Best Amazon Prime Day deals: Mumsnet favourites

Best Amazon Prime Day deals:
Mumsnet favourites

Shop now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to worry about general public intelligence

146 replies

Collectivethoughts · 03/02/2026 00:08

Aibu to be worried about the intelligence of the general public?
I know intelligence is generally a bell curve with most people falling in the middle with minoritys falling either side.
Im in no way saying im extremely intelligent because im not but I would say i use critical thinking.
For example hearing other people in the supermarket over the weeks. People swearing at each other, stopping dead in the centre of an aisle so no one can get through and actually being oblivious to themselves blocking others. Some of the conversations I hear.
Then in my job, having to tell people how to parent when thats not really my job. Parents actually being clueless on what to do I.e seeking further help.
Recent political things. Some people think if they just shout loud it means they're correct without any critical thinking and weighing up sides, policies and mandates.
Im finding the general public harder and harder to be a part of and overly frustrating to be apart of as in finding most dont want to engage with any critical thinking.
Aibu?

OP posts:
Hoardasurass · 03/02/2026 07:51

@Collectivethoughts I'd say it has more to do with their inability to think critically than lack of intelligence.
We don't teach kids how to think critically nor to question any narrative that teachers, adults, friends or the Internet tells them.
They are only taught what they need to pass exams instead of why these things are correct and given a full understanding of the subject and it has seriously harmed them. The only subject that kids are taught is their rights and entitlements.
Whole generations have been failed as their education has been watered down as the concentration on exam results has become more important than a functional knowledge of the subjects.

5128gap · 03/02/2026 07:51

MandingoAteMyBaby · 03/02/2026 07:47

I live rurally, and the older generation here seem uniquely thick.

I reckon they were taken out of school early and worked on the farms, and it shows.

Its not exactly genius level thinking to believe that education is the same as intelligence.

Collectivethoughts · 03/02/2026 07:52

TwoLeftSocksWithHoles · 03/02/2026 01:27

I think today's society is doomed, but on the brightside the meercats appear to be pretty adept (based on their recent advertising campaigns) so why not let them have a go?

😂😂 love a meerkat

I feel we are slightly doomed. Its been ever since covid I feel.

OP posts:
Collectivethoughts · 03/02/2026 07:54

AuntieMatters · 03/02/2026 01:40

I apologise profusely for not using every last bit of my intelligence when wandering around a supermarket. You are right. I should be 100% focused at all times.

People are missing my point. These are a few examples. It would take me ages to list loads of various daily examples! These are cherry picked.

OP posts:
Wolmando · 03/02/2026 07:56

Do you shop in Asda

AuntieMatters · 03/02/2026 07:59

Collectivethoughts · 03/02/2026 07:54

People are missing my point. These are a few examples. It would take me ages to list loads of various daily examples! These are cherry picked.

Maybe you should have used more intelligence in picking your examples then?
If people are missing your point has it not occurred to you that perhaps you didn't make it clearly enough?

AuntieMatters · 03/02/2026 08:00

Hoardasurass · 03/02/2026 07:51

@Collectivethoughts I'd say it has more to do with their inability to think critically than lack of intelligence.
We don't teach kids how to think critically nor to question any narrative that teachers, adults, friends or the Internet tells them.
They are only taught what they need to pass exams instead of why these things are correct and given a full understanding of the subject and it has seriously harmed them. The only subject that kids are taught is their rights and entitlements.
Whole generations have been failed as their education has been watered down as the concentration on exam results has become more important than a functional knowledge of the subjects.

Speak for yourself.
In my experience all intelligent parents make sure their children are taught to think critically at home

Collectivethoughts · 03/02/2026 08:01

Friendlygingercat · 03/02/2026 01:53

The average national reading age is 9-11 years old.

Wow I didnt actually know that. I just googled and it said the Sun newspapers reading age is 8 and the Guardians is 14.

OP posts:
TappyGilmore · 03/02/2026 08:02

I think blocking the supermarket aisles comes down to being inconsiderate, as in they haven’t thought about how that impacts others, or simply not caring about the impact on others. Both of those things do seem to be on the rise in society. I don’t think either are connected to intelligence.

Use of swearing is just a shift in society where swear words are more socially acceptable. Again, nothing to do with lack of intelligence. I know my mother would say “people who swear do it because they can’t think of a more intelligent word to use” but I disagree as it becomes a normal part of people’s vocabulary with more widespread use.

LookingThroughGlass · 03/02/2026 08:04

Friendlygingercat · 03/02/2026 01:53

The average national reading age is 9-11 years old.

How is 'age 9-11' determined? Surely if it's the 'average national reading age' that means more adults read at that level than not, so it should be the 'average adult reading level' not a 'reading age of 9-11'.

NobodyFool · 03/02/2026 08:07

There seems to be a lack of emotional intelligence and ignorance of social norms here on MN. I don’t know whether it’s just that people are desperate to prove the OP wrong, or whether it is a real societal shift. Some people just don’t seem to know how to behave, how to be polite and considerate any more.

OvernightBloats · 03/02/2026 08:07

There are people around who are self-absorbed and rude but that doesn't mean that they are not intelligent.

Your opinion about parents needing education is misguided if you think it is all down to intelligence and not circumstances.

Your frustrations about people is not down to them being intelligent or not. Perhaps you should question why you think it is down to intelligence and not other factors.

Collectivethoughts · 03/02/2026 08:08

Meadowfinch · 03/02/2026 02:34

When even an experienced chief constable is fooled into giving false information to parliament, because a 3rd rate AI product invented a football match and presented it as fact, I think the general public can be forgiven for believing their browser.
That is what makes AI so very dangerous.

More than 50% of the UK's population do not reach A'level standard. They are not taught critical thinking. One in 6 UK adults is functionally illiterate.

I worked with the emergency services 20 years ago and some of it was painful. The levels of ignorance were initially astonishing and I wish more people understood what our public services have to cope with.

Imagine dealing with a medical emergency in a child when the parents believe in witchcraft or were more worried about their dog being left at home alone. (two I came across).

But no, yanbu to get frustrated.

Edited

I think thats what it is, ignorance. People unable to look at different points of view.
Even my parents are this way. They believe Reform and what they say is true in their eyes. They dont question if what they are told in life is a lie.
Plus yes I feel your pain. The job I work in I speak to alot of parents and the lack of common sense to keep children safe is staggering.

OP posts:
Hoardasurass · 03/02/2026 08:08

ThejustbrothersCarlenaNSoul · 03/02/2026 01:24

I do wonder about people who believe the poisonous garbage that spews lies and division.
Daily Mail
Farage ..man of the people🤣🤣
Tommy robinson..coke snorting racist git.
X.
Anyone thinking the above value ordinary people are very much mistaken.They only value their own kind fellow millionaires.
They get others to do the dirty work ,it's been a tactic of the extreme far right for decades.

And the extreme far left.
Anyone who thinks that Farage is more dangerous than Zachary polanski (sp) is failing to hold the far left to the same standards as the far right. Antifa are behaving more like the racists that they claim to fight than anyone on the far right. The Overton window has been pushed so far to the left that straight middle class white men are considered more vulnerable than women and children all because he claims a special identity.
No im not a fan of Farage (odious little toad of a man) in just recognise that the left are just as dangerous as the right.
Look up horse shoe theory and you'll have a better understanding of the harms of both the far left and right

honeylulu · 03/02/2026 08:09

I'd say it has more to do with their inability to think critically than lack of intelligence.

This is exactly what I was trying to put into words but @Hoardasurass put it perfectly.

I've noticed a huge rise in thoughtless, oblivious social behaviour since covid. People blocking aisles and footpaths in a big group stopping and having a conversation and then looking astonished and put out when you say excuse me to try and get past. Phones on loudspeaker on public transport and in the street etc. There were always some people like this but it's definitely worse now. It's as if the couple of years of lockdown led many people to just forget how to behave in public.

I don't think it has anything to do with intelligence/education though.

Also agree that some elements of life are now spoon fed and people haven't developed skills or been prompted to use their initiative to solve problems. So much of life can be serviced by the internet/technology. I am crap with directions for example but in the early 90s I had to do lots of driving from work. Would study the road atlas and understand the route and surrounds (in case of diversions). Now I don't even think about it. I just stick the sat nav on. Today I need to get my gel nails taken off but I can't seem to get the booking app to work and my brain is freaking out at the idea of having to actually phone up the salon and speak out loud rather than just press a few buttons on my phone.

Nevermind17 · 03/02/2026 08:09

Some of the most intelligent people I know (absolute boffins with PhDs) have little common sense, self-awareness, spatial awareness, etc. I think they’re so focused on their subjects that they don’t waste precious brain power noticing what’s going on around them.

But in general, I agree with your post. I’m no longer shocked by how low average intelligence is. I always told my DCs “Don’t worry. The average person isn’t that smart. As long as you work hard and you’ve got half a brain, you’ll still be head and shoulders above most people in the average workplace”. Now they’re working, they completely agree.

WeepingAngelInTheTardis · 03/02/2026 08:11

yes, the other day I was out shopping with my ds and there was a little girl with her parents, they had their backs turned ignoring her and she was struggling to put something on the shelf. I helped her and her parents didn’t even notice could easily of kidnapped her.
The supermarket thing drives me nuts! So many people stopping dead in the middle of the aisles at the end when they can see people qeueing to go down them! It’s very frustrating.

aLFIESMA · 03/02/2026 08:12

It's not the lack or decline of intelligence that worries me, more the lack of kindness.

Boomer55 · 03/02/2026 08:13

Surely things like aisle blocking and swearing loudly in supermarkets, is more about lack of manners than intelligence?

Intelligence is different to common sense or good manners. Plenty of highly intelligent people lack both manners and common sense. 🤷‍♀️

WeepingAngelInTheTardis · 03/02/2026 08:14

Hoardasurass · 03/02/2026 08:08

And the extreme far left.
Anyone who thinks that Farage is more dangerous than Zachary polanski (sp) is failing to hold the far left to the same standards as the far right. Antifa are behaving more like the racists that they claim to fight than anyone on the far right. The Overton window has been pushed so far to the left that straight middle class white men are considered more vulnerable than women and children all because he claims a special identity.
No im not a fan of Farage (odious little toad of a man) in just recognise that the left are just as dangerous as the right.
Look up horse shoe theory and you'll have a better understanding of the harms of both the far left and right

Farage is more dangerous, he appears in the Epstein files. We exiled Andrew, yet Farage is basically a n*nce and it’s acceptable. It is very worrying how dim people can be supporting a person like that, yet if one lived in their street they would set fire to their house!

Collectivethoughts · 03/02/2026 08:18

RedTagAlan · 03/02/2026 05:53

I personally dislike the term "critical thinking". For me, in many discussions it's a red flag.

I am sure we can all agree, intelligence and knowledge are not the same thing. And intelligence has nothing to do with manners, cultural differences, indoctrination etc. And if we say intelligence is the ability to "figure things out", as opposed to repeating or learning by rote (although that forms skill), then I reckon we can split intelligence into separate types We see how it works- fantastic at applying maths but can't work out how to assemble a flat pack cupboard.

So we have intelligence, knowledge, and skill. Memory can be slotted into knowledge here I think, but memories work different from person to person.

And these are all intertwined, categories sub divided, linked in different ways, in a pretty much infinite amount of combinations.

"You're all individuals"

"Yes, we are all individuals"

"You are all different"

"Yes we are all different"

"I'm not"

:-)

So for me, when I think of the premise of " critical thinking" and I apply "critical thinking" to my thought process of thinking about it, taking into account the variations mentioned above, I reach my conclusion that it is only a valid premise where the data input is complete and irrefutable, and the natural laws applied to the data are proven.

So, "critical thinking" works when debating a flat earther. But it appears to me to be practically useless for more abstract stuff, like economics.

And that is why I do not like the term " critical thinking". I think, but I am open to debate on it :-)

Critical thinking re blocking supermarket aisles ? Hmm. I need to think about that.

No i agree and I am open to debate too.

I agree with you around different types of intelligence. You can also add emotional intelligence in too. I think perhaps what I meant was I find is frustrating for those people who lack any kind of skill to be aware of anything around them or to think of different points of view.

When i said think critically to me I just mean to take different opinions/views to come to their own conclusion and not just blindly follow a group because thats what other people say.

OP posts:
Collectivethoughts · 03/02/2026 08:21

RhaenysRocks · 03/02/2026 07:00

I don't think the op's post is especially good but I agree with her basic premise.

On fb threads about education, the inability to understand quite simple concepts like INSET days coming off what were teachers holidays, not term days or teachers being paid in 12 equal installments does not mean we're paid for 13 weeks holiday is quite infuriating. I appreciate someone might post not knowing those things, but I've ended up in arguments where I have very simply explained both those things to no avail.

I've been having a debate with a male poster on another thread about whether the bar for mens' parenting is really low. I've directed them to various boards / threads to see evidence, I've given lots of examples. He just keeps saying "I can't believe most sensible people would praise bad parenting" " it seems unbelievable to me" Well go do some reading then! Your lack of credulity is not an actual argument.

I feel your pain with the 13 weeks holiday. I work in a school.

Yes I also agree with your other example. Alot of people will argue the toss and refuse to read to see if they are correct or not.

OP posts:
Haemagoblin · 03/02/2026 08:25

WonderingWanda · 03/02/2026 06:57

You are probably getting a very skewed sample of society at the supermarket. Anyone with half a brain has booked a delivery or click and collect to avoid the hell that is supermarket shopping.

Nah I like to pick my own fruit and veg so they don't give you all the bruised/near date ones. Doesn't make me dumb, just discerning!

Hoardasurass · 03/02/2026 08:26

Slightyamusedandsilly · 03/02/2026 05:58

Trying to take the OP down a peg or two because she's dared to do a bit of sociological / analytical thought. Probably a right winger.

And yet you are doing the same thing by claiming that the poster is "probably right wing", as a dyslexic person I see the same superiority over grammar, spelling and punctuation from all political sides and would say it has more to do with looking down on those you deem unworthy and the righteousness of denigrating them because anything is acceptable if you're "on the right side of history" than political leaning.

Matronic6 · 03/02/2026 08:34

YANBU. I came across a clip last night of a man who called in to explain that during jury service they knew the person on trial was guilty of rape but decided the 'consequences' would be too much so going him not guilty. Under the belief that he would now appreciate what a serious crime it was and simply not do it again. And if he did they he would be brought back and then get guilty. The man had absolutely zero awareness. No understanding when the host pointed out there could be another victim.

Which means not only this man, but the entire jury thought it was their place to decide on the suitable punishment for a guilty man. They all completely failed their simply jury duty to simply decide on guilt or innocence. Thought it was for themselves to act as judge. The man completely stood by his decision. Showed a complete lack of a understanding for the gravity of what he said and thought he was completely in the right.

Swipe left for the next trending thread