Help end medical misogyny. Sign our petition.

Help end medical misogyny.
Sign our petition.

Sign the petition

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

New neighbour has asked us to stop construction on new home until daughter has finished exams.

489 replies

Grammarninja · Yesterday 19:34

This is such a tricky one for me. We bought a house that needed a complete overhaul a year ago. We've finally gotten through architects, planning permission and trying to find affordable builders etc. It has been stressful.
We broke ground this week and the neighbours have asked us to stop until dd has finished her exams in 3 weeks.
I really feel for the family and can't imagine how upsetting it must be for them at this crucial time (we had no idea they had a child sitting exams this summer). My husband has offered them an office at his work around the corner to facilitate study. I wouldn't mind postponing if it wouldn't cost us 30k to do so as builders are working to a set time frame. I wouldn't even mind the extra costs we'd incur through having to stay in our current accommodation for another month if it weren't for the builders' costs which we simply can't afford.
I'm worried now that we're going to start off on a terrible note with our new neighbours which would be such a shame considering my current neighbours are like family.
Are we being unreasonable to continue with the build in these circumstances?

OP posts:
FrankieMcGrath · Yesterday 20:37

Gwenna · Yesterday 20:34

Your access lane and they want you to keep cover for their bikes? Wow, they’re incredibly entitled!

Sounds like a deliberate drip feed to me to make the neighbours sound unreasonable - not sure I believe it!

Hangingcrystal · Yesterday 20:37

OP I have a child doing very important exams at the moment, and your neighbours are absolutely ridiculous.
Your husband made a lovely offer.
Be wary of such people.

My friend had her daughter doing important exams and her builder started yesterday.
They have waited a year for the builder.

I cannot imagine the entitlement of such an ask.
Noise cancelling head phones or go to your husbands office.

Back away from them.

You can ensure peace from 6 o clock.
Mine all did huge study in the evening, like many students.

I agree with above, be very wary.
Reasonable people wouldn't ask this.
Twats would IMO.

Grammarninja · Yesterday 20:38

JuliettaCaeser · Yesterday 20:28

I would worry about the karma and someone will do the same to you when your 2 year old has her public exams!

I'm not worried about karma but I am distressed at the notion of putting someone, who's going through a hard time, through more hardship. I couldn't feel for her or her parents more. I'm really sad about this and it has my stomach in knots.

OP posts:
Whyherewego · Yesterday 20:38

I think they can ask but you can equally explain that you're on a fixed schedule and unfortunately you cannot delay that. However you are sympathetic so you can offer their DD a space to study in the nearby office or a pair of noise cancelling earphones.

I think that is more than reasonable.

Grammarninja · Yesterday 20:39

FrankieMcGrath · Yesterday 20:37

Sounds like a deliberate drip feed to me to make the neighbours sound unreasonable - not sure I believe it!

It really is the case but not really relevant to this thread as the worry is the dd and her exams.

OP posts:
Choux · Yesterday 20:39

Grammarninja · Yesterday 20:23

It's no more than 500m away from her home and has women working there. There's a spare office, a kitchen and a coffee shop downstairs. I know it's not ideal but it's a potential solution?

I think that sounds like a lovely offer. What I would also do is try to give them clarity so she can plan her study time eg “the builders will arrive at 8, have a 30 minute break at 12 and will leave by 4 each day. This week they are doing X so it might be noisier but next week they will be doing Y so it should be slightly quieter”

She might then focus on studying 6-8 at home, then a few hours in your office or the school library and then back home to study more after 4pm.

oliviaAustin · Yesterday 20:39

Troublein · Yesterday 19:39

They will hate you forever and you will deserve it.

You've been faffing around for a year from their perspective, then suddenly you want to make their daughters life harder while you live elsewhere so the noise and disruption doesn't bother you.

This is only the case if the neighbours have 0 knowledge of how long these things take. Plus it’s not faffing to start building when it’s convenient for you and not everyone else nearby.

Isitevensummer · Yesterday 20:39

Tableforjoan · Yesterday 20:31

Ask my neighbour! 7:30am - 6pm. Weekends? What’s a weekend. They just start later at 8am 😬😬😱

Wish they had been the ones who did my bathroom then!

scalt · Yesterday 20:39

If you agree to this, what else will they demand?

Are they also going to demand that the unions suspend the strikes on the London Underground, for exams? That would be far more useful.

Adrian Mole accused Margaret Thatcher of being incredibly selfish for calling a general election for June 9th, so candidates were disturbing his O-level revision by knocking on the door. “We’re not trying to exterminate the working class, just trim them down a bit!”

Gwenna · Yesterday 20:40

Nofeckingway · Yesterday 19:50

Another example of preciousness . Ridiculous to think that neighbours should stop work because your kid is taking exams . How on earth are these young people supposed to get any skills at living real life or any resilience. And what is this to cover , revision ? exam dates ? There are young people worldwide struggling to get education under very difficult circumstances. FFS .

Absolutely agree! 👏

user1476613140 · Yesterday 20:41

Just carry on with your build. Libraries were invented for a good reason. She can study there. Not a big deal.

MmeDubois7 · Yesterday 20:41

MandemChickenShop · Yesterday 19:40

What a load of nonsense. She will be at school during the day doing the exams and revising in the evenings so can't see she will be disturbed much anyway. If she's at home during the day she can go to school or the library, or use some noise cancelling headphones.

She's not going to have an exam every day!

I feel for both sides. Obviously you can't pay an extra 30k but I would have been angry if my dc's studying had been interrupted. My dc would have hated to have had to go to the library every day to study.

LadyMacbethWasFierce · Yesterday 20:42

Your offer of an office space is good.

I think so long as you keep strictly to normal builders hours - Monday - Friday 8am - 4pm you are ok. It would be wholly unreasonable to have any work outside those days/hours.

i think you should tell them why you can’t delay so they don’t think you are being difficult.

You sound nice.

But are you totally sure you would lose £30k?

oliviaAustin · Yesterday 20:42

Grammarninja · Yesterday 20:32

Thank you. Over the last year we've had several requests from these neighbours. We've had to hire people to deal with our joining hedge, pay for a new fence and told that we'd have to consult them on our access lane as the current cover has been providing them with cover and they don't want to lose this as their bikes might rust so 'we'll have to agree on your plans for sheltering this space'.

Just say ‘no we won’t as that’s not in the deeds or covenants.’

ScribblingPixie · Yesterday 20:43

Grammarninja · Yesterday 20:23

It's no more than 500m away from her home and has women working there. There's a spare office, a kitchen and a coffee shop downstairs. I know it's not ideal but it's a potential solution?

Using this or school/college library would probably do her favours, studying without the distractions she has at home. It's a totally reasonable offer.

oliviaAustin · Yesterday 20:43

Tableforjoan · Yesterday 20:30

As someone living next to this currently I’m so glad my teens are not doing exams right now. The noise thunders through the whole house you just cannot escape it and the vibrations.

If they are on study leave they might not actually be able to go back into school to study. One of mines school doesn’t allow it your expected to study at home where is supposed to be quieter than the hustle and bustle school.

Horrible for both but yeah you’re probably not going to be friends.

Public libraries are open to everyone for free

Grammarninja · Yesterday 20:44

JuliettaCaeser · Yesterday 20:15

You have to press on but yes they will hate you.

I know 😞

OP posts:
Brunchatstephanies · Yesterday 20:44

This is such a MN thing.

We live in an older house and 5 out of the 7 houses in our row have been fully renovated in the last 4-5 years including neighbours on both sides. We did ours but both houses next door were empty during the work due to bereavement.

It wouldn’t occur to any of us to make demands of the neighbours doing work and yes it was inconvenient many times for us. That is bloody life.

Oh and yes there were exams for 2 of our children.

Shittyyear2025 · Yesterday 20:44

SusieSussex · Yesterday 19:49

They only go in for exams. They aren't at school all day.

Not a single secondary school in my area has kids on study leave until at least mid june. Kids expected to be in for revision sessions right up to the last big exam (GCSE physics iirc) - she is likely to be in school until 3ish after which the builders will only be around for an hour, and not evenings or weekends.

Check the school website or give them a call and ask when the year 11s finish...

Mousespoons · Yesterday 20:44

SusieSussex · Yesterday 19:43

When you've had kids go through GCSEs or A Levels you understand their point of view more. It's a stressful time without having to be banished from their house due to angle grinders etc

Disagree, we have exam children in the house, wouldn’t dream of asking the neighbours to stop installing their new kitchen. There’s plenty of work arounds if she can’t cope with the noise. Life goes on.

Mumtobabyhavoc · Yesterday 20:45

It was very cheeky of neighbours to ask. Ear plugs and libraries is their answer.

Gloriia · Yesterday 20:45

Grammarninja · Yesterday 20:39

It really is the case but not really relevant to this thread as the worry is the dd and her exams.

They're exams, it's fine. She'll study on an evening and weekends when builders won't even be there.

Please do not give these entitled arseholes another inch they seem to be taking complete advantage of your good nature. Smile, wave and ignore.

WiddlinDiddlin · Yesterday 20:46

Offering an alternative and suitable place to work is a kindness and above and beyond really.

Being clear about what time work may start and definitely will finish by, and giving them advanced warning of particularly noisey works is very helpful.

Beyond that, unless they're happy to pay you what it would cost you - 30K - no, you can't halt the works until after exams, life happens she will just have to get on with it and as you say, THEY had this work done to their house and I would bet they did not delay it for their neighbours childrens benefit.

Building work can only go on between certain daytime hours, there are other locations and many more hours a day where the kiddo can rest and revise.

Oriunda · Yesterday 20:47

At the very least, ensure that there are NO weekend works, and work stops in the evening at an agreed hour, ideally as early as possible. No early starts either; the teen will need her sleep.

Bryll · Yesterday 20:47

SusieSussex · Yesterday 19:44

How rude.

Well saying the OP had been faffing around ie waiting for planning etc and that she actually wanted to make the girl’s life hard, is a pretty stupid thing to say!

Swipe left for the next trending thread