Help protect children from gaming harms.

Take our survey

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is Putin a threat to UK ?

131 replies

HumbleStumble · Yesterday 11:22

With the CIA flying into Moscow, Russia appears to be ramping up the offensive. Is Russia a threat to the UK? Putin wants unconditional surrender from Ukraine which they will never agree to. Is Burnham right to poke the bear ?

OP posts:
TooBigForMyBoots · Yesterday 13:45

Mizzeldrizzle · Yesterday 13:44

@Judicioususeofthewordgirdle no I mean when he attacks us on our soil what can we do because apparnrly our drones would last a a few hours ?

He has already attacked us on our soil. Repeatedly.

Mizzeldrizzle · Yesterday 13:45

Omg yea I know !!
Ans still we don't prioritise our defense ?

dustabsorber · Yesterday 14:18

We have a million NEETS, we just need to arm them

PerkingFaintly · Yesterday 14:26

Why was Stephen Yaxley-Lennon aka Tommy Robinson a guest in Moscow a couple of months ago?

Along with Elon Musk's dad?

What does the Kremlin want from them?

KoiTetra · Yesterday 14:30

randomchap · Yesterday 11:28

In what way a threat? Spreading discord online through troll farms and bots, absolutely.

Asynchronous warfare such as arson and hacking, most likely

Actual out and out attacks. Not likely at all

It's still the right and moral thing to support Ukraine.

This is my view, Putin is struggling to defeat Ukraine, a country initially considered tiers below Russia.

The UK is part of Nato and there are multiple Nato countries between us and Russia, they would have to invade most of Europe first before they had any chance of reaching the UK.

While the UK standing army my be tiny Nato combined would be more than a match for Russia, Poland is itching for an excuse to show off what they can do and get some revenge for the last 200 odd years.

Is a nuclear strike possible? Yes but my view is that is a risk worth taking and if it wasn't the UK it would be somewhere else and as soon as one nuke is launched it will be all over. Everyone will launch everything and the world will be screwed.

So is some digital disruption and the occasional spy film style operation worth it? In my view yes!

risingup · Yesterday 14:32

TrunkElliot · Yesterday 11:27

Yes of course he is. You only have to look at the Salisbury poisonings of 2018 to see that.

Exactly. He released a biological agent on british soil. He's been a threat for a very long time.

HRTQueen · Yesterday 14:38

Of course he is and always has been he is a very dangerous man who does as he wants

What other leader of a country has ordered people to be poisoned in the UK, the cases could have been far far worse

TooBigForMyBoots · Yesterday 14:41

PerkingFaintly · Yesterday 14:26

Why was Stephen Yaxley-Lennon aka Tommy Robinson a guest in Moscow a couple of months ago?

Along with Elon Musk's dad?

What does the Kremlin want from them?

He was chilling with Russian Neo Nazi group, Brotherhood of Academists.

TR is another fucking traitor.

Pedallleur · Yesterday 14:41

TrunkElliot · Yesterday 11:27

Yes of course he is. You only have to look at the Salisbury poisonings of 2018 to see that.

Arguably Russia has always been an enemy. Started after WW2 and Russia wanted to expand it's Communist ideology. That's never gone away but now it's about wider borders and making money.

olivepicanto · Yesterday 14:42

Poke the bear, OP?

why should we pussyfoot around that monster?

Zuve · Yesterday 14:42

Putin should be playing with the grandkids at his age. He should be in the garden growing pretty roses. Aristotle once said 'those that would be great the God's make mad'.

Pedallleur · Yesterday 14:43

PerkingFaintly · Yesterday 14:26

Why was Stephen Yaxley-Lennon aka Tommy Robinson a guest in Moscow a couple of months ago?

Along with Elon Musk's dad?

What does the Kremlin want from them?

What do those characters want from the Kremlin? Money, power, disruption.

HRTQueen · Yesterday 14:44

We also have to consider the cyber threat

this is constant its not from the west its from Russia and China

Government's ignored the very obvious danger that he was for years, and cheap oil and gas kept us on his side. He took a step too far and its suddenly noticed how dangerous he is 🙄

same old story again and again throughout history

Maray1967 · Yesterday 14:46

LejlaKapovic · Yesterday 11:42

USA and Israel are significantly bigger threats to the entire world.

I’m rolling around on the floor laughing Surely no one can be this stupid?

olivepicanto · Yesterday 14:46

EmeraldShamrock000 · Yesterday 11:40

As long as the UK is supporting Ukraine, supplying weapons to kill Russian people then I’d say yes.of course they will retaliate, I am surprise they haven’t by now.
The CIA was not trustworthy in my option. They push the narrative too on behalf of political powerful parties.
Keep in mind that while the war continues elections don’t.

Retaliate is such a strange word to use.

HRTQueen · Yesterday 14:55

Maray1967 · Yesterday 14:46

I’m rolling around on the floor laughing Surely no one can be this stupid?

Oh yes they can be

Some also suspect the terrible US/west influence being behind the Iranian people protesting against the regime that they have to live under

that is how thick they are

olivepicanto · Yesterday 15:01

Mizzeldrizzle · Yesterday 13:45

Omg yea I know !!
Ans still we don't prioritise our defense ?

Edited

I think WW3 will not be physical.

I also think he has been attacking us for years. We're already at war

RafaistheKingofClay · Yesterday 15:07

dustabsorber · Yesterday 14:18

We have a million NEETS, we just need to arm them

😂 although I think it is highly unlikely we are going to find ourselves in boots on the ground sort of warfare against Russia in the immediate future. Cyber attacks and possibly drones. Even the latter might be a bit of a stretch in the immediate future. I don’t think he’s quite insane enough to invoke NATO yet.

ACynicalDad · Yesterday 15:07

Yes, I doubt he will drop a nuke but cyber attacks are very likely.

Mizzeldrizzle · Yesterday 15:13

@olivepicanto well our drone supply would last a few hours apparently.

TopPocketFind · Yesterday 15:14

There was a cyber-attack on 3 UK airports today

Not saying it was Russia, could well have been Iran or someone else.

LeaderBee · Yesterday 15:19

Putin is of course a threat to the UK, but since Ukraine is not part of NATO we have a buffer zone between the east and west, this is one of the many reasons we have not granted them NATO status, despite several attempts; Had we allowed them in then the treaty would require the rest of the NATO states to offer assistance to another member state and therefore be drawn into a war with Russia.

Politically, as it stands, we can provide certain assitance to Ukraine via medical and food supplies (i'm not sure about how military hardware works but it seems we've provided drones already?) without being direct agressors to Putin, which would cause us a load of problems.

The west is technologically superior, however, Russia, and Putins real advantage is manpower. Russia has an approximate area of 6.6 million square miles and a population of approximately 146 million, less than half of the population of the US, granted, but far more willing to conscript people.

Wibble128 · Yesterday 15:24

We are Russia's raditional enemy, We stopped their expansion Eastward when they threatened to invade India. Think of Kipling and the stories of the Great Game, read, Peter Hopkirk The Great Game on Service in High Asia etc. We have not been forgiven for our success in preventing that. In their news reports we are regularly the credited as being the root of successful military actions against them, even now in Ukraine. We live rent free in Moscows heads. They have and will attack. But the method will assymetric and deniable by employing the useful idits we have fostered and tolerated within our own shores. The Coal Miners and other trade unions tried it in the second word war until we became allied with Russia against Germany, they then turned on a dime. The next series of attacks will be more deniable, or by destroying the economy by severing under seas communications and pwer cables / gas lines.

EasternStandard · Yesterday 15:25

LeaderBee · Yesterday 15:19

Putin is of course a threat to the UK, but since Ukraine is not part of NATO we have a buffer zone between the east and west, this is one of the many reasons we have not granted them NATO status, despite several attempts; Had we allowed them in then the treaty would require the rest of the NATO states to offer assistance to another member state and therefore be drawn into a war with Russia.

Politically, as it stands, we can provide certain assitance to Ukraine via medical and food supplies (i'm not sure about how military hardware works but it seems we've provided drones already?) without being direct agressors to Putin, which would cause us a load of problems.

The west is technologically superior, however, Russia, and Putins real advantage is manpower. Russia has an approximate area of 6.6 million square miles and a population of approximately 146 million, less than half of the population of the US, granted, but far more willing to conscript people.

It is sad to still see the huge number of deaths to conscripts. I doubt they have much choice. It’s awful for Ukraine who don’t and didn’t deserve the attack, but also for young Russian men that are put into drone wars.

IonianNerveGrip · Yesterday 15:59

olivepicanto · Yesterday 14:46

Retaliate is such a strange word to use.

Isn't it.