women find it difficult to leave shit men

Ionlymakejokestodistractmyself · Yesterday 22:27

I found it sickening reading your post.

You scurrying behind him cleaning up his mess as he swans about, doing all the laundry and cleaning and making him cups of tea, meanwhile him utterly resenting you for not doing more.

nostability · Yesterday 23:07

Beer3000 · Yesterday 21:55

So many things wrong with this. Did you ever even like each other?

Why does he think you are his slave? Why aren't you paying basic bills if you are working full time?

I was contributing towards bills and groceries until a year ago. I stopped because he wasn't meeting me halfway and helping with anything in the house and it felt too much for me to be doing everything in the house + contributing financially. I did propose aa 50/50 model - he won't do it. He says he won't do anything in the house, he doesn't feel like a husband if he does and feels like he is a housemate. There was no other solution to this other than me stepping away from financially contributing and also doing less frequent cooking, cleaning etc or otherwise I'd never find time for myself outside of my job.

He can be nice and caring. He would do anything I say i.e. go out and do grocery runs, go to the other part of town for something etc. He waits for me outside my one hour weekly dance class in the parking. He happily drives me around if I needed him to as I don't have a licence as of yet. He would spend a whole day out and about with me doing nothing but giving me company if I wanted to shop around (with my own money). But all those things that he does for me - I hardly ever go out. Maybe once in a couple of months. He would give me a pick and drop max once a week. So it doesn't feel fair when he expects me to do his meals twice a day, household chores etc - all that requires a lot frequent cadence and therefore time and energy as compared to what he does for me.

OP posts:
Fidgety31 · Yesterday 23:14

You do have a child - it’s him !

how can you find this man attractive ?! He sounds grim.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · Yesterday 23:22

Surely he can't have it both ways. He either wants a traditional set up, where he pays for everything and you do everything at home. Or you share financial contributions and household tasks. He seems to want the best of both worlds (for him, and the worst of both worlds for you)

However even his view of a traditional housewife is warped. My dad was born in the 40s, my mum stayed at home and he managed to eat his dinner at the table rather than be 'served' it elsewhere, clear away after himself, and make his own breakfast

roseymoira · Yesterday 23:25

This isn’t normal at all is there a cultural element?