Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband, our Saturday together - aibu for improvising our day together instead of planning more?

97 replies

Happywhen · 03/05/2026 09:12

I’ve previously posted about my husband, his activities and trying to keep one Saturday a month spending time together, as he has his daughter every weekend day bar this Saturday, as well as time in the week, and has multiple hobbies on weekdays.

So yesterday was the Saturday. In the morning we took his elderly mother to the airport as she was going to visit her family. She was nervous and wanted help at the airport so my husband agreed to take her. I get on really well with his mother so I also went. We got back at 2pm.

He then asked me what I had planned. I said I was going to look for something for us to do, as I’d originally planned a day trip somewhere but was too late when we got back. I was looking on my phone and suggesting things to do, everything I said he said “I don’t mind”. Eventually we went somewhere and then got food. Got the impression all day he was tired/in a mood but didn’t say anything.

During the meal his brother called and said he’d felt left out of the airport trip and they needed to talk. Husband left me at the restaurant and went to his brothers for around 2 hours. I explicitly said to him “it’s not ideal but you’re being put in a difficult situation”. His brother and I don’t get along, and he’s been vile towards his mother, so I said along the lines of, he’s positioning himself as badly done to, but he’s created this situation himself.

husband got home around 7. We needed a weekly shop so we went to get it. We were laughing around the shop, all fine.

Around midnight after watching a series together, he snapped and said “you went on and on about this Saturday together, and what did we do? Went to a museum and had food?”

I said I didn’t want a grand plan, just time together. He said I asked you to plan something, that would have been nice for me. He got irritate, shouting and hitting his head. He said I should’ve planned something he’d enjoy, and I was in a mood because he had to go to his brothers, he said “I have to spend time with you in the week, at the weekend, all the time”

He was so angry. I said I didn’t plan anything as we were planning on going the airport, he said you’ve had weeks.

I left the room as the shouting came from nowhere and eventually cried myself to sleep.

Aibu? I was quieter after his brother rang because I think his brother creates drama and the family have to placate him. But I wasn’t moody with him, the evening carried on as usual when he came home. Aibu to not have planned a big elaborate day, and improvised on the day?

OP posts:
Pippin2017 · 03/05/2026 09:16

Well, there'd have been no point planning a big elaborate day only to have to cancel because of airport duties. Your H sounds like a selfish nob, tbh, what with his hobbies and being at his brother's beck and call. Are you happy in your relationship generally?

JacknDiane · 03/05/2026 09:18

Honestly life is too short for this shit. Relationships that take this much thought and effort are plain hard work and not worth having.
Think how much easier life would be alone op.

Duckiewasthefirstniceguy · 03/05/2026 09:19

I think you guys need counselling or something. None of this is normal or healthy.

  • I don’t get why you didn’t plan something or at least have a list of options.
  • I don’t get why HE couldn’t plan something or have a list of options.
  • I don’t get why none of this was discussed until you got home - not even during the trip back?
  • I don’t get why you appear to have to make a case for your husband to spend time with you.
  • I don’t get why going to the airport is an event requiring multiple adults.
  • Why does it require both of you to do a food shop?
  • Why was he hitting himself in the head?!

ETA: I’ve now seen your previous thread. This man does not like you.

DisplayPurposesOnly · 03/05/2026 09:20

He got irritate, shouting and hitting his head.

Is this someone you want to stay married to?

StationJack · 03/05/2026 09:21

Get rid.

TheFunFriend · 03/05/2026 09:21

Why was he hitting his own head during the argument? That’s weird enough without the picking an argument out of nowhere. Were you drinking?

Poppingby · 03/05/2026 09:23

Is it normal for you to be constantly gauging his mood or was it just today? You describe his mood at every chance. I realise it might be to explain that the shouting came out of nowhere but really if you're having to do that, you're treading on eggshells and that is not a nice way to live.

Saying he 'has' to spend time with you is mean. If you think he doesn't want to spend time with you at all or doesn't engage with you as if you're in a relationship you need to talk about this. Think about what you want so it's clear in your mind. What are some non negotiable a for you? Then rather than tell him this so him what he thinks your relationship should look like. Maybe you can get somewhere in the middle. But it's possible the two things - what you want and what he thinks should be happening - can never align isn't it?

ProudPearl · 03/05/2026 09:23

This is so far from normal! Leave him and build a nice life for yourself. Imagine waking up at weekends, doing whatever pleases you and not being yelled at!
Life is too short to tie yourself to an arsehole!

MermaidsSideEye · 03/05/2026 09:23

What @Duckiewasthefirstniceguy said. This all sounds deeply mysterious, and your DH sounds deeply unpleasant, yet you seem to have to make a case to get him to spend time with you, and then provide entertainment to his liking if he does?

Starzinsky · 03/05/2026 09:29

Making a big deal about this one day a month ring fenced as together time, creates both pressure, expectations and is not that practical given weekend time is also catch-up on jobs time for working people.

meganorks · 03/05/2026 09:30

It doesn't sound like he even likes you. He is actively avoiding spending time with you. My guess is his annoyance was him suddenly thinking 'I could have done hobby xxxx and had a much better time'. You shouldn't have to have something big planned to spend time with your husband. And you did plan something but then spent most of the day at the airport! And did he really leave you sat in a restaurant to run to his brother?! He shouldn't even have taken the call in the restaurant ffs!

FYI - my husband has never spoken to me like this. We enjoy spending time together. We rarely have any big plans, just decide on the day. Usually based around eating!

Gardenquestion22 · 03/05/2026 09:33

I’m not sure you are very compatible. Honestly it shouldn’t be this hard and he should want to spend time with you. He also sounds like an arse.

Topjoe19 · 03/05/2026 09:34

This is no way to live.

Happywhen · 03/05/2026 09:35

I can’t reply to the original post but no, we don’t drink.

OP posts:
Happywhen · 03/05/2026 09:36

When he said “I have to spend time with you in the evenings and the weekends”, I said you don’t have to. You don’t have to continue a relationship.

I think from the beginning he was upset because he had to cancel golf so either way he’d have reacted like this.

OP posts:
Comtesse · 03/05/2026 09:37

Oh that tosser? A special family trip to the airport? Mmm lovely.

What the hell is wrong with him? He is just rubbish.

cestlavielife · 03/05/2026 09:39

Just leave
You can never win.
He will never be happy.
Move on

meganorks · 03/05/2026 09:40

Just read your other post (not all the replies etc). It absolutely sounds like he has you to help parent his child and nothing more. Without you there he would have to do all the work caring for and entertaining his child. And he wouldn't be able to do his hobbies while she is there. Let me guess, you plan/prepare everything for her visits (probably says on the other thread to be fair)

He never 'chooses' you. He doesn't see spending time with you as important. He thinks he sees enough of you being in the same house. Honestly, I'd leave. I couldn't spend my life knowing the person I'm with would always pick anything or anyone else rather than spend time with me.

Duckiewasthefirstniceguy · 03/05/2026 09:41

Happywhen · 03/05/2026 09:36

When he said “I have to spend time with you in the evenings and the weekends”, I said you don’t have to. You don’t have to continue a relationship.

I think from the beginning he was upset because he had to cancel golf so either way he’d have reacted like this.

You get that your husband should actually want to spend time with you, right? It shouldn’t be something you need to argue about or force him to do.

If he’s in a mood because he’s had to spend time with you, as opposed to doing something he actually enjoys, then your relationship is dead. Being with you is meant to be a thing that he enjoys. Otherwise, what’s the point of your relationship for either of you?

You don’t have kids with him, he seems to actively dislike you, and you spend your time parenting his kid and begging him to give you the crumbs of his attention. Is this the life you want? As you have the option of walking away.

BitOutOfPractice · 03/05/2026 09:42

So everything depends on his mood, doing what he likes, keeping him happy, treading carefully around him, gauging his reaction?

As demonstrated by the multiple threads about this, he hasn’t change, he won’t change, he doesn’t want to change.

StandOutSpace · 03/05/2026 09:43

Reading this one and your last thread-
Get out. Seriously.
The way he behaved yesterday is shocking. If my dh bro called him when we were out he would actually either ignore the call or have a quick chat saying soz didnt know you wanted to go airport. speak to mum and take her next time yourself 👍
2 hours away from you to chat about that?! What!?

PygmyOwl · 03/05/2026 09:43

He is awful. He wants you to plan something that would be nice for him when he never ever does anything nice for you.

TheNoisyGreyLion · 03/05/2026 09:44

I’m struggling to understand why you want to spend time with him, because he sounds utterly vile.

Morepositivemum · 03/05/2026 09:45

You’re both too busy and have too many expectations, we can be the same, you know there’s this one glorious day so you want it to be worth all the days ye’ve missed together- it’s why I think holidays are mostly stressful- right we’ve been working towards this, it’s to be amazing!!!!

Saying that my god he lost it, I’m hoping it was a build up/ breakdown thing, which to be fair makes sense if he was tired starting the day and then did an airport run, had it out with his brother etc. Hope ye get it sorted out op x