Help end medical misogyny. Sign our petition.

Help end medical misogyny.
Sign our petition.

Sign the petition

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think a male pill would be one of the best things that could happen to society?

137 replies

ZoeCM · Yesterday 13:30

A massive number of society's problems are caused by absent or bad fathers. Imagine if, before a baby was conceived, a man had to consciously think, "I want to have a child with this woman, so I'll come off the pill." Not just "I want to have sex, this woman is willing, and it'll be less enjoyable if we use a condom."

Of course, it wouldn't be a panacea. There would still sadly be men who choose to come off the pill but are bad fathers anyway, or decide once the reality of parenthood sets in that they can't be bothered. And there would also be men who just don't bother to take the pill properly and are then shocked when the woman gets pregnant. But on balance, if there were a way for men to have condom-free sex without potentially having to pay for a child for eighteen years afterwards, a lot of them would be downright religious in their use of it.

I'm genuinely intrigued to see if anyone disagrees with this. I can't see any downside.

OP posts:
Vivi0 · Today 17:23

Lifelover16 · Today 17:11

I wouldn’t trust any man to take, or even remember to take a pill. And in the heat of the moment a man would probably take the risk.

I think many people take the risk in the heat of the moment. Women, however, can get the morning after pill. I know I have.

There is a difference though, between not using a condom in the heat of the moment, but being proactive about taking a contraceptive pill every day. I think a lot of men would be able to manage the latter.

Ooofbananas · Today 17:25

I don’t believe men would be willing to tolerate the side effects of a hormonal pill. The payoff for women is huge, but pregnancy, childbirth and rearing can just be a minor inconvenience to a man.

RudolphTheReindeer · Today 17:26

Won't some men just claim they're on the pill when they're not so as to dodge a condom then claim it must have failed if anyone gets pregnant? Much like some women do? You're either responsible or not I'm not sure a male pill makes much difference to that.

Cheeseandolivesplease · Today 17:31

@IAmWhoIAmm
A man with no job pays no maintenance. Many find other ways to get away with it.

Cheeseandolivesplease · Today 17:32

Also, a male pill would see a rise in STD rates.

Ace42 · Today 17:56

They made their own pill. A red one and it's working better than anything so far.

Firefly1987 · Today 18:52

ZoeCM · Today 14:28

I know! Women would still have the exact same contraceptive options that they have now.

Yes I don't know what women aren't getting or why they're making this about themselves. It always happens when the idea of a male pill is discussed. This is about men having more choice not women. We can still take our own. Imagine if we had a new contraception method and men were constantly putting their 2 cents in about how we wouldn't take it etc-there would be outrage!

Honestly men can't win, they get criticised for not having to take on any of the responsibility but any whiff of a male pill and it's "I wouldn't trust them"-just an excuse to man bash. In reality women are terrified there will be no more babies if a male pill ever gets invented I think.

Cheeseandolivesplease · Today 18:55

The reality is...reckless men will always be reckless. A male pill won't change that.
Just in the same way that the female pill doesn't stop reckless women.

Dribblo · Today 19:36

I’d say shit parents in general are a problem for society. There are some people who clearly shouldn’t have had kids and it’s mystifying why they bothered in the first place.

Cheeseandolivesplease · Today 20:53

@Dribblo For money maybe?

TowerRavenSeven · Today 20:55

Downside? Surely you jest! I wouldn’t trust Any man with that responsibility!!

phoenixrosehere · Today 21:15

There was a male injection in the works in 2016 I recall but it was scrapped due to too many side effects which were the same side effects women had to endure being on contraceptives.

I would welcome a male pill as another option, simultaneously it doesn’t change the fact that women would still bear the brunt anyway if it failed so it would have to be both parties using contraceptives vs just one.

I do wonder if a pregnancy occurs anyway with both on contraceptives , how would that be looked into and could it become a legal issue if a parter was lying or taking contraceptives wrong.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page