Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what you think of Thomas Tuchel's England World Cup Squad?

49 replies

mumofoneAloneandwell · Yesterday 15:20

In my football era 😌

No Trent Alexander Arnold, no Phil Foden, no Slabhead, no Cole Palmer

I think its a shame that theres no Harry Maguire - his mum taking to defend him on social media makes her, imo, slightly iconic

What do we think? Will Tuchel bring us the cup, or are we in for heartbreak?

https://www.skysports.com/football/news/12016/13546983/england-world-cup-squad-thomas-tuchel-defends-his-specialist-selections-after-cole-palmer-phil-foden-and-harry-maguire-left-out

To ask what you think of Thomas Tuchel's England World Cup Squad?
OP posts:
araiwa · Yesterday 15:25

Surprised by Toney after his retirement to Saudi

Foden and Palmer has been trash and I'm not surprised they're not going

Thought harry would make it. Always turned up for England

murasaki · Yesterday 15:28

Toney was a surprise, but I think he's only there for pens, and won't play before being subbed in in the last 2 minutes of extra time.

Gibbs White deserved to go. And possibly Wharton.

Maguire can do one. His entitlement is astonishing, and his family seem as bad as he is. Is he still fighting that conviction?

They are not going to win whoever they pick, so I'm happy enough.

murasaki · Yesterday 15:28

Very pleased for Watkins, he worked really hard since being dropped.

the80sweregreat · Yesterday 15:31

I bet that the armchair pundits will all go on the sport radio channels having a rant that he has left off so many big names. It’s a gamble I suppose. If it works he’ll be praised and if it’s bad he’ll get the abuse.

Keepoffmyartichokes · Yesterday 15:32

Harry Maguire has a criminal record so probably wouldn't get an ESTA

TheBabyFatmoss · Yesterday 15:33

I didn’t know anyone else called him Slabhead 😂

ladyrinths · Yesterday 15:35

Well they may as well try something new as we are generally crap

Namechangedasouting987 · Yesterday 15:36

I dont think Foden deserved to go, not had a great year.
I think I would have taken Adam Wharton over Jordan Hendersom, but apparently he is going for his leadership qualilities. Alth that sounds a bit meh tbh.
Toney is an odd choice for me.
And I agree about Gibbs White, i think he should be there.
And I cannot get my head around Djed Spence. Spurs defence has been shocking all season...

PullTheBricksDown · Yesterday 15:38

Keepoffmyartichokes · Yesterday 15:32

Harry Maguire has a criminal record so probably wouldn't get an ESTA

Hadn't thought of that. But it doesn't look great for him or any of his family to be moaning about it online.

murasaki · Yesterday 15:44

PullTheBricksDown · Yesterday 15:38

Hadn't thought of that. But it doesn't look great for him or any of his family to be moaning about it online.

Tuchel has already said he's 'surprised' at it (read disappointed) given it was a private conversation leaked before the announcement.

murasaki · Yesterday 15:47

Nearly all the Villa first team are off to it.

3 England
1 Scotland
2 Belgium
1 France
1 Sweden
1 definite Argentina, 2 if they've got any sense
1 Spain hopefully.

9 definite, possibly 11. Not bad. I'd like them back in one piece please.

Livpool · Yesterday 15:49

murasaki · Yesterday 15:28

Toney was a surprise, but I think he's only there for pens, and won't play before being subbed in in the last 2 minutes of extra time.

Gibbs White deserved to go. And possibly Wharton.

Maguire can do one. His entitlement is astonishing, and his family seem as bad as he is. Is he still fighting that conviction?

They are not going to win whoever they pick, so I'm happy enough.

I agree about Maguire - I think he is dire, and as you say his entitlement is a reason he shouldn’t go.

murasaki · Yesterday 15:51

Livpool · Yesterday 15:49

I agree about Maguire - I think he is dire, and as you say his entitlement is a reason he shouldn’t go.

He's more use up front at corners than he is as a defender.

Tuchel seems to have a thing for a group that works together, and leadership and character, hence Henderson, and Maguire blotted his own copybook on that.

Livpool · Yesterday 16:02

murasaki · Yesterday 15:51

He's more use up front at corners than he is as a defender.

Tuchel seems to have a thing for a group that works together, and leadership and character, hence Henderson, and Maguire blotted his own copybook on that.

Yeah we’ve had that issue for years - good players that don’t play well together or work as a team. It was a major problem with Gerrard and Lampard a few years ago. I’m happy to try out a cohesive team, without any divas to be honest. No other managers have been able to do it for the last 60 years!

I am a Liverpool fan and happy to see Henderson in the squad. He was a good captain for us, in my opinion.

coneyislandoldspot · Yesterday 16:02

Awful.

Absolutely awful.

murasaki · Yesterday 16:04

Livpool · Yesterday 16:02

Yeah we’ve had that issue for years - good players that don’t play well together or work as a team. It was a major problem with Gerrard and Lampard a few years ago. I’m happy to try out a cohesive team, without any divas to be honest. No other managers have been able to do it for the last 60 years!

I am a Liverpool fan and happy to see Henderson in the squad. He was a good captain for us, in my opinion.

Bellingham is enough of a diva for the lot of them, can't carry another!

coneyislandoldspot · Yesterday 16:07

Livpool · Yesterday 16:02

Yeah we’ve had that issue for years - good players that don’t play well together or work as a team. It was a major problem with Gerrard and Lampard a few years ago. I’m happy to try out a cohesive team, without any divas to be honest. No other managers have been able to do it for the last 60 years!

I am a Liverpool fan and happy to see Henderson in the squad. He was a good captain for us, in my opinion.

Good captain but an awful player. Choosing experience is all well and good if you’ve got enough players to pad the team out. Realistically Henderson shouldn’t be in any squad.

Ablondiebutagoody · Yesterday 16:08

Doesn't really matter. Scrape through the group, bore our way through the last 16 with a Kane penalty. Out in the quarter finals.

Fwiw, Palmer and Foden have been shit this season.

Livpool · Yesterday 16:09

coneyislandoldspot · Yesterday 16:07

Good captain but an awful player. Choosing experience is all well and good if you’ve got enough players to pad the team out. Realistically Henderson shouldn’t be in any squad.

I know what you mean but I am hoping Henderson is a grounding force. Just need the other players to play 😂.

I’m an 8th French so will be supporting both anyway 😂😂

Boomer55 · Yesterday 16:10

mumofoneAloneandwell · Yesterday 15:20

In my football era 😌

No Trent Alexander Arnold, no Phil Foden, no Slabhead, no Cole Palmer

I think its a shame that theres no Harry Maguire - his mum taking to defend him on social media makes her, imo, slightly iconic

What do we think? Will Tuchel bring us the cup, or are we in for heartbreak?

https://www.skysports.com/football/news/12016/13546983/england-world-cup-squad-thomas-tuchel-defends-his-specialist-selections-after-cole-palmer-phil-foden-and-harry-maguire-left-out

I like Jack Grealish. But we’ll see. 🤷‍♀️

murasaki · Yesterday 16:10

I suspect Henderson won't start but is there for backroom vibes.

AsimpleOstrich · Yesterday 16:11

I'm gutted for Morgan Gibbs-White.

ItsmeMargo · Yesterday 16:39

I thought Lewis Hall would be going.

PullTheBricksDown · Yesterday 16:39

murasaki · Yesterday 15:44

Tuchel has already said he's 'surprised' at it (read disappointed) given it was a private conversation leaked before the announcement.

That, for me, would get him filed in the 'not selecting him ever again' drawer.

LlynTegid · Yesterday 16:42

AsimpleOstrich · Yesterday 16:11

I'm gutted for Morgan Gibbs-White.

I think not including him is the worst decision.

I hadn't realised that Harry Maguire's criminal record could have created issues with getting him into the US, though I bet an exception would have been made. I think his reaction showed a lack of class, he could have waited until after the squad announcement and wished others well.

I'm more interested in the hope that for the first time Scotland get beyond the group stage. England will do well to make the semi-finals.

Swipe left for the next trending thread