Help end medical misogyny. Sign our petition.

Help end medical misogyny.
Sign our petition.

Sign the petition

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What is going on with Brooklyn/Harper Beckham?

210 replies

IberianLynx · Today 13:20

https://www.mirror.co.uk/3am/celebrity-news/harper-beckhams-devastating-gesture-after-37292907.amp

AIBU to feel sorry for Harper? If BB has an issue with his parents it shouldn’t mean that he also stops talking to his siblings. It’s equally as sad if the parents did choreographed the letter/visit.

Brooklyn Beckham accuses parents of using Harper for 'choreographed' house visit

Harper Beckham was spotted making a failed attempt to reunite with her brother Brooklyn, with a spokesperson dismissing the visit as another stunt from 'brand Beckham'

https://www.mirror.co.uk/3am/celebrity-news/harper-beckhams-devastating-gesture-after-37292907.amp

OP posts:
Gowlett · Today 14:14

I know others blame Nicola, and think she’s controlling. Same as with Meghan. But, from what I can see, both Brooklyn & Harry wanted out. They’d both gone out with suitable women before. And duly dumped the ones that weren’t. But look at the women they married.

Both have said that the press narrative / family dynamics were the reason they’ve cut off their families. If you look at other nepo babies, the co-dependency is strong. Kelly & Sharon. Damian & Liz Hurley. With Kris Jenner, it’s business first. I mean, look at Kylie…

Kbcdtyijgd · Today 14:18

Nicola doesn’t need Beckham wealth, she’ll never be on the pay roll.

faithfultoGeorgeMichael · Today 14:19

Making money for the family business, him for his DFIL her for DM and DF. This is their life, lived publicly. It is looking past it's best isn't it?

BeardySchnauzer · Today 14:19

Yes he’s married someone controlling because he probably doesn’t know anything else. I really hope for his sake his relationship works out.

Tableforjoan · Today 14:19

Isn’t it just amazing there was a paparazzi right there ready to snap this moment despite no paparazzi snapping Brooklyn and his Mrs leaving and not even being there 🤣

Just another called in pap session to feed the Beckham woe is me brand.

UserNineNine · Today 14:20

It does make sense that they must have just assumed that they would be able to keep their children in line with money and then Brooklyn ends up with someone richer than the beckhams will ever be. They have used him as a commodity since he was conceived.

ithinkilikethislittlelife · Today 14:22

the whole thing was clearly a set up and she had to go along with it as she is a child. I actually feel sorry for her. She looked so uncomfortable in her strappy dress at her father’s recent award thing. Poor kids.

AstonUniversityPotholeDepartment · Today 14:22

TheAutumnCrow · Today 13:57

Her parents told them when they were giving the required legal permission for the newspaper(s) to publish.

Disgusting, manipulative behaviour. Brooklyn and Harper are both victims here.

TheAutumnCrow · Today 14:22

Gowlett · Today 14:14

I know others blame Nicola, and think she’s controlling. Same as with Meghan. But, from what I can see, both Brooklyn & Harry wanted out. They’d both gone out with suitable women before. And duly dumped the ones that weren’t. But look at the women they married.

Both have said that the press narrative / family dynamics were the reason they’ve cut off their families. If you look at other nepo babies, the co-dependency is strong. Kelly & Sharon. Damian & Liz Hurley. With Kris Jenner, it’s business first. I mean, look at Kylie…

Edited

Except Meghan ‘Backgrid’ Sussex is building this exact same branding dynamic with her five year old daughter Lil, and Harry is enabling it. Go figure 🤷‍♀️

Genevieva · Today 14:23

SaffronsMadAboutMe · Today 13:38

So he's gone NC, she didn't respect that, turned up on his doorstep and there just happened to be photographers waiting?

It sounds like he has the measure of her and probably doesn't trust her not to blab his personal stuff to the two business people who raised them.

Edited

She’s a 14 year old. I don’t think she can be expected to have an adult’s grasp of what has gone on. She may have been encouraged by her parents, or she may have begged them because she misses her brother and was nearby. We simply don’t know. We also don’t know that her brother turned her away. He might simply have been out.

Indigovelvet · Today 14:23

Looks like Harper was being set up by the parents. Father's day next weekend.

WheretheFishesareFrightening · Today 14:23

The fact we even know it happens sort of puts Brooklyn in the right. It is of course possible to do things in private, even if your the Beckhams, and Harper chose not to go that route which Brooklyn has made it clear he would prefer.

Although, my sympathy is limited for someone who was happy to be within Brand Beckham when his family wealth supported him, but once he married into a richer family he was happy to disown the brand. The Peltzes don't need to maintain celebrity like the Beckhams do to remain wealthy and relevant, and so I suspect he thinks that his parents should have given him the life Nicola had (one with all of the opportunities that nepotism brings but without creating tabloid fodder), but they weren't wealthy enough for that.

He didn't complain about the compromises associated with Brand Beckham when he needed it, but now it's given him access to a better life he's happy to disown it.

allthingsinmoderation · Today 14:23

I don't think you ABU to feel sorry for a 14 yr old girl who has lost contact with her brother and wants to see him, he's cut contact with her because of a falling out with their parents and i think thats wrong and must hurt them both.

mumofoneAloneandwell · Today 14:25

Wynter25 · Today 13:53

Hes an arsehole

I dunno tbh

But i'm in his shoes (albeit not rich or famous) and its hard for people to understand

Tableforjoan · Today 14:25

allthingsinmoderation · Today 14:23

I don't think you ABU to feel sorry for a 14 yr old girl who has lost contact with her brother and wants to see him, he's cut contact with her because of a falling out with their parents and i think thats wrong and must hurt them both.

I don’t think he can be in contact with her because it would just be used by the parents.

He has no choice but to cut her off or he might as well not cut of his parents.

TheAutumnCrow · Today 14:27

ithinkilikethislittlelife · Today 14:22

the whole thing was clearly a set up and she had to go along with it as she is a child. I actually feel sorry for her. She looked so uncomfortable in her strappy dress at her father’s recent award thing. Poor kids.

I know. She’s a child. It’s nauseating that they choose this for her.

I hope to god the BrookNics don’t do anything like this in the future, trading on a mini-me or two like they’re Pokémon cards.

sweetsibil · Today 14:28

It's just Beckham PR to get Harper into the spotlight. Poor rich girl.

blacksax · Today 14:28

Pabbel · Today 13:35

To cut off siblings and other family members when your problems are with your parents is childish and hurtful

I have known this situation - in my wider family, unfortunately. Including the 'being shunned on the doorstep' scenario.

It is a really horrible situation to be in, both for siblings and other relatives, and being in the public eye is not going to make it easier, by any means. Especially when you have the paps camped on your doorstep 24/7 waiting to follow you wherever you go.

TheAutumnCrow · Today 14:28

Genevieva · Today 14:23

She’s a 14 year old. I don’t think she can be expected to have an adult’s grasp of what has gone on. She may have been encouraged by her parents, or she may have begged them because she misses her brother and was nearby. We simply don’t know. We also don’t know that her brother turned her away. He might simply have been out.

In California children can’t be photographed and publicised without parents’ permission. State law.

Ritasueandbobtoo9 · Today 14:29

Ridiculous. Total manipulation.

Tableforjoan · Today 14:30

TheAutumnCrow · Today 14:28

In California children can’t be photographed and publicised without parents’ permission. State law.

Exactly so we only know about it because V and B want us to know.

They want the world to think their son is horrible. By using their daughter.

Hardly great parents.

BeardySchnauzer · Today 14:30

WheretheFishesareFrightening · Today 14:23

The fact we even know it happens sort of puts Brooklyn in the right. It is of course possible to do things in private, even if your the Beckhams, and Harper chose not to go that route which Brooklyn has made it clear he would prefer.

Although, my sympathy is limited for someone who was happy to be within Brand Beckham when his family wealth supported him, but once he married into a richer family he was happy to disown the brand. The Peltzes don't need to maintain celebrity like the Beckhams do to remain wealthy and relevant, and so I suspect he thinks that his parents should have given him the life Nicola had (one with all of the opportunities that nepotism brings but without creating tabloid fodder), but they weren't wealthy enough for that.

He didn't complain about the compromises associated with Brand Beckham when he needed it, but now it's given him access to a better life he's happy to disown it.

I actually think there’s an element of coercive control and Stockholm syndrome though. He knew no different

TheAutumnCrow · Today 14:32

TheAutumnCrow · Today 14:28

In California children can’t be photographed and publicised without parents’ permission. State law.

And actually, I think the Beckhams senior have really fucked up here on this one. Maybe they didn’t realise the law in CA is so very strict, and inevitably puts them right at the scene of the crime, so to speak.

SeasideDaisy · Today 14:33

NeelyOHara · Today 13:38

They are disgraceful, it has to be a set up as the press are not allowed to photograph under 16’s without permission in LA.

I don’t practically care so I don’t know why I’m even commenting but I can see that paparazzi where waiting around Brooklyns home on that day.. Just incase.

UserNineNine · Today 14:34

Genevieva · Today 14:23

She’s a 14 year old. I don’t think she can be expected to have an adult’s grasp of what has gone on. She may have been encouraged by her parents, or she may have begged them because she misses her brother and was nearby. We simply don’t know. We also don’t know that her brother turned her away. He might simply have been out.

He was out, he was in New York on the other side of the country and had been posting on his social media that he was in New York.

He’s apparently blocked his parents on SM but not his sister. Not that they couldn’t look at his posts on someone else’s account of course.

Swipe left for the next trending thread