Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

OH wants custody of baby niece?

1000 replies

milkshakess · 08/05/2026 10:55

So OH's younger sister has recently had a baby and there is possibility that the baby may end up in care.

She already has an 18 year olds on who has lived with their mum since he was 8.

She dips in and out of his life, she even forgot his last birthday, she hasn't really been a mum to him at all. Despite this he has turned out to be a lovely, smart and hard working lad.

Everyone was so surprised by the pregnancy.

From what we understand she was kept in hospital for 2 weeks whilst some kind of team were getting stuff ready for the baby.

I think the hospital staff were monitoring and observing her interact with the baby and something must of been flagged?

Her mum has sold her house and was due to move abroad in September but she had been visiting her and the baby at the hospital daily and helping.

OH isn't really close to his sister but he is close to her son, he calls OH the "best uncle" as him and the other uncles have all chipped into help raise him.
OH would sometimes not see his sister for years and she was always changing her number and would have to talk to her though her son.

Anyway the family don't want the baby to end up in care but everyone has young kids themselves ( we have toddlers and are trying for a 3rd).

OH wants to go for custody but the care would really fall on me and I work from home and have a very flexible job.

Just wanted input on the situation as OH and the family don't want the baby to go into care

OP posts:
Watdidusay · 08/05/2026 23:40

milkshakess · 08/05/2026 10:59

I feel really sorry for the baby and would love to keep her in the family but I don't see how it would work.

It would also mean putting baby number 3 on hold.

Wouldn't this be baby 3? Otherwise would be a plan to treat the child as different from the other children

eotwaski · 08/05/2026 23:42

Watdidusay · 08/05/2026 23:40

Wouldn't this be baby 3? Otherwise would be a plan to treat the child as different from the other children

Yes, and if baby #3 biological baby went ahead, in the birth order it would be #4. I wouldn't let adopting a niece stop be having my own #3, even if they were close in age, but I didn't find the preschool years difficult and thrived on being surrounded by children. Note everyone can cope with it as well or wants to, and that's okay.

Scout2016 · 08/05/2026 23:43

Does your partner's sister want you to visit her in hospital OP? You said she's ignoring his calls. Or are you planning on just turning up?

Lunde · 08/05/2026 23:44

Watdidusay · 08/05/2026 23:40

Wouldn't this be baby 3? Otherwise would be a plan to treat the child as different from the other children

Not necessarily a permanent child for OP if Social Services are intending OP to facilitate the baby's return to its own parents

If OP is not married she may not have any parental responsibility for the child

Allisnotlost1 · 08/05/2026 23:44

FungibleAssets · 08/05/2026 23:11

No one is ‘erasing this baby’s humanity’. I’m simply pointing out that handwringing on the internet about how you couldn’t possibly let a child go into the care system is very easy.

It’s equally easy to dismiss a baby when it’s not your partner’s family and has no impact on your relationships in future.

Needspaceforlego · 08/05/2026 23:45

milkshakess · 08/05/2026 21:40

So SIL was under the care of the mental health team during her pregnancy.

She had to be induced and then it was decided that it would be best for her to remain in hospital with the baby as the mental health team were liaising with the council into getting her settled as she was moving into a brand new house.

Concerns were noted and observed by the midwives in the hospital.
The baby and SIL are still in hospital with MIL visiting every day along side her son.

There at various organisations involved already and they are looking to see if anyone can take the baby.

With the nephew, she wasn't a very good mum to him, would neglect him, leave him with his nan for days to go out drinking etc.

When he was 8 his nan became responsible for him and she has dipped in and out of his life.

She took loans out in her mum's name and went off to New York for 3 months when he was 11 and didn't even call to check how he was.

Nephew has turned out into such an amazingly kind and smart young man. He is at college and has done so well BUT he has no parental figure in his life and he says this a lot to OH and me.

He tells OH that he is like his dad and OH will give him money, buy him stuff and take him out for food etc every week.

I am really torn and I know when I see the baby that I will want to keep her as I won't be able to face her getting put in care.

Before I had kids I had 5 cats, and I was adamant that I didn't want any more.

Then one day a little kitten came to my front door after being dumped by someone after Xmas and she would come every day following me around and I kept her in my greenhouse, insulated it and made it her home until I got her vaccinated, checked for FIV and when she was spayed she stayed in my bedroom to recover.

We took her to Cats Protection with the intent on having her rehomed but I didn't have the heart to say goodbye and I think this will end up happening with this baby.

But as others have pointed out I would want the baby to raise as my own and now have SIL dip in and out as she does with her son.
That would both be stressful and unfair.

I will know more weekend as we are going with MIL to the hospital.

Bless you Op.
I hope you are able to get proper information at the weekend.
If you were to take custody what exactly the legal set up would be. I certainly don't think i could cope with the Mum dipping in and out but I also don't know how open adoption really work. Would that be the plan?

Take your time.

nomas · 08/05/2026 23:46

Watdidusay · 08/05/2026 23:40

Wouldn't this be baby 3? Otherwise would be a plan to treat the child as different from the other children

Read the post above yours for Lunde’s definitive summary of why this isn’t simply baby no.3.

Crazy that people are still trotting this out after 650 posts.

nomas · 08/05/2026 23:49

Allisnotlost1 · 08/05/2026 23:44

It’s equally easy to dismiss a baby when it’s not your partner’s family and has no impact on your relationships in future.

No one should feel coerced into taking on a child to keep their partner happy.

eotwaski · 08/05/2026 23:50

nomas · 08/05/2026 23:49

No one should feel coerced into taking on a child to keep their partner happy.

Especially one they wouldn't have any legal right to even see if the relationship broke up.

nomas · 08/05/2026 23:51

ToffeeCrabApple · 08/05/2026 23:30

I think its a positive that your DH is willing to focus on what's best for the baby & step up (absent abuse or neglect, its generally better long term for a child to remain with family than go into care or be adopted). Having contact (even infrequent) with bio mother & sibling, and being part of the wider family of aunts/uncles/cousins is important.

I know in my family if anything happened to my siblings there is no way we'd let any of the DC go into care/be adopted. They are "our" kids.

That said, its obviously a huge decision for your family & something you need to decide together.

He’s not stepping up, though, he is stepping OP up. He has asked OP ‘Do you want X’s baby?’ because he expects her to do the bulk of the care.

AnotherEmma · 08/05/2026 23:51

I'm on the fence about this. It's a tricky one. I think it would be lovely if you could take in your niece but I understand it's no small undertaking and I think you need to find out much more to make a fully informed decision.

Firstly the situation seems unclear - if social services really are looking for kinship carers, you will need a discussion with them to find out the situation and the process.

There is a Kinship Care charity and I'd suggest you contact them for advice:
https://kinship.org.uk/support-and-advice/

Once you've got more info you will need to have a really open and honest discussion with your partner about what each of you wants, how it might work, what it might mean for any plans to try for another baby, etc.

Only the two of you can decide. But if you decide to take in your niece you should definitely get married (tbh you should get married anyway, for legal/financial protection for you and your children).

Best of luck.

Support and advice

Whether you are new to kinship care, already caring for a child or supporting a family member or friend, we’re here to help.

https://kinship.org.uk/support-and-advice/

Allisnotlost1 · 09/05/2026 00:02

nomas · 08/05/2026 23:49

No one should feel coerced into taking on a child to keep their partner happy.

Of course they shouldn’t, but it’s naive to think that a decision either way is without consequence and that OP can just say ‘no thanks’ and crack on with plans for baby no3. There will be emotional things to navigate, it’s just a hard situation all round.

MissRaspberryRipples · 09/05/2026 00:04

I think she's right to not take this decision lightly. Whilst I get that OP's partner doesn't want to see his sisters baby go to another family he needs to consider the fact that his sister has already had one child that she hasn't taken any responsibility for yet she's been irresponsible enough to have another one that is being taken out of her care. His sister needs to take some accountability for her actions and understand that she can't keep having babies if she's unable or unwilling to look after them herself

MilkyLeonard · 09/05/2026 00:06

Bubblesgun · 08/05/2026 17:34

I dont understand. If you re married surely this baby is also your niece. Why dont you take her and treat her as your own? It would be like having a 3rd child.
i know i would do that.

you want a 3rd child she s your niece and you dont want her to gi in foster carers if you cant help it.

Sorry OP i dont get what is the issue

On the basis of this post, I’m not surprised you don’t understand.

Clonakilla · 09/05/2026 00:07

TheBlueKoala · 08/05/2026 11:36

Well here you got yourself baby number 3. I couldn't live with myself making a baby while at the same time rejecting this poor baby who is already here.

This silly guilt-tripping hyperbole is so insightless. Everyone who has a baby is doing so instead of fostering a child.

I’ve been a foster carer. The need is endless. I invite you and the other PP who would think about this baby for the ‘rest of her life’ to put your money where you mouth is and become foster carers for all the children whose stories you haven’t read.

OP there’s so much to think about. Ultimately if you don’t want to, you don’t want to. It’s not just ok, it’s essential, to say no to something you don’t feel you can do. Too much damage is done by dishonesty around this. I think I’d be sitting down with my husband to talk through all of the implications (including what you would do if she goes on to have another baby) and how he thinks it could work.

Pistachiocake · 09/05/2026 00:19

Sunisgettinganewhaton · 08/05/2026 10:56

Then oh needs to prepare to make himself available to parent the poor baby. He can't play the hero then expect your life to change.

The way I read it, OP works from home and has flexibility, her OH doesn't, and presumably they can't afford to lose his wage? Maybe he could find another job, but that's not easy right now, and depending on his field, would he be able to work flexibly/at home OP? Obviously that's something the two of you would need to discuss.

Italiangreyhound · 09/05/2026 00:25

OP i just wanted to wish you all the best with this difficult decision.

Andthatmyfriendisthat · 09/05/2026 00:25

A man you're not married to wants you to adopt a baby you're not related to and become forever embroiled in his family's issues and tied to a woman with mental health issues, as well as being unable to try for your own much anticipated third baby, while being expected to mother a baby you are not related to with no guarantees of any kind moving forward.

You don't want to do this.

So the answer is, unequivocally and very simply - No.

echt · 09/05/2026 00:25

Duckswaddle · 08/05/2026 22:45

I would never forgive myself for letting a tiny baby into the foster care system when I could help.
What a fantastic home and life you could give them.

Unless you've actually done this, you really don't get to say this.

Not one thought for the OP here, just sentimental maundering.

Andthatmyfriendisthat · 09/05/2026 00:27

Clonakilla · 09/05/2026 00:07

This silly guilt-tripping hyperbole is so insightless. Everyone who has a baby is doing so instead of fostering a child.

I’ve been a foster carer. The need is endless. I invite you and the other PP who would think about this baby for the ‘rest of her life’ to put your money where you mouth is and become foster carers for all the children whose stories you haven’t read.

OP there’s so much to think about. Ultimately if you don’t want to, you don’t want to. It’s not just ok, it’s essential, to say no to something you don’t feel you can do. Too much damage is done by dishonesty around this. I think I’d be sitting down with my husband to talk through all of the implications (including what you would do if she goes on to have another baby) and how he thinks it could work.

Right. Every person on this thread trying to guilt the OP is a bad person, because they chose to procreate rather than adopting.

Or, OP has a perfect right to say no to adopting a baby that is being forced on her by a man she is not married to.

It's one or the other I'm afraid.

MilkyLeonard · 09/05/2026 00:34

LBFseBrom · 08/05/2026 18:32

Do you really need baby No 3, Milkshakess? This little baby could be your no 3. See her, hold her and gauge how you feel about her.

Your husband will have to step up too.

It would be nice for nephew to have a baby sister and at 18, he can help out.

Go carefully and be sure before you make any decisions but I think it would be worth a try. Bless her little heart.

Pass me a bucket 🤮

Tigerbalmshark · 09/05/2026 00:46

Aluna · 08/05/2026 12:40

The real world in which parents in tribal communities take on relatives’ children without so much hoo ha; where they don’t have a conception of “orphan” as we understand it as the wider family or the tribe take responsibility for the child; they have a great deal less money and resources than in the west.

The real world where adoption into a foreign family is traumatic however well meant; where contact with the birth parents is maintained in many cases these days unless a very good reason eg abuse or criminality.

You’ve mentioned “tribal communities” a couple of times, and “tribal communities” vary so much that that is a pretty meaningless description. A NW Canadian First Nations tribe and an East African tribe don’t really have anything in common culturally.

In which specific tribe are all babies seen as completely interchangeable, and parents barely know which children are theirs and which are other people’s?

Because every tribe I am aware of places great stock on ancestry and parentage (that is kind of the point to being a member of a tribe). Of course I don’t know every tribe in the world, so I’m interested to know which one sees all babies as communal property and it doesn’t really matter who is the parent and who brings them up. It isn’t a common cultural practice.

Tigerbalmshark · 09/05/2026 00:51

IfYouNeedMeAskYourFather · 08/05/2026 22:41

I agree with others, adopt this baby and it now baby 3

The baby is not even up for adoption!

covilha · 09/05/2026 01:05

@milkshakess - difficult to vote as I am not sure of your marital stays. If oh is your husband then I think you should go for custody as child is part of your family.
If oh is not your husband then I think it is unfair on you to have to look after this child in addition to your own.
I know even in a marriage you could divorce but the marriage changes your status, confers rights as part of the family and hence a responsibility to family members

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.