Help end medical misogyny. Sign our petition.

Help end medical misogyny.
Sign our petition.

Sign the petition

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Another child killed by a dog...

900 replies

tnorfotkcab · 09/04/2026 22:08

Another poor child is killed by a dog.... We already know this is an XL Bully, don't even have to wait for confirmation.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/ce35zkl9dg3o

A Google street view of Hardale Grove. It is a residential cul-de-sac with cars parked on the pavement.

Child dies in Redcar dog attack, police say

Police remain at the scene in Dormanstown, where one dog was destroyed earlier.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/ce35zkl9dg3o

OP posts:
Thread gallery
28
tnorfotkcab · 10/04/2026 19:37

One witness claimed one of the dogs was a pocket bully and was running around.
Seems like that was the one that wasn't shot?we do know the other one, just something about a "standoff"

OP posts:
BackToLurk · 10/04/2026 19:37

AcquadiP · 10/04/2026 19:12

What they choose to do in America is not my concern. The evidence in the UK has been crystal clear: the American Pit Bull Terrier and the XL Bully have both caused significantly higher human fatalities in a relatively short period of time than any of the other 220+ breeds.

If you want to reduce harm then you follow the evidence. The evidence globally is that breed specific legislation doesn’t work. There are better strategies, such as licensing, compulsory training and restrictions on breeding.

FishingInTheRiversOfLife · 10/04/2026 19:40

BackToLurk · 10/04/2026 19:37

If you want to reduce harm then you follow the evidence. The evidence globally is that breed specific legislation doesn’t work. There are better strategies, such as licensing, compulsory training and restrictions on breeding.

Does the mauling beast know its been licensed and decides oh, I'd better not maul anyone now that my idiot owner got a piece of paper about me?

You can not train the aggression out of these dogs any more than you can train a herding dog not to herd.

FishingInTheRiversOfLife · 10/04/2026 22:09

BackToLurk · 10/04/2026 19:47

A staffy type isn’t a SBT, and neither is a Jack Russell or a bull terrier.

Is that all you've got to say? Several examples of maulings by SBTs and you are quibbling over 'staffy type'? They are all bully breed demon monstrosities. NOT worth the maulings they dish out. Sure, they are all a bit mongrel, but we all know the type - blocky dented head, ugly pig eyes, slobbery hanging mouth.

OonaStubbs · 10/04/2026 22:32

Just ban all dogs, then there would be no arguments over which breeds should be banned, is that dog really a banned breed etc etc. It would save so many lives.

AcquadiP · 10/04/2026 22:36

BackToLurk · 10/04/2026 19:37

If you want to reduce harm then you follow the evidence. The evidence globally is that breed specific legislation doesn’t work. There are better strategies, such as licensing, compulsory training and restrictions on breeding.

The best strategy is to not allow the situation to arise in the first place by banning the importation of breeds which have a terrible reputation. Horse, stable door.

Scampiniknak · 10/04/2026 22:44

Seen this story doing the rounds on social media and the comments are staggering. One person actually said ‘two sides to every story’ along with the usual ‘I own an XL and they are so soft, blame the owners.’

Honestly the stupidity of some people is staggering.

TheKittenswithMittens · 10/04/2026 23:04

I was bitten by a dog whilst out jogging last weekend in my local woods. I have been in pain for a couple of days. I will get over it. But what gets me is how the owners bolted and left me there. I have got a massive bruise on my right thigh. They don't fucking care. Sorry about that, and they fucked off.

LooneyLiberalSpaceWaster · 11/04/2026 00:51

FishingInTheRiversOfLife · 10/04/2026 22:09

Is that all you've got to say? Several examples of maulings by SBTs and you are quibbling over 'staffy type'? They are all bully breed demon monstrosities. NOT worth the maulings they dish out. Sure, they are all a bit mongrel, but we all know the type - blocky dented head, ugly pig eyes, slobbery hanging mouth.

SBT are small dogs, can not be compared with "staffies" which applies to "Staffie" looking dogs which are much larger and quite strangely many look just like pitbull terriers, because that is exactly what many of them are.

I'm in two minds about BSL. Clearly it isn't working. I think pitbull type "staffie dogs," have slipped through the net, and american Bully dogs have been badly bred. Many have health problems and they appeal to idiots. However as one type or breed is banned another becomes desirable to these idiots. Cane corso and Pressa are now popular. Where does it end? And for those calling to ban all "bully" breeds I would like as ask them to explain what they mean by bully breeds. Do they mean american bully or all bull breed dogs? Or any cross breed? I mean, who would seriously ban boston terriers on the basis of safety?

If we ban and euthanise american bully dogs (xl, pocket and standard) not only do we erradicate this menace and it might help to stop the hysteria around other bull breeds. However the idiots who want tough looking dogs will continue to burn through the breeds choosing mastifs and other bull breeds such as EBT. Or even just buy great danes or large guardian dogs. Where would it end?

Dogo Argentino was banned in the uk having never put a paw on UK soil. A dog that is far more balanced than any XL. However much I admire their spirit and beautiful looks I concede that no UK home could offer a dogo the life for which it was bred. This can not be said of other long established bull breeds that have had the fight bred out over many generations.

One last point, bull breeds were actively bred to show no agression to humans. Even when dog fighting was legal. The owners had to be able to intervene in the pit. Dogs that showed agression to humans were put down as they couldnt be used, and they were not used for breeding. On the other hand guardian breeds that have been bred to be suspicious of strangers are often a bigger threat, and the idiot owners are now sniffing about dogs like mallonois which can be extremely dangerous.

CymruChris · 11/04/2026 01:05

Its the sheer strength of these dogs that terrifies me. Reports that dogs shot by police are shot multiple times before they stop...what chance does an unarmed person have in their home?

I find it interesting that lovers of the bully type dogs claim they are "big softies" "family dogs". But they purposefully have sought out a breed known for its size and strength. The advertising is always similar.

Also to add, this is an interesting (and horrifying) read - someone up thread mentioned many xl bullies being linked to the same dog.
https://banthebullyxluk.wordpress.com/2023/08/01/finding-kimbo/

It appears that inbreeding is a desirable quality and breeders purposefully breed for size and strength. I typed pocket bully breeder into Facebook and this was the first thing that came up - proudly stating "true inbred". Sickening.

Another child killed by a dog...
IsEveryUserNameBloodyTaken · 11/04/2026 01:05

Jenkibuble · 10/04/2026 11:06

I watched Panorama too - the law is not worth the paper it is written on (the breed specifics / head dimensions and height etc)

As a result, many dogs did not fall under the remit .

Additionally, banning one breed will cause another one to take its place !

The guy at the end of the programme nailed it - licences for ALL dogs need to be issued like they are for guns. Any responsible owner would not object to this !

As a runner/walker the number of yappy dogs that snap at my ankles irritate me nearly as much as the tragic cases of deaths. But of course they have the 'cute ' factor !

How will licences speed up the elimination of these dogs.

mrsCtheRed · 11/04/2026 01:07

CymruChris · 11/04/2026 01:05

Its the sheer strength of these dogs that terrifies me. Reports that dogs shot by police are shot multiple times before they stop...what chance does an unarmed person have in their home?

I find it interesting that lovers of the bully type dogs claim they are "big softies" "family dogs". But they purposefully have sought out a breed known for its size and strength. The advertising is always similar.

Also to add, this is an interesting (and horrifying) read - someone up thread mentioned many xl bullies being linked to the same dog.
https://banthebullyxluk.wordpress.com/2023/08/01/finding-kimbo/

It appears that inbreeding is a desirable quality and breeders purposefully breed for size and strength. I typed pocket bully breeder into Facebook and this was the first thing that came up - proudly stating "true inbred". Sickening.

This is both sickening and chilling

IsEveryUserNameBloodyTaken · 11/04/2026 01:14

Usernumber36373647323 · 10/04/2026 10:25

awful awful news, it seems to happen all too often. I’ve heard of a story in the last week where an XL attacked and killed a smaller dog unprovoked, it had escaped from the house and went for the smaller dog who was with owner! When a child/adult/dog gets killed it’s nearly always a bully breed!

This happens many many times.So often indeed that there are groups set up to guide and commiserate with the poor owners.Guide them in trying to get justice with the police and courts.Sadly a well known advocate for the breed or rather type shall we say (Ms Marland) actually takes it upon herself to troll and bully the group all over social media, which makes it more difficult as people end up not wanting her unwanted attention in a difficult time in their life.

IsEveryUserNameBloodyTaken · 11/04/2026 01:28

RubyFlax · 10/04/2026 11:36

Wholeheartedly agree with you, as a dog owner myself who has put hours and hundreds, possibly even thousand's of pounds in to ensuring mine are well trained, fulfilled, happy and well rounded it frustrates me massively that anyone can own a dog & there is no requirement to train it or be accountable for its behaviour.

Mine is not a dangerous type breed at all, we have a spaniel - a very popular pet in the UK despite being a very high energy working breed, and people honestly do not do enough breed specific research before they take a dog into their lives.

A huge proportion of spaniels that end up in rescue have bitten people (or snapped without making contact) as they are prone to resource guarding. This can be guarding anything from “high value” items such as their food to things we perceive to be low value such as a pair of socks or a tea towel. Carrying items & wanting to retrieve & sniff (hunt) was literally bred into them as a working breed of dog, and yet millions of families get a spaniel puppy with ZERO regard to what they’re bred to do. They then wonder why their dog constantly picks their shoes up or steal the tv remote to carry around in their mouth, all whilst giving them no safe & appropriate outlet to express their inbuilt working “drive”. It only takes a few times of snatching that item back off the dog or telling them off for “stealing” shoes/socks whatever, and the resource guarding then starts. It all could have been prevented if people just understood their dogs and trained them / worked with them in a breed specific way!!!

The difference between a spaniel and an XL is what they’ve been bred to do. The XL ancestry is fighting dogs. Give that to some clueless muppet who wants to look hard, who has no clue about breed specific behaviour and appropriate training and it’s an absolute recipe for disaster.

All dogs should be licensed in the UK and it should be mandatory to have at least 3rd party liability insurance.

Edited

Correct me if I’m wrong but I believe 3rd party liability insurance was being offered for these dogs (XL’s) by Dogs Trust as a condition by Defra of having the dogs. This came in from the date of banning.
Unfortunately Dogs Trust have now withdrawn from the scheme.

IsEveryUserNameBloodyTaken · 11/04/2026 01:56

LordofMisrule1 · 10/04/2026 12:23

I've noticed that since the 'ban', a lot of the deaths are no longer random strangers on the street, but family members in the home. Hopefully this means that the muzzling is working. Still wouldn't willingly be near an XL bully in a muzzle as I've seen some people with plastic ones and it would take them seconds to tear through that. But it's a positive that only the morons dumb enough to adopt these animals are suffering. Just heartbreaking that their children have to pay the price.

Yes I believe that was the idea to protect the public.
Unfortunately you can’t legislate for stupid and therefore the ones dying and being mauled are within the home of the owner.
I will add though that I think it is imperative that children when they go to a friends house after school that they do not go anywhere near a house that has one of these dogs.
Jack Lis the 10 year old that was killed by an XL bully after going to a friends house after school.
His injuries were such that he could only be identified by his shoes.

GlovedhandsCecilia · 11/04/2026 03:11

Frequency · 10/04/2026 16:23

And he is trained, but if my reply had been "I can control him because he is trained to come, sit, down, stay, come to my side and press his nose to my palm, and settle on command," posters would have accepted that or would they have insisted that one day his training will fail and he will eat me?

The harness and head collar are secondary tools to his training and are there as a "just in case" rather than something I put all of my faith into or rely on fully. He does pull on his lead, so the head collar helps with that.

I could train him to not pull, but a) it doesn't bother me, and b) he will come to my side and put his nose to my palm when I need him under close control, such as when we are passing a child, so I don't feel like resolving the pulling is a massive priority. I'd prefer to spend time playing scent games with him and teaching him useful things like putting his toys away and closing doors after he opens them. I might get around to teaching him heel one day, I might not.

The reason you discourage pulling is because it's part of promoting impulse control. It means they are having to focus on you the whole time and are less likely to be distracted by other things. It keeps them in the zone.

FitAt50 · 11/04/2026 06:40

As soon as I saw the headline I knew it would on some dodgy estate. These never seem to happen in 'nice areas' and habitually always seem to be the pets of rough types.

PartQualifiedAcca · 11/04/2026 06:47

FitAt50 · 11/04/2026 06:40

As soon as I saw the headline I knew it would on some dodgy estate. These never seem to happen in 'nice areas' and habitually always seem to be the pets of rough types.

A friend has got a proper Doberman guard dog that wouldn’t actually kill anybody but it would chase you until the ends of the Earth. It’s far better than any police helicopter or German Shepherd. This thing is relentless.
But it’s been trained and handled so well that once it’s found you it just pinned you to the ground and waits for help to arrive. It wouldn’t hurt a hair on your head.
He keeps it extremely well fed and looked after because the dog cost him 40 grand
If people want animals for security reasons that’s the calibre you’re looking for
These Excel bullies. I always think look half starved. They can’t be fed on a normal person’s income. It costs a fortune

Imdunfer · 11/04/2026 08:14

tnorfotkcab · 10/04/2026 19:37

One witness claimed one of the dogs was a pocket bully and was running around.
Seems like that was the one that wasn't shot?we do know the other one, just something about a "standoff"

In reports today two dogs were shot and a man has been arrested.

I'm seeing a few bullies that are just under the height limit to be an American Bully and therefore not subject to the legislation.

If this is anything like horse showing, they will be teaching these dogs how to measure under.

I met one the other day, unmuzzled, clearly an American Bully at maximum height allowed. As the owner walked towards me he put the dog against a wall and stuck his knee into the base of its neck, preventing it from running forwards because of the width of the shoulders behind his knee.

These killing machines are still on the streets.

IsEveryUserNameBloodyTaken · 11/04/2026 08:36

EvangelicalAboutButteredToast · 10/04/2026 12:34

And the last one I read about did exactly that and they killed her.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c3gg6zql03eo

Edited

Ah yes and that was the one where the video did indeed show one of her arms being pulled off by one of the two attacking dogs as confirmed by her parent.
She did a video singing to her dog with the words something like “I don’t give a fuck what you think about my dog”

JackieLeeOhmyDarlinNsoul · 11/04/2026 08:37

IsEveryUserNameBloodyTaken · 11/04/2026 08:36

Ah yes and that was the one where the video did indeed show one of her arms being pulled off by one of the two attacking dogs as confirmed by her parent.
She did a video singing to her dog with the words something like “I don’t give a fuck what you think about my dog”

Bloody hell!!

ChimpanzeeThatMonkeyNews · 11/04/2026 08:45

BackToLurk · 10/04/2026 19:37

If you want to reduce harm then you follow the evidence. The evidence globally is that breed specific legislation doesn’t work. There are better strategies, such as licensing, compulsory training and restrictions on breeding.

And people never break the rules and the law, of course. 🙄
They’ll only get a slap on the wrist if they do. So, it’s pointless.

Swipe left for the next trending thread