Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Foodbank - 3 cars

503 replies

TalkToTheHand123 · 17/08/2025 00:11

Am I being unreasonable to think a family with 2 cars and a big fancy house shouldn't be using foodbanks regularly? No disability issues.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Needmorelego · 17/08/2025 11:36

AmandeFrance0979 · 17/08/2025 11:33

I have a neighbour. He's single, early sixties, and hasn't worked for years as he has savings and a lodger which, "Gives me enough to live off without working," he says.

I work behind the bar in a pub in our high street a couple of afternoons a week. This neighbour comes in at midday, sets down two shopping bags filled with food, then spends the entire day drinking Stella Artois at £6 a pint.

The shopping bags, he's happy to tell anyone who will listen, are filled from the local food banks. When he's been asked if he thinks that's a bit unethical he just laughs.

I think some of the comments on here display a rose-tinted view of the world. Some of you ladies really need to wake up to reality.

Is it actually free food though?
I know of one scheme that's calls itself a "food bank" but it's actually one where you pay something like £4 to fill a bag.
Anyone can go there.

Snoopysimaginaryfriend · 17/08/2025 11:36

https://news.sky.com/story/it-shouldnt-be-like-this-full-time-workers-turning-to-food-banks-13393691

I haven’t read the full thread so apologies if it has already been posted but I think this is the sky news story that the OP is referring to.

In the article they are broadcasting the family with the house and three cars explain that their son is learning to drive so they have had to cut back on his sister’s horse riding. I can’t remember if this family specifically are using the food bank or just saying that with their jobs and wages they shouldn’t have to make cutbacks on holidays etc.

I don’t know where I sit on this issue. I grew up dirt poor as in no hot water, no central heating etc. I’m fortunate that we can afford our bills and have a decent standard of living but I think people are struggling to realise that maybe you can’t have a foreign holiday, horse riding, the latest everything even on a decent wage. No one should be going hungry in this country though.

'It shouldn't be like this': Full-time workers relying on food handouts amid cost of living crisis

Wages in Cannock Chase matched the national UK average in 2021, but that's not the case any more. Full-time workers say they thought their lifestyles would be more comfortable - that their work ethic would be delivering more than it is.

https://news.sky.com/story/it-shouldnt-be-like-this-full-time-workers-turning-to-food-banks-13393691

FreezeDriedStrawberries · 17/08/2025 11:37

AmandeFrance0979 · 17/08/2025 11:33

I have a neighbour. He's single, early sixties, and hasn't worked for years as he has savings and a lodger which, "Gives me enough to live off without working," he says.

I work behind the bar in a pub in our high street a couple of afternoons a week. This neighbour comes in at midday, sets down two shopping bags filled with food, then spends the entire day drinking Stella Artois at £6 a pint.

The shopping bags, he's happy to tell anyone who will listen, are filled from the local food banks. When he's been asked if he thinks that's a bit unethical he just laughs.

I think some of the comments on here display a rose-tinted view of the world. Some of you ladies really need to wake up to reality.

I think some of the comments on here display a rose-tinted view of the world. Some of you ladies really need to wake up to reality

I'd rather take the risk of a possible piss taker or three than have someone feel desperate and miserable because they're wondering whether they have enough food for that week or are just scraping by.
I've thankfully never had to use foodbanks but do know what it's like to not even be able to afford
a nice packet of biscuits after all the bills and boring, basic food has been bought and you just want something nice to break up the monotony and a treat every once in a while.

Beautifuladventcalendar · 17/08/2025 11:37

AmandeFrance0979 · 17/08/2025 11:33

I have a neighbour. He's single, early sixties, and hasn't worked for years as he has savings and a lodger which, "Gives me enough to live off without working," he says.

I work behind the bar in a pub in our high street a couple of afternoons a week. This neighbour comes in at midday, sets down two shopping bags filled with food, then spends the entire day drinking Stella Artois at £6 a pint.

The shopping bags, he's happy to tell anyone who will listen, are filled from the local food banks. When he's been asked if he thinks that's a bit unethical he just laughs.

I think some of the comments on here display a rose-tinted view of the world. Some of you ladies really need to wake up to reality.

Sounds like you know my father! Except the rounds of food come from the community fridge that anyone can use not the food bank you need to prove you're really poor to use the food bank.
This whole thread reads like a big misunderstanding. Unless people really do get their panties in a twist about anyone richer than a homeless person using the community fridge.

UnhappyHobbit · 17/08/2025 11:42

I’m with you OP. If I was donating to a food bank, I would expect to be donating to the needy and would not expect people with nicer houses and cars than myself to be classed as “needy”.

rainbowstardrops · 17/08/2025 11:44

Obviously nobody knows people’s circumstances and some people just fall on hard times (I’ve been there) but some people do take the piss.
I know a taxi driver who picked a bloke up and took him to a food bank and the bloke asked him to wait and return. The whole job cost over £15! Surely that man could have gone to the shop and bought groceries instead of an expensive taxi fare?
Having said that, I buy £5 of pet food/groceries for the food bank most weeks and I just hope it’s going to someone who actually needs it.

Digdongdoo · 17/08/2025 11:46

Snoopysimaginaryfriend · 17/08/2025 11:36

https://news.sky.com/story/it-shouldnt-be-like-this-full-time-workers-turning-to-food-banks-13393691

I haven’t read the full thread so apologies if it has already been posted but I think this is the sky news story that the OP is referring to.

In the article they are broadcasting the family with the house and three cars explain that their son is learning to drive so they have had to cut back on his sister’s horse riding. I can’t remember if this family specifically are using the food bank or just saying that with their jobs and wages they shouldn’t have to make cutbacks on holidays etc.

I don’t know where I sit on this issue. I grew up dirt poor as in no hot water, no central heating etc. I’m fortunate that we can afford our bills and have a decent standard of living but I think people are struggling to realise that maybe you can’t have a foreign holiday, horse riding, the latest everything even on a decent wage. No one should be going hungry in this country though.

Edited

Oh FFS. So OP has just got the wrong end of the stick and run away with it.
The family with the 3 cars aren't using the food bank. Just bemoaning the rising cost of living.

Hoppinggreen · 17/08/2025 11:48

AmandeFrance0979 · 17/08/2025 11:33

I have a neighbour. He's single, early sixties, and hasn't worked for years as he has savings and a lodger which, "Gives me enough to live off without working," he says.

I work behind the bar in a pub in our high street a couple of afternoons a week. This neighbour comes in at midday, sets down two shopping bags filled with food, then spends the entire day drinking Stella Artois at £6 a pint.

The shopping bags, he's happy to tell anyone who will listen, are filled from the local food banks. When he's been asked if he thinks that's a bit unethical he just laughs.

I think some of the comments on here display a rose-tinted view of the world. Some of you ladies really need to wake up to reality.

I don't have a rose tinted view of the world, far from it
I am just not a judgemental Twat

usedtobeaylis · 17/08/2025 11:52

Food banks were traditionally often used used by people dealing with a a new job and the changeover in when wages were paid, for all you know that's the case here. People shouldn't have to start selling their belongings due to short terms issues.

In other words, you don't know the circumstances and it's none of your business.

SumUp · 17/08/2025 11:54

Why not ensure that there is a solid social safety net across the UK (no postcode lottery), where anyone can apply to an emergency fund administered by the council, with strict qualifying criteria, delivered alongside money help and signposting.

If a household is genuinely in crisis, a carrier bag of food is not going to have much of an impact. It’s more upsetting to think of families in crisis being reliant on piecemeal help from the voluntary sector.

BuckChuckets · 17/08/2025 11:55

TalkToTheHand123 · 17/08/2025 10:56

It looked like a £200,000 ish property that they had bought on a mortgage a long time ago. The cars didn't seem essential for work or school runs and more for luxury from what I recall from the interview.

Yikes, where do you live that £200k is a big fancy house?

rainbowstardrops · 17/08/2025 11:56

Hoppinggreen · 17/08/2025 11:48

I don't have a rose tinted view of the world, far from it
I am just not a judgemental Twat

If the pub bloke and the taxi driver customer are abusing the kindness of other people then I think more people should be ‘judgemental twats’!

usedtobeaylis · 17/08/2025 11:57

SumUp · 17/08/2025 11:54

Why not ensure that there is a solid social safety net across the UK (no postcode lottery), where anyone can apply to an emergency fund administered by the council, with strict qualifying criteria, delivered alongside money help and signposting.

If a household is genuinely in crisis, a carrier bag of food is not going to have much of an impact. It’s more upsetting to think of families in crisis being reliant on piecemeal help from the voluntary sector.

I know the council area I grew up in had multiple funds like this - emergency, hardship etc - and it was always cumbersome with a long waiting list. The criteria was so strict that hardly anyone actually qualified - not because they weren't in need, but because funds were so limited and the criteria was impossible.

FreezeDriedStrawberries · 17/08/2025 11:59

BuckChuckets · 17/08/2025 11:55

Yikes, where do you live that £200k is a big fancy house?

Exactly 😁

Beautifuladventcalendar · 17/08/2025 12:01

BuckChuckets · 17/08/2025 11:55

Yikes, where do you live that £200k is a big fancy house?

That's a small two room apartment or ancient mouldy terrace house round here (not London) think the op must be old and out of touch (no offence)
Probably will try and say they should rent as if they think that's cheaper than a mortgage.

It's not the 1960s anymore a house is not a luxury item if you have kids unless they think the kids can live in a bin. I should say it's not the 1860s then

Trixibell1234 · 17/08/2025 12:03

@TalkToTheHand123 if you think people like shopkeepers are abusing the system let the people running the food bank know and they can sort it out. I thought you needed referrals,

Where I live public transport is awful and if you work you almost certainly need a car.

What was the tv program?

usedtobeaylis · 17/08/2025 12:09

I live in a disadvantaged area of Glasgow and houses on my street range from the flats at £120k to 3 bed semis at £170. Cheaper houses in the area are old and decrepit ex council stock that need a lot of work. I imagine £200k doesn't go far in nicer areas.

Elleherd · 17/08/2025 12:09

FreezeDriedStrawberries · 17/08/2025 11:32

So don't then. 🙄
I'll keep on donating. Might throw in an extra pack of biscuits next time just for you 😁

You know what, you could be onto something there. Perhaps if all the MN donators dropped in a little extra in Vivienmary's name every time they thread plopped, we could actively re balance some of MN's intentionally spread misery. 😀

I don't need any lessons in reality. I was born into it, and have been through the mill backwards, live with the physical results of it, and would consequently pop an extra biscuit onto the meanest fuckers saucer to prevent them ever having to find out just how thin living on next to nothing than fear, can be, and how it can carry on affecting you in many different ways, years later.

Digdongdoo · 17/08/2025 12:10

So OP, are you indeed referring to the SKY piece, in which the family with 3 cars aren't actually using a food bank at all?

Canicule · 17/08/2025 12:11

Elleherd · 17/08/2025 11:29

@TalkToTheHand123 You'd be welcome to take food from the community pantries to save money so you can have better holidays. 🙂They are officially there to reduce food waste, though those who run them are very aware of who's also using them because of need.

Of course there will always be CF's around but like so many things, appearances can also be very deceiving.

Being disabled often means loading and unloading vehicles makes me very visable.
I'm publicly berated by a neighbor (who isn't very good with their finances or choices, and is a regular food bank user) for being seen taking large quantities of food from a couple of community food pantries (open to all) and a food bank, (referral only) and showing my face easily as frequently as they do..

Neighbor has no idea some of their and their kids free meals are prepared by me, and shouts all sorts of slurs around to make themself feel and in their opinion, look, better to others.

I do (internally) question if they couldn't divert their energy to sorting their life out, rather than abusing others. But, I know the kids would still be taken abroad regularly, because their parent expects to go (along with many other things that are luxuries to me), but they'd just be hungrier in between trips.😕

I'm actually a community cook, collecting excess and rejected food, to cook up and turn it into re-heatable vegetarian meals in containers, some of which are then transported to both community pantry/food bank freezers, and the big ones are for the street kitchen I'm part of.
The community pantry has a main table that's take all you can use please, and is for all, others that are rationed, and behind the counter items and prepped meals which are for those who specifically ask for them, or are known to need them and asked if they'd like them.

Meals aren't always as nutritious as we'd like, but I'm good at making something filling and tasty from little, can cater for vegans and religious requirements, and can cook on scale. The meals I make go to anyone who requests them and I don't have any issues over who they are, how they live, or why they take them. The vast majority are people in need, one way or another.

I with others, help feed a small army of street homeless people every week.
It's incredibly difficult to sort your life out when you're running on empty and constantly malnourished, whether you've fallen on hard times or you're the author of your own problems.

They too are a huge cross section of society and a couple of them have managed to hold onto cars. There are people in high quality tents, people in festival level tents, basic benders, cardboard shelters, and or just a tarp or a plastic sheet, and those without even that.
In amongst them we have the odd one who is 'just' precariously housed, or so low on funds that the lure of a free hot meal will draw them, and we get the occasional person who turns up, who we suspect has no need of what we offer at all. We rightly question no one.

Just to say @Elleherd - you sound wonderful ❤️

whynotwhatknot · 17/08/2025 12:15

my house is a terraced two bed worth 260k not in any way fancy

but if theyre going on holidays no they shouldnt be using fb

FreezeDriedStrawberries · 17/08/2025 12:26

whynotwhatknot · 17/08/2025 12:15

my house is a terraced two bed worth 260k not in any way fancy

but if theyre going on holidays no they shouldnt be using fb

I've been on holiday before when skint, it was with parents though who paid for it. You just can't judge people's circumstances.

Mrsbloggz · 17/08/2025 12:30

Obviously they need to be given free food, how else are they going to pay for their large house and numerous vehicles?!

Sunshineandoranges · 17/08/2025 12:35

Community fridges are to stop food going into landfill, not only for poorer people. Food banks are for people who don’t have enough money to buy all the food they need.

SandyDunesCoffeeShack · 17/08/2025 12:35

Remember, many of these wives in their fancy houses are pets on a financial leash. Allowance, abuse, you name it. I don't envy people who live in big empty halls but eat old out of date food. God knows what goes behind closed doors, especially in detached houses