Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

300 children from Gaza to be brought to the UK for free specialist NHS care

1000 replies

Fragmentedbrain · 03/08/2025 01:33

According to the Sunday Times. That's nearly as many beds as there are in Great Ormond Street, where the average waiting time for paediatric surgery is 15 weeks (which is fairly typical nationwide).

Why is it mysteriously possible for government to deliver these showy, headline-grabbing measures (I know we already knew it could happen from COVID policy) but not to just make systems work well in an ordinary way?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
nearlylovemyusername · 03/08/2025 19:26

Hagr1d · 03/08/2025 19:16

See, my understanding of that wording is that NHS staff and facilites are being used but the actual treatment is being funded privately by the charity? Am I misunderstanding?

You are misunderstanding.

If you read Sky (free link) very carefully they are trying to be impartial and they specifically mentioned private treatments as another avenue. The boy with facial injuries was funded privately.

But these 300 children and their families incl siblings will be treated by NHS and funded by government.

nearlylovemyusername · 03/08/2025 19:30

Gloriia · 03/08/2025 19:22

Plenty of capacity in Saudi and Qatar, nearer so it's less distressing re travelling. They're helping out already and will easily be able to take more. This charity absolutely do not need to send sick kids from gaza all the way to the UK.

The thing is - how are these 300 selected out of all who require help? do they have any connections with the UK? is this their chance to stay here with their parents and siblings?

LittlePigRobinson · 03/08/2025 19:31

pointythings · 03/08/2025 19:25

When you say 'non UK people ', do you include foreign nationals who have been here for decades, working and paying tax in that?

No, of course not because they are in the UK, working, paying tax and contributing. I'm not some crazed racist FFS.

I just think people actually living in the UK and contributing the the NHS should get first dibs at treatment, especially as its so strapped for cash it can't even prescribe the best medication for my DD.

Edited because I wasn't making sense.

ArtfulGoldWriter · 03/08/2025 19:35

Jesus Christ- the state of some of the comments on this thread.

Many of these kids have serious injuries such a limb loss etc and are utterly traumatised. i am glad a tiny proportion of my taxes are being spent on helping this kids.

Am sure Nigel the cunt will have some nasty racist thing to say about it which I where I assume some of the comments on here are coming from.

Terrible.

DuncinToffee · 03/08/2025 19:35

Gloriia · 03/08/2025 19:22

Plenty of capacity in Saudi and Qatar, nearer so it's less distressing re travelling. They're helping out already and will easily be able to take more. This charity absolutely do not need to send sick kids from gaza all the way to the UK.

Why shouldn't they be treated in the UK?

Thegreyhound · 03/08/2025 19:35

Gloriia · 03/08/2025 18:36

But they have very rich Samaritans much closer by who yes are helping and are able to continue to do so.

I don't know, if it were me and one of my dc was sick I'd like them to be treated closer to home for logistical reasons and of course practical ones like culture, language etc. When one is very distressed and anxious the last thing you need is more complications like language barriers.

Edited

What do you mean by culture? Do you think a Muslim doctor would operate on a gunshot wound differently to a non Muslim one? What a very very bizarre thing to say.

GreenZebraStripes · 03/08/2025 19:36

I don't think this is comparable.

PandoraSocks · 03/08/2025 19:37

LittlePigRobinson · 03/08/2025 19:31

No, of course not because they are in the UK, working, paying tax and contributing. I'm not some crazed racist FFS.

I just think people actually living in the UK and contributing the the NHS should get first dibs at treatment, especially as its so strapped for cash it can't even prescribe the best medication for my DD.

Edited because I wasn't making sense.

Edited

In a publicly funded health system, cost has to have a bearing on treatment, whether we like it or not.

Even private health insurers will look at cost and decline expensive treatments if there is a cheaper alternative.

GOSH has a long tradition of treating children from other countries. It has specialities that are rare elsewhere. It is something to be proud of and long may it continue.

GreenZebraStripes · 03/08/2025 19:38

Thegreyhound · 03/08/2025 19:35

What do you mean by culture? Do you think a Muslim doctor would operate on a gunshot wound differently to a non Muslim one? What a very very bizarre thing to say.

I think I'd want my child to be operating on by the best surgeon for the task, wherever they were.

ArtfulGoldWriter · 03/08/2025 19:39

Oh and what a fucking surprise.

The usual suspects Pro Israel lobby is on here making sure nothing good can happen to Palestinian children.

Assume they are saying that the kids aren’t really injured and it’s all Hamas’s fault 🙄

1457bloom · 03/08/2025 19:39

This is nothing compared to allowing 500,000 Ukrainians to move here.

Absentmindedsmile · 03/08/2025 19:44

1457bloom · 03/08/2025 19:39

This is nothing compared to allowing 500,000 Ukrainians to move here.

Half a million people from Ukraine moved here? Where’s that stat come from?

Thegreyhound · 03/08/2025 19:45

PersephoneSeethes · 03/08/2025 18:12

Thank you for confirming from the horses mouth why the NHS is so beleaguered. Putting the Gazan children aside, what other country has this policy? Honestly? It's utter madness.

It must be Pavlov’s NHS you are talking about- simultaneously staffed and kept afloat by immigrants and yet being destroyed by immigrants.

Izzadoraduncancan · 03/08/2025 19:45

Wishiwasatailor · 03/08/2025 18:53

Unless she is on the private ward in the private building at GOSH. Which many foreign children are.

No, she will be in a public NHS ward

NeverDropYourMooncup · 03/08/2025 19:47

LittlePigRobinson · 03/08/2025 19:04

This is nice for those children and their families but unless it's definitely not coming out of the NHS budget then it really pisses me off.

My DD has a chronic medical condition (autoimmune). There is standard (ie cheap and keeps you alive) medication and there is new, improved (ie more expensive and gives a much better quality of life) medication. Guess which one the NHS will prescribe despite much begging. It's not as if the new medication is extortionate, it's just more than the cheapest alternative. It would however cost us about 10k a year to buy privately.

It's a standard treatment ladder for many automimmune diseases to start on Methotrexate, possibly combined with Sulfazaline or Leflunomide before escalating to Humira/other first line biologics, then only change to something like Cosentyx if Humira/the first choice is not having adequate effect upon active disease or the patient has developed antibodies to Humira - and only after that, in turn due to lack of effect/developing antibodies to the biologic, something like Bimzelx or infusions, for example. More expensive medications aren't clinically necessary if disease activity can be effectively reduced on another medication and have risks in their own right - and higher cost does not mean inherently better.

It certainly isn't privately funded children being treated as private patients at private costs (except for surgeons, etc, donating their own time for no fee out of pure altruism thereby reducing the overall cost to the charity) that determines the guidelines of NICE or an Independent Funding Request referral outcome.

Thegreyhound · 03/08/2025 19:47

GreenZebraStripes · 03/08/2025 19:38

I think I'd want my child to be operating on by the best surgeon for the task, wherever they were.

Well quite. But some posters here seem to think that doctors should share your ‘culture’ whatever on earth they mean by that. Baffling.

LittlePigRobinson · 03/08/2025 19:49

PandoraSocks · 03/08/2025 19:37

In a publicly funded health system, cost has to have a bearing on treatment, whether we like it or not.

Even private health insurers will look at cost and decline expensive treatments if there is a cheaper alternative.

GOSH has a long tradition of treating children from other countries. It has specialities that are rare elsewhere. It is something to be proud of and long may it continue.

I agree that 'In a publicly funded health system, cost has to have a bearing on treatment, whether we like it or not.'

This is exactly why I'm not happy about bringing people from other countries for free NHS care when the NHS can't afford to treat the UK public who actually fund it.

This isn't just children from Gaza, I would feel the same about bringing people from any other countries for free NHS treatment.

In fact why stop at the NHS? I'm sure there are people in far flung parts of the world who would love a UK education. I'm sure we can squeeze a few hundred children into our education system and UK children and their parents would happy to step aside.

ArtfulGoldWriter · 03/08/2025 19:50

Thegreyhound · 03/08/2025 19:47

Well quite. But some posters here seem to think that doctors should share your ‘culture’ whatever on earth they mean by that. Baffling.

Pure racism.

And a hatred of Palestinians I suspect. A few of the posters on here are well known on the gaza threads arguing that there’s no kids getting bombed in Gaza. Or starved. Or anything.

ArtfulGoldWriter · 03/08/2025 19:51

LittlePigRobinson · 03/08/2025 19:49

I agree that 'In a publicly funded health system, cost has to have a bearing on treatment, whether we like it or not.'

This is exactly why I'm not happy about bringing people from other countries for free NHS care when the NHS can't afford to treat the UK public who actually fund it.

This isn't just children from Gaza, I would feel the same about bringing people from any other countries for free NHS treatment.

In fact why stop at the NHS? I'm sure there are people in far flung parts of the world who would love a UK education. I'm sure we can squeeze a few hundred children into our education system and UK children and their parents would happy to step aside.

Christ.

EmeraldShamrock000 · 03/08/2025 19:51

LittlePigRobinson · 03/08/2025 19:31

No, of course not because they are in the UK, working, paying tax and contributing. I'm not some crazed racist FFS.

I just think people actually living in the UK and contributing the the NHS should get first dibs at treatment, especially as its so strapped for cash it can't even prescribe the best medication for my DD.

Edited because I wasn't making sense.

Edited

First dibs? How many children in the UK have had limbs blown off lately?
How many children in the UK are suffering mass starvation? How many children in the UK have been deprived of water, areas plagued with disease, bits of human decomposing around them?

BIossomtoes · 03/08/2025 19:51

marshmallowmix · 03/08/2025 19:12

Yes I can read that is for the ones previously….the 300 they just announced said NHS funded and clarity need to be given on that….who is paying?
where are 300 beds coming from …just like that ….

You have presumably heard of private hospitals?

MummytoE · 03/08/2025 19:52

I, for one, would be delighted if my tax contributions were spent helping these innocent children and Their families .

ArtfulGoldWriter · 03/08/2025 19:52

EmeraldShamrock000 · 03/08/2025 19:51

First dibs? How many children in the UK have had limbs blown off lately?
How many children in the UK are suffering mass starvation? How many children in the UK have been deprived of water, areas plagued with disease, bits of human decomposing around them?

Exactly. People have lost their fucking minds.

LittlePigRobinson · 03/08/2025 19:53

NeverDropYourMooncup · 03/08/2025 19:47

It's a standard treatment ladder for many automimmune diseases to start on Methotrexate, possibly combined with Sulfazaline or Leflunomide before escalating to Humira/other first line biologics, then only change to something like Cosentyx if Humira/the first choice is not having adequate effect upon active disease or the patient has developed antibodies to Humira - and only after that, in turn due to lack of effect/developing antibodies to the biologic, something like Bimzelx or infusions, for example. More expensive medications aren't clinically necessary if disease activity can be effectively reduced on another medication and have risks in their own right - and higher cost does not mean inherently better.

It certainly isn't privately funded children being treated as private patients at private costs (except for surgeons, etc, donating their own time for no fee out of pure altruism thereby reducing the overall cost to the charity) that determines the guidelines of NICE or an Independent Funding Request referral outcome.

I have no idea what any of those medications are but they aren't relevant to my DDs condition.

Gloriia · 03/08/2025 19:54

Thegreyhound · 03/08/2025 19:47

Well quite. But some posters here seem to think that doctors should share your ‘culture’ whatever on earth they mean by that. Baffling.

I didn't say they must share your culture. I said language barriers and cultural differences will make a distressing time for a sick dc even worse.

'Project pure hope' should understand this obvious fact and carry on getting patients treated in other Arabic countries. There are plenty of them nearby with fantastic facilities. They've assisted with thousands, another 300 shouldn't be a problem.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread