Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be saddened that anyone would want to take away a woman’s right to safe abortion?

1000 replies

Balayagequeen · 13/09/2025 14:48

It makes me sad and angry that there are so many people who believe that a woman’s right to a termination is up for debate/political football.

It’s always privileged men too.

No woman should be forced to continue with a pregnancy that she doesn’t want.

An abortion is a very safe, simple procedure, it’s a personal and private choice, it’s discreet, no one is ramming it down anyone else’s throat or trying to persuade others to do it. The vast majority of the time is done very early on in the pregnancy. Evidence shows that there are no long term negative physical or mental effects on the woman.

As someone who works for children’s services, there are already far too many children in the care system and they can end up deeply traumatised, and having poor outcomes in life, adoptions often don’t work out and even when they do can be extremely traumatic for both the mother and child. That is not to take away from all of the wonderful adoptive parents and foster carers, but please let’s not romanticise it.

Most adoptions are because the birth parents are unable to care for the child, not because the mother willingly gave the baby up. Therefore to force a woman to give birth would potentially be the worse option for the woman, the child and any existing siblings. It isn’t a fairytale ending where a woman willingly gives up her baby to a loving couple to live happily ever after.

There are babies conceived in poverty, domestic abuse, rape, teenage pregnancies, older age pregnancies. These women should not be forced to give birth, it is not the better option for anyone.

If abortion was ever restricted in the western world then I have no doubt that it would result in unsafe illegal abortions, risking the woman’s life.

Women take all the risk with pregnancy and childbirth. They take an enormous toll on a woman body, her mental health, her life outcomes. We are not living in the dark ages, women deserve the choice.

What right does any privileged male who has probably never experienced any of these things and has probably done very little child rearing, who can never conceive or give birth, have to try to restrict a women’s access to abortion?

Are they themselves going to care for the babies born? Or will they expect that someone else will do it?

OP posts:
LayerCakeOfStrangers · 13/09/2025 20:07

Womblingmerrily · 13/09/2025 19:46

@Maltipoo

Are you saying that premature babies have "no awareness, no thought or feeling whatsoever."?

Dear me this is rather exhausting

A born baby has feelings and awareness. Because it’s been born.

Duh

Lelophants · 13/09/2025 20:08

Maltipoo · 13/09/2025 20:06

That is complete and utter nonsense. Laughable actually.
You're out because you can't support that false claim. 🤷

Edited because I wonder if you actually meant that just having human DNA makes it a person. If so, that's weird.

Edited

It’s not laughable that someone is upset because they believe you are mocking the idea of a fetus that age being a baby. Have some respect.

Lelophants · 13/09/2025 20:09

LayerCakeOfStrangers · 13/09/2025 20:07

Dear me this is rather exhausting

A born baby has feelings and awareness. Because it’s been born.

Duh

But they also have feeling and awarness before theyre born. 😭 Do you know how labour works?

MrsTerryPratchett · 13/09/2025 20:09

Gloriia · 13/09/2025 20:04

'But what absolutely baffles me is that you rarely hear pro lifers campaigning for better services for women and children'

Better services? What like GPs, and contraception?

There is no need to have an abortion. Use contraception or take the MAP. Unless in rare, extreme circumstances where the mother's life is at risk.

Edited

I used to take part in a program for young mums. The families that did it used to meet up every now and again and chat. When the subject came up, all the families who were giving up their time and care to mums so they could keep their kids in their care were pro-choice.

Money, time, care, housing. Give mums that and you’d see fewer abortions.

That’s another reason it’s obviously misogyny, not care fr babies.

Another is the lack of pressure to make dads accountable.

hadjustaboutenough · 13/09/2025 20:09

I believe that most abortions are completely avoidable if adults behaved responsibly. I believe that taking a human life before it's born is morally wrong. I think it's sickening when people use abortion as birth control. I also believe that in cases where the mother's life is at risk, abortion should obviously be allowed. I personally wouldn't deny abortion to victims of rape, either, though I struggle with it in the abstract, as the unborn child has done nothing wrong.

There are a lot of things people do that we as individuals and as a society feel free to judge and make illegal. I don't see why abortion should be free of judgement and regulation, especially considering that it denies life to the innocent unborn.

Maltipoo · 13/09/2025 20:10

Lelophants · 13/09/2025 20:05

I can see why you’re upset. I know someone who has now lost three babies at between 12-16 weeks and she’s had to deliver them all. They look like perfect tiny humans, have fingerprints, different looks, can see their sex. She is pro life and a christian so believes they have been full people sincr conception so I can completely see why it’s so upsetting for her. I dont agree with a lot of what she says (im not religious myself) but she loves babies and children and always puts them first. Her three miscarriages have been girls. It’s definitely made me think about it more. And since having my own children.

Edited

It's irrelevant what they look like. The facts show that up until later in pregnancy they do not feel anything, cannot possibly, have no capacity for thought, zero consciousness. Therefore they are not people. They have no need for rights.
What about that do people not get?

myglowupera · 13/09/2025 20:11

People who are completely against abortion don’t care about happens to the baby, the mum or her existing children when the baby is born.

They probably also at some point witter on about their overwhelming burning disgust towards large families, single mums working part time around their kids, benefit claimants, people who don’t earn a lot, families in overcrowded homes, women staying in abusive relationships (trapped because of having the baby). And yet they want every single woman to carry on with every single pregnancy.

LayerCakeOfStrangers · 13/09/2025 20:11

Lelophants · 13/09/2025 19:48

Because the belief is that an innocent child always comes first. And killing any life on purpose is bad.
On a slightly other point, I can’t believe how many Christians / pro lifers are pro death penalty! That’s hypocritical and sickening to me. At least be consistent.

Or they’re happy for children to have their life ended by bullets while they sit in classrooms because it means they can play with their penis extenders, sorry guns

LayerCakeOfStrangers · 13/09/2025 20:13

OhhNoYouDont · 13/09/2025 19:49

It’s thriving on its own without the need of a woman

Really? A newborn baby? I'm pretty sure they can't thrive on their own!

It it shouldn't all be about the woman.

Yes it should.

Its her body afterall.

Yea babies can thrive without women. How do you think it a possible when women sadly die in childbirth but their baby survives?

RitaFromThePitCanteen · 13/09/2025 20:13

WhatAboutThisUser · 13/09/2025 20:00

I genuinely think you and others are barking up the wrong tree here.

The hierarchy is that death (baby) is worse than pain (mother).

No one is killing babies.

And women dying in childbirth is still a thing, sadly. The fact that you don't acknowledge/care about that is how I know women are the lowest of your priorities.

TheSwarm · 13/09/2025 20:14

hadjustaboutenough · 13/09/2025 20:09

I believe that most abortions are completely avoidable if adults behaved responsibly. I believe that taking a human life before it's born is morally wrong. I think it's sickening when people use abortion as birth control. I also believe that in cases where the mother's life is at risk, abortion should obviously be allowed. I personally wouldn't deny abortion to victims of rape, either, though I struggle with it in the abstract, as the unborn child has done nothing wrong.

There are a lot of things people do that we as individuals and as a society feel free to judge and make illegal. I don't see why abortion should be free of judgement and regulation, especially considering that it denies life to the innocent unborn.

It's a very odd argument to say that the kind of women you are so happy to label as irresponsible as to get pregnant without wanting to be are then suddenly responsible enough to actually raise a child.

Don't you think?

pointythings · 13/09/2025 20:14

WhatAboutThisUser · 13/09/2025 19:51

Where the mum’s life is in danger by continuing the pregnancy?

I’d probably say the mum’s life should take priority but it’s a situation not relevant in 99%+ of abortions so not sure it’s relevant to the thread.

The problem is that early stage abortion is an order of magnitude less dangerous in terms of death and/or permanent health impacts than carrying to term and giving birth.

If you want to force a woman to give birth against her will, you are also forcing her to take the risk of birth injuries which may have a lifelong effect. I call that cruelty.

The religious argument, btw, is bollocks. All that does is impact the person who has that faith. Nobody is allowed to impose the rules of their faith on another person - freedom of religion and all that good stuff.

Lelophants · 13/09/2025 20:15

MaggieBsBoat · 13/09/2025 20:07

God if there was a lab burning and there was a toddler in it screaming and a liquid nitrogen tank with 1000 embryos in it. And they could only save one, by their logic I would expect these anti-abortion people to save the embryos. Would they? I’d love some pps to come on here and say they would. To my mind that’s severely fucked up.

Well this is getting silly. 🙄 Obviously the toddler would come first. The embryos are a bunch of cells that have not yet implanted onto a woman’s uterus. However, they would still be very important to a lot of people so yes I would also try to save them. 🙄

WhatAboutThisUser · 13/09/2025 20:15

Digdongdoo · 13/09/2025 20:03

Why is pain the only consideration for the mother?
I've had 3 children, the pain was a piddlingly short part of carrying, birthing and raising them. So why is pain the only only consideration for you?

I was trying to be succinct to make a point. Is there anything about having a baby that’s worse than death?

ExtraOnions · 13/09/2025 20:15

Total Female bodily autonomy … as women we are able to make decisions about our bodies.
We do not require permission, from others, to do what is right for us.

Once they start deciding what we do with our bodies, as we can’t be trusted to do “the right thing” we are on a slippery slope.

LayerCakeOfStrangers · 13/09/2025 20:15

WhatAboutThisUser · 13/09/2025 19:51

Where the mum’s life is in danger by continuing the pregnancy?

I’d probably say the mum’s life should take priority but it’s a situation not relevant in 99%+ of abortions so not sure it’s relevant to the thread.

No, I’m talking about her right to life free of a child she can’t look after

Free to not be forced to have a backstreet abortion

Free to not risk her health through a forced birth

Free to not have the utmost trauma of delivering a baby she didn’t want, and whatever that means afterward.

Women are more than just vessels. Women have feelings and needs and deserve to be happy. Not just suddenly become literal second class citizens because of an unwanted pregnancy

Bikergran · 13/09/2025 20:16

ThejoyofNC · 13/09/2025 19:06

I'm anti abortion and I'm not a man.

But are you a fundamentalist "Christian"? The quotation marks are because many of the so-called Christians I see seem to lack any basic human compassion.

LayerCakeOfStrangers · 13/09/2025 20:16

Lelophants · 13/09/2025 19:51

But that’s all about belief. If you believe in God then you believe they do have a personality and I suppose potential personality from conception and of course at some point it feels pain and comfort from it’s mother. You only have to read all those any surrogacy threads about it.

Well I don’t believe in God, nor do most people, and there’s a good reason why church and state should be deep rate in law making

Maltipoo · 13/09/2025 20:16

Lelophants · 13/09/2025 20:08

It’s not laughable that someone is upset because they believe you are mocking the idea of a fetus that age being a baby. Have some respect.

I said the claim that a 12 week fetus qualifies as a person is laughable, not her feelings. I do not feel obligated to be respectful about statements that fly in the face of facts.
She should try showing some respect for the rights and feelings of women who do not wish to be forced to give birth.

TooBigForMyBoots · 13/09/2025 20:17

OhhNoYouDont · 13/09/2025 19:57

People's main reasoning for abortion seems to be women dying if they continue the pregnancy. I wonder what percentage that amounts to in the Western world with modern medicine?

And women dying from the inevitable illegal abortions that will happen.

A zygote, embryos or fetus is not a child. It is a potential life. It should not be prioritised over actual, existing, woman's life.

PinkyFlamingo · 13/09/2025 20:18

CaroleLandis · 13/09/2025 19:17

I’m vehemently against abortion and I am
female. 🌹

Noone will force you to have an abortion then, it's a choice.

thepariscrimefiles · 13/09/2025 20:18

Lemsipcoldandflu · 13/09/2025 19:33

This.

people have become so desensitised to abortion and all about the woman’s rights only. They forget that it’s an actual baby whose life is being taken away because they are an inconvenience or unwanted or god forbid the wrong gender.

no one wants to be in a situation where they fall pregnant as a result of an act of crime however that doesn’t make the babies life less valid. That baby could still go on to live a very normal and happy life be that through adoption or if mum decides to keep her baby etc. i appreciate this is hard for the mum but having your life ended is also traumatic for the baby.

I actually used to be pro choice because of the rape argument and I couldn’t see past it however I ended up learning a lot more and watching lots of interviews of now adults who were born to mums who had been raped and the adults were saying how grateful they were that their life was saved and they could live and be happy. By having an abortion your taking away a babies chance at having a life and that is so sad. People are having abortions for the most minor of reasons

being a mum means making a sacrifice and putting someone elses life before you.

Ofcourse when there is a threat to mum or babies life for medical reasons or baby will be born with 0 quality of life in a medical sense then that’s different. Still sad but you can’t expect a baby to suffer for all of their life.

I can't believe that you would like to prevent women who are pregnant from rape from having an abortion. You are forcing them to give birth to their rapist's baby. As for the adults born to mums that have been raped being grateful that their lives were saved, if they had never been born they wouldn't have known anything about it.

As for this:

'being a mum means making a sacrifice and putting someone elses life before you.'

You are trying to make women who have had an abortion because they were pregnant through rape feel guilty. I find your stance utterly disgusting and abhorrent.

LayerCakeOfStrangers · 13/09/2025 20:19

OhhNoYouDont · 13/09/2025 19:57

People's main reasoning for abortion seems to be women dying if they continue the pregnancy. I wonder what percentage that amounts to in the Western world with modern medicine?

Western medicine doesn’t really factor into backstreet abortions

Western medicine didn’t save Savita Halappanavar because although she died in a hospital the anti abortion laws meant she died a horrible premature death, and she didn’t even want an abortions they wouldn’t dispense their western medicine because of the laws

So your point is sadly entirely moot

Balayagequeen · 13/09/2025 20:19

Gloriia · 13/09/2025 20:04

'But what absolutely baffles me is that you rarely hear pro lifers campaigning for better services for women and children'

Better services? What like GPs, and contraception?

There is no need to have an abortion. Use contraception or take the MAP. Unless in rare, extreme circumstances where the mother's life is at risk.

Edited

You sound very naive about the realities of contraception and some women’s lives and circumstances.

OP posts:
pointythings · 13/09/2025 20:20

Gloriia · 13/09/2025 20:00

Well just the it's independent when born thing is hard to understand. It isn't, whether it is dependent on a mother in utero or dependent on any adult when born a baby and fetus require an adult. They both count.

Irresponsible people should be advised to use contraception. Enabling repeat terminations is absolutely appalling in a country where contraception is readily available.

Edited

I trust you are aware that there is no such thing as 100% failsafe and effective contraception?

I have two separate sets of friends who were diligently using double contraception - and had unplanned pregnancies. The risk of failure is per incidence of coitus, so if you have a healthy sex life, your risk of an unplanned pregnancy with correct use of contraception is considerable.

Then there's the women who can't use hormonal contraception, the selfish men who refuse to use condoms because 'it doesn't feel nice', the patronising medical establishment who will not allow a woman of childbearing age to get sterilised because 'the little woman might change her mind'. This is what we're up against. It's nice and easy to think that it's all down to people being irresponsible, but actually it isn't anything like that simple.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.