Help protect children from gaming harms.

Take our survey

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Job market is awful

356 replies

Flowerpowerz · 03/08/2026 19:34

I work in pharma (general field) and the job market is horrendous. I’m seeing a huge trend towards AI which is not surprising. Perhaps more concerning is the massive uptick of offshore partners aka shipping work out to India because they are cheaper than people in the uk and USA. I have several friends in several related companies (technology, IT, coding) that have lost jobs due to this. They are being expected to share knowledge with their Indian colleagues before their redundancy kicks in.

I have honestly never known it so bad. My linked in is a sea of “open to work”

is it just me or has anyone else noticed these trends? It’s worse than ever

OP posts:
Bathroomphilosopher · 04/08/2026 15:26

SadiraOfTyr · 04/08/2026 14:43

Yeah - that's not UBI. As soon as you start giving top-ups for housing, children etc it's no longer UBI - it's just UC. The idea is to give a very basic standard of living (similar to state pension) for everyone so that those who cannot (or will not) work, at least are not destitute. Because it isn't means tested (everyone over the age of 18 gets it) it removes a huge administrative cost. And it also removes complexity in the tax system as in most proposals it comes with flat rate income tax.

But given that housing costs are so high, and it needs to support families as well as individuals, it would need to be quite a lot of money to meet a basic standand of living. That everyone would get. I don't see how it could work.

StandingDeskDisco · 04/08/2026 15:29

SadiraOfTyr · 04/08/2026 14:43

Yeah - that's not UBI. As soon as you start giving top-ups for housing, children etc it's no longer UBI - it's just UC. The idea is to give a very basic standard of living (similar to state pension) for everyone so that those who cannot (or will not) work, at least are not destitute. Because it isn't means tested (everyone over the age of 18 gets it) it removes a huge administrative cost. And it also removes complexity in the tax system as in most proposals it comes with flat rate income tax.

There is no way a UBI could cover rent.
The only possible way to introduce UBI would be to make it a very basic standard (as you say), i.e. each adult would get the current single person's adult rate of Universal Credit - because according to logic that is currently considered enough to meet an adult's needs.
But it is not enough to afford rent or children, so there are separate payments for these. Ideally there would be no private rental sector to speak of, everyone would be offered LA or HA social housing to rent, and UBI would cover this rent so no need for separate HB, but we don't live in such a world.

There is no logical reason that UBI has to go hand-in-hand with a flat rate of income tax. That just benefits those who have high incomes. If anything, there would need to be more income tax bands at the higher levels to pay for UBI

StandingDeskDisco · 04/08/2026 15:32

Digerydont · 04/08/2026 15:04

Why would anyone get a job, given how stressful the world of work is? Who would do jobs like nurses, doctors, fire brigade, police, army etc. Who would get up at 5 to start work at 6 as an emergency worker?

Anyone who wants to have more that just basic UBI to live on.
Obviously.

XenoBitch · 04/08/2026 15:32

amala18 · 04/08/2026 14:56

Everywhere.

Just looking at Ireland for example. Ireland has 163,000 empty houses.

The U.K has 700,000 empty houses.

People should also be encouraged to buy cheaper static mobile homes or alternative ways of living like van life. (convert and sleep in a van)

People are constantly being told that they must get huge mortgages/pay huge rent - to get everyone under pressure

Edited

Haha, no.
Living in a van would be like those Chinese coffin apartments to me.
Home should be somewhere you can stretch out and relax... not just a literal bed space with a bit extra for your belongings.

Stayinganontoday · 04/08/2026 15:33

Digerydont · 04/08/2026 15:04

Why would anyone get a job, given how stressful the world of work is? Who would do jobs like nurses, doctors, fire brigade, police, army etc. Who would get up at 5 to start work at 6 as an emergency worker?

I would always have a job, regardless of universal income

Bathroomphilosopher · 04/08/2026 15:34

amala18 · 04/08/2026 15:17

The people on Planet Earth.

The current Government control systems were formed when men were in power.

We need to get more women in power - to get a better balance for people on the planet. Women are naturally more empathetic as we have the ability to sustain another body in our bodies.

When it is mainly men in power - we get lack of empathy, cruelty and destruction in the world

We eventually need to have a system where more power is in each person,not just in a few people in government who then misuse the power - but it will take time

Young women in the UK, as a group, are disproportionately likely to hold views which, imho, are incredibly destructive to women and society, they are highly intolerant of difference, which subsume individual thinking into group orthodoxy with punishment of dissenters. I am dreading these young women gaining power if they maintain these views. All polls show they are going in a different direction to all other groups in society in their political thinking. And not in a good way, in my opinion.

BlueRedCat · 04/08/2026 15:40

SwirlyGates · 04/08/2026 10:18

Yes. Why don't they? There are so many complaints about this but no action.

I only assume it is because in the short term the tax receipts will go down and politically that would be terrible. Long term it will pay off as firms start employing and investing in their businesses but a week is a long time in politics.

StandingDeskDisco · 04/08/2026 15:42

Bathroomphilosopher · 04/08/2026 14:30

Housing benefit and higher rate disability benefits would have to remain in place. There may also be a need to keep UC payments for children

If you are keeping housing benefits, disability benefits and family related benefits under UBI then you are keeping nearly all of the benefits structure and associated staff, AND have the cost of paying UBI to those who currently do not get it as their savings are too high (and you only need a few K in savings to start having benefits reduced) or their partner's income is too high.

It sounds like an expensive policy!!

Yes it will be expensive, so it won't be introduced for a long while yet.
But when tens of millions more are unemployed, it will be introduced to remove the admin burden.
Most of the admin is checking that people who are unemployed are looking for work properly, and checking that people who are ill or disabled have medical evidence. Remove those two requirements and the admin is considerably less.

The admin for child benefit now is minimal, so this would be similar for UBI (which would replace child benefit, and it would be re-instated for all children).
Those with lifelong severe disabilities that don't change over time would not need checking regularly either - just an initial confirmation of the condition.

HB admin would remain, unfortunately, because we have failed to provide social housing at a low rent for decades.

amala18 · 04/08/2026 15:43

Bathroomphilosopher · 04/08/2026 15:34

Young women in the UK, as a group, are disproportionately likely to hold views which, imho, are incredibly destructive to women and society, they are highly intolerant of difference, which subsume individual thinking into group orthodoxy with punishment of dissenters. I am dreading these young women gaining power if they maintain these views. All polls show they are going in a different direction to all other groups in society in their political thinking. And not in a good way, in my opinion.

I mentioned that I was talking about the whole Earth. What do you think about young women in other countries?

Countries where there is more of a gender balance in Government are doing well in many areas

Digerydont · 04/08/2026 15:45

Imagine Mum, Dad and 2 adult children getting 60k a year for doing nothing.

inamarina · 04/08/2026 15:47

amala18 · 04/08/2026 15:43

I mentioned that I was talking about the whole Earth. What do you think about young women in other countries?

Countries where there is more of a gender balance in Government are doing well in many areas

How would you change it across the whole Earth though?
Plenty of places where women are oppressed - who and how exactly should implement new systems of power in these places?

StripyShirt · 04/08/2026 15:51

Digerydont · 04/08/2026 15:45

Imagine Mum, Dad and 2 adult children getting 60k a year for doing nothing.

They wouldn't be doing nothing, they would be consuming.

amala18 · 04/08/2026 15:52

inamarina · 04/08/2026 15:47

How would you change it across the whole Earth though?
Plenty of places where women are oppressed - who and how exactly should implement new systems of power in these places?

We all need to think about how we can change it. When women are stronger across the world, we are all stronger.

I can't personally change it for every woman in the world, but I think about it and I try to do something.

I've donated money to Malala's fund for example- her fund helps girls to access education

JuliettaCaeser · 04/08/2026 15:52

What I don’t understand is the whole point of the system is to ensure the majority have employment so they have money to pay into the economy and to pay tax to support the vulnerable. And jobs to keep us busy.

It seems now the end goal is profit. If there are no jobs a few will be vastly wealthy and the majority in poverty and bored. Plus there won’t be anyone to buy their goods and services so what’s even the point. Also the few vastly wealthy and the majority crushed into poverty does t generally end well. Look how that turned out for the French in 1789.

Bigfatsquirrel · 04/08/2026 15:57

The government has a lot to answer for. Huge increase in regulation (employment rights act) and cost to hire people (min wage, national insurance). Then they wonder why youth unemployment has sky rocketed and the grad market is in the doldrums plus huge reduction in vacancies generally. Until this gets fixed expect things to keep getting worse - more tax rises coming in the October budget. But it’s ok cos Andy has cut bus fares to £2 (where they were when they took office) and given us all £45 off electricity (even though the price cap is increasing by around £150). They take us for fools - and now the proposal is an extra 1.8% levy (tax) on earnings above £6500 to pay for social care. There’s never any discussion about cutting spending is there from this lot. Just looking to tax people more. And then they wonder why businesses don’t want to hire people - the economy is not growing and Labour have no plan to get it growing (hopefully the fake solicitor now in charge of the Business Dept will have a think about that!)

Cars4Gov · 04/08/2026 16:10

I used AI to tell me which sectors have the most vacancies.
Healthcare & social care – highest demand and long-term shortages.
Technology & professional services – strong demand for digital and AI-related skills despite a softer overall hiring market.
Education – persistent recruitment needs, especially for teachers.
Construction & skilled trades – demand remains high in many occupations despite overall vacancies easing.
Logistics & warehousing – steady hiring driven by retail and e-commerce.

Digerydont · 04/08/2026 16:14

Every time we use AI to accomplish something; are we strengthening AI and contributing to our eventual downfall?

SwirlyGates · 04/08/2026 16:38

Digerydont · 04/08/2026 16:14

Every time we use AI to accomplish something; are we strengthening AI and contributing to our eventual downfall?

Yes. We are also outsourcing our brains and deskilling ourselves.

SwirlyGates · 04/08/2026 16:39

JuliettaCaeser · 04/08/2026 15:52

What I don’t understand is the whole point of the system is to ensure the majority have employment so they have money to pay into the economy and to pay tax to support the vulnerable. And jobs to keep us busy.

It seems now the end goal is profit. If there are no jobs a few will be vastly wealthy and the majority in poverty and bored. Plus there won’t be anyone to buy their goods and services so what’s even the point. Also the few vastly wealthy and the majority crushed into poverty does t generally end well. Look how that turned out for the French in 1789.

If the majority are in poverty and bored, and have no realistic prospect of changing their circumstances, that's a great recipe for increased crime, anarchy or revolution.

JuliettaCaeser · 04/08/2026 17:14

That’s what I said. The French had a revolution and guillotined the ruling class that hogged all the resources. Musk take note.

Nutmuncher · 04/08/2026 17:27

ThePeppyOpalScroller · 04/08/2026 10:59

This is the senario that Elon has no answer for. When you decouple labour from money, society collapses. Even in a UBI utopia, some jobs still need to be done. Why would anyone work any job whan they are being given everything they need or want for free? That's the problem with UBI, if you tell people it's a basic subsistence payment, then it's just universal credit. And poor, unemployed people aren't known to suddenly become philosophers or artists. We all know what longterm unemployment does to people's mental health.

If you set UBI at a high level, a luxury lifestyle, then nobody will work. And humans are not good at just sitting around. If I can have a new car, a new house, new clothes and electronics, all for almost nothing, how do you convince someone to work in waste management, to oversee the A.I and the robots. What more would you have to pay them? A UBI economy is just a contradiction and historically has very few successful precedents.

Not to mention the developing nations. A UBI economy would need mass surveillance to ensure compliance. Developing countries would become a "human economy utiopia". We would be living inside a polished, communist panopticon. The "free" nations like Africa and South America would look on us as we looked at the East Germans 50 years ago. Do we really want that kind of life?

Plenty of people work as volunteers today, doing charity work for free. Plenty of people love their jobs and relish having a purpose through work. There will still be a cohort of society who would do anything over not working at all. There will still be highly paid human roles, controlling the AI, robots and the systems. I think before UBI or UHI we will see the shift towards shorter working weeks for many sectors, 3 day weeks will be common in the next 18-24 months.

It’s also going to be a good 4/5 years before people are comfortable having a robot carer or nurse so many jobs will stay human centric out of necessity for the human touch initially. Let’s not forget that the new world we’re entering is going to be filled with an abundance of new opportunities just as the internet brought with it influencers, online retailers and service providers, new careers will blossom.

Backedoffhackedoff · 04/08/2026 17:32

I always wonder why house repossession figures are so low when apparently so many people are out of work?
If I was out of work I’d be out of savings in a few months. How do people manage to pay their bills?!

IDontHateRainbows · 04/08/2026 17:52

Backedoffhackedoff · 04/08/2026 17:32

I always wonder why house repossession figures are so low when apparently so many people are out of work?
If I was out of work I’d be out of savings in a few months. How do people manage to pay their bills?!

I'm wondering that too. You can get a mortgage interest loan if you are out of work but it's only for a limited time.

Anyone out of work, how are you coping?

Boudy · 04/08/2026 18:06

If UBI became reality perhaps a fair few people would choose to work fewer hours and have more balance. So more people might be able to work.Sort of along the lines of a job share type scenario but not quite the same. People could choose to work more hours obviously depending on the outgoings they have or choose to have etc. Less chance of burn out in some roles too. I am thinking healthcare as that is my background work wise.

curiositykilledthiscat · 04/08/2026 18:46

Backedoffhackedoff · 04/08/2026 17:32

I always wonder why house repossession figures are so low when apparently so many people are out of work?
If I was out of work I’d be out of savings in a few months. How do people manage to pay their bills?!

Not all of unemployed people are paying mortgages.

Also repossessions are the highest they’ve been for a while according to the most recent figures:

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cj0e0jjz88ro

A close-up image of Jose's hand, lightly touching his keys on top of the court decision document stating his home will be repossessed.

Stories from court as home repossessions hit five-year high

BBC journalists in the East of England and London attended various county courts as mortgage-holders and renters appeared in front of judges.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cj0e0jjz88ro