Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think my brother-in-law and partner are copying us?

130 replies

maria199 · 04/04/2026 23:55

I feel like my husband’s brother and his partner are ‘copying’ us. My husband’s older brother is known to copy him and has done throughout his life. It really annoys my husband but he is often told to try to not let it bother him. Now I feel I am noticing a bit of a pattern with him and his partner and I don’t know if I am being unreasonable to feel like this?

Our daughter was born at the end of October (our first baby) and when I was pregnant we had shared names we liked. One of the names was a boy name that was very meaningful to me and I was told at the time that was their “favourite name” and what they would call their baby (they were not pregnant). My husband said another boys name he liked and then suddenly a couple of weeks later that was the name they were going to call their hypothetical baby. We ended up having a girl and forgot all about it. They have announced they are having a baby due mid November and a boys name for them is the name my husband said he liked. I don’t care as we definitely cannot gatekeep names, but it’s just a thing to add to the ‘copying’.

I had a miscarriage 2 months before being pregnant with my daughter, so when I was pregnant with her we got 2 early scans as I was very anxious (I calmed down a lot later on in pregnancy). They have had an early scan and have another one booked in 2 weeks. Again, completely their right and nothing to do with me but it’s just another thing.

Last Easter we announced my pregnancy to our family at the family meal (I was 12 weeks) and then this year at the family Easter meal they have announced theirs (around 8 weeks pregnant). Again, nothing to do with me when people announce but just another thing.

My husband and I are married but I kept my name and our daughter has my name as this was something I was clear I wanted. Today at lunch they said that the baby will not have my brother-in-law’s name but will take his partners name. Again fine, but it’s another thing.

My daughter has gorgeous red hair, neither me or my husband have red hair at all. At lunch my brother-in-law’s partner was saying she’s a natural red head and the baby will likely come out ginger. An odd comment to make I feel?

When they told us about their pregnancy they told us the day they found out and followed it by saying that the baby will be almost exactly a year after ours and that’s what they wanted. At the time I thought nothing of it, but again looking back it seems like an odd comment to make.

They mentioned some prams they looked at and one of the ones they like is the one we have. Again, I can’t gatekeep a pram but it’s just another thing.

I am very happy for them and looking forward to meeting my niece/nephew in the future. We get on very well and my husband and his brother are close. It just seems a lot things seem similar and I guess I’m not sure if I’m just being very self-centred in thinking this is a bit of ‘copying’ and therefore being unreasonable, or whether this just seems like a bunch of coincidences.

OP posts:
Bake · 05/04/2026 07:03

Are you suffering from PND or PN Anxiety?

I don't see any of this as copying. Are your husband's examples of his brother 'copying' similarly tenuous?

StrawberrySundaes · 05/04/2026 07:05

You were silly to share names with them if you thought they like to copy you. Have they copied other pivotal things (house buying, location etc)?

Early on my BIL and his wife copied us incessantly. BIL would wear the same clothes (colour & brand), we would move cities and they would follow, we bought a house and even though they weren’t thinking of this they bought a house a few streets away about 3 months after us. We got engaged and 4 months later they did. After our wedding they booked the same venue, reception and photographer etc, If we bought a home appliance sure enough they would buy the same thing. We moved overseas and within a year they wanted to move over where we were (even got visas ready but they had financial issues that stopped that idea). We moved countries again and sure enough they moved over within 12 months. They now live a couple of suburbs away. It was a joke amongst immediate family members at the time.

There is no more copying now since children came along, in part because we are in a totally different income bracket. I purposefully put my son in a different school to theirs (partly as I wanted separation but also there were some other things my school offered that my son would enjoy).

TheTortiePuffinNeedsHerBreakfast · 05/04/2026 07:11

It does sound a bit odd. I agree with PP - share less with them, they only have the information you give them.

Hohumitsreallyallthereis · 05/04/2026 07:13

It’s in your head but the easiest way to solve it regardless is to not share things like baby names if it bugs you so much!

TikTokker · 05/04/2026 07:14

None of these examples are standing out as copying. You’re not the main character in anyone else’s life.

SardinesOnButteredToast · 05/04/2026 07:18

I really dislike copycats but most of this is so absolutely common, or so unconnected to you (a natural redhead mother remarking that her baby will likely be red haired), that I'm afraid you're over reaching with this one. I'd chalk it up to you just don't like them that much. That's fine. Individual preference is entirely valid.

Jaggy1 · 05/04/2026 07:23

I don’t think you can be surprised that someone you know has a history for copying his brother is now… copying his brother.

Riapia · 05/04/2026 07:23

Imitation is the most sincere form of flattery. 😉.

Dragracer · 05/04/2026 07:27

They sound like normal people getting on with their lives doing normal things people in the same stage of life as you do.

You sound obsessed with them and very self centered.

Next you'll be saying you bought a house and then they copied you. I bet you started watching game of thrones and so did they. We put our child in nursery and so did they.

How about. Live your life, and let them live theirs. God I hope you haven't said any of this to anyone in real life, you must look quite pathetic if you have.

Imisscoffee2021 · 05/04/2026 07:28

These things don't sound specific enough to be total copying. Do they annoying you in other ways so you are clinging to these seemingly innocuous similarities?

Its totally normal to want to announce a baby at a family getntogether, and as Easter is the nearest for them then that made sense. They may want theirs and your kids close in age so they can play together as they're cousins. So far so normal. The red hair thing is also normal, everyone talks of what their baby may look like and as sil is a natural red head the baby may indeed have red hair ... that's not a copy of your daughter having red hair...

These are all quite innocent things, I lean a pram!? Again totally normal to see someone lses pram and like it enough to consider getting one for your child. You definitely are gate keeping and perhaps time to examine your and your husbands feeling as to why you guys feel this way towards family, do you like them generally?

pilates · 05/04/2026 07:31

It doesn’t sound like copying. Just live your life and don’t disclose important information to them.

supersop60 · 05/04/2026 07:34

CalmLemonCrab · 05/04/2026 00:32

Huh? Coping you because she got an early scan? I am astonished at how self centred some people are 😂

Agree. I got an early scan. OP - did you copy me?
And did they time the conception so precisely that the birth would be exactly a year later than yours?

Dollymylove · 05/04/2026 07:34

Stop telling them your plans, or at least throw in some decoys to put them off the scent 😅

MyDeftDuck · 05/04/2026 07:35

Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery……..but if you don’t want them to continue to copy you then STOP sharing every detail of your lives with them.

supersop60 · 05/04/2026 07:37

Re the red hair - it’s a recessive gene, which your DH and you both have. If your BIL also has it and your SiL is a natural redhead, then yes, the baby probably will be ginger. Cute red headed cousins!

RitaFires · 05/04/2026 07:40

If BIL has copied your husband in the past then it makes sense that that is influencing how you are interpreting things but some of your examples are such a reach that it undermines your point.

They haven't even got a pram yet, just mentioned that they'd like something like yours, if you have a really popular one like an Uppababy Vista you have even less of a leg to stand on.

You can take comfort in that your baby is so lovely that she may have influenced them to have their own, but trying to gatekeep early scans and hair colour is only going to stress you out over nothing.

Catcatcatcatcat · 05/04/2026 07:41

I was expecting a far more impressive list of copying than you have provided here. Very weak examples.

Never tell anyone about baby names you are considering.

TheBeaTgoeson1 · 05/04/2026 07:43

I think you need to get a hobby.

Moonnstarz · 05/04/2026 07:45

No I don't see them as copying. If anything assuming it's their first baby, then they have used you as an example of what to do e.g. make a big announcement at a family occasion, that it is ok to have early scans. Things like prams are hard to view these days (we have no baby shops near us anymore, everything would have to be bought online) so if they know yours is good (maybe they have even had a go pushing your little one in it) then why wouldn't they go for something they know someone else would recommend.
Names is annoying but unless it's something really rare then there is a possibility of them wanting it anyway and at least it's no surprise to you when the baby is born for them to be using what you feel is one of your names.

daisychain01 · 05/04/2026 07:48

Why are you telling them your business when you and your DH know they have form for copying. You're setting yourselves up,for a world of frustration and yet you keep doing it. You've only got yourselves to blame.

you clearly don't like your BIL

JontyGentooey · 05/04/2026 07:50

HelenaWaiting · 05/04/2026 04:35

Why? My cousin has the same name as my brother. No one minds and it hardly matters. Why are people so anal these days?

Because some people like my MIL feel entitled to give you their opinions if you share the name before the baby comes. We had a beautiful classic name for DD picked out, DH told her and she said oh dear I don't like that at all. We still used it but it did make me feel a bit sad at the time.

IME people are far less likely to give you rude comments when the baby has actually arrived and you say this is her name. With DD2 we didn't tell anyone till she was born. Lots of people asked but we just kept saying nope haven't thought of anything yet.

OP just start chucking out random names you DON'T like and see if they choose one of them.

Never understood that episode of Friends where Rachel asks Monica what her fave girl name is and then wants to use it. Monica absolutely knew she was going to do that, she should've just said any girl's name that wasn't Emma!

SoSadSoSadSoSad · 05/04/2026 07:51

If you really feel this way, then just keep schtum about most events like babies etc. just talk about the weather, cars etc.

It doesn’t sounds like copying to me.

Saynototheinevitable · 05/04/2026 07:56

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Overtheatlantic · 05/04/2026 07:57

It sounds like copying to me but they are a young couple navigating a new and anxious time in life. It sounds like they don’t have much confidence in their own decisions but they think you and your DH have paved the way fairly well. I would limit future information sharing as much as possible. I have a sister who used to do this, down to buying the same picture frame as I had and starting the same very niche hobby.

bandog · 05/04/2026 07:58

It’s normal! My sister in law has just bought the exact same pram as us because she liked ours and knew we were really happy with it… they were excited their child and ours will be only a year or so apart in age as hopefully it means they will be close… perhaps they are trying to bond with you over things they have in common? I can see how the name thing is a bit annoying but honestly just don’t tell people your favourites, as it might inspire someone else’s choices!