Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Paying monthly for a car? Should I do it?

28 replies

Bruminbrum · 30/07/2025 15:31

Hi all,

could use some car advice. I’ll caveat this with, I’ve never taken anything out on lease or purchase.

we have as a household 2 cars owned outright. One 7 seater that I think we could see for c£13/£14k and one hatch back we could see for c£7/8k (but the car is getting a bit old now so could really be replaced and I’ve been wanting to for a while)

my company now has a new electric vehicle scheme, and they’ve got my 7 seater available for £500 a month, including charging point, insurance, energy credits, road tax and services rolled in. Should I do it? We spend about £100 a month in fuel per car and insurance annually is about £800. It would get deducted from my salary and my husband would set up a standing order for half.

it would take our household income to c £6k a month inc child benefit (which we save for the kids)

we’d then sell the hatch back and get another run around car, for c£11k and then invest the rest.

we’d need to tighten our belt on a few things like eating out and tbh frittering money away but we typically save around £1k a month, so reckon we’d still be able to save £800 a month. Plus then £8k going straight into the bank. Thoughts?

OP posts:
Bruminbrum · 31/07/2025 13:54

NigelPonsonbySmallpiece · 31/07/2025 13:05

How much would your repayments be for a normal loan? Personally I’d rather do a bank or normal car finance loan and make repayments, own the car and then run it into the ground.

If a car is looked after and serviced it should last 15 years. We currently have a 2010 and a 2016 car and neither of them have had any issues apart from tyres and brake pads/shoes. The older one has getting on for 200k mileage.

The other issue with stuff like pcp and leasing is look into the small print of mileage restrictions, bubble payments at the end, how much could they potentially “fine” you for any little scuffs, etc.

As this is a lease there is no balloon payment at the end.
there would be, as you said a surcharge if you go over the mileage.

if I took a 50k loan? As that’s the cost of the car new. Car finance the apr is usually sky higher but unlikely to get a 50k unsecured loan, so that would be additional borrowing on a mortgage. Probably £300 a month depending on term and rate.

my cars need a little bit of work, but they are looking a bit old (well aware this is a status and vanity thing)

OP posts:
NigelPonsonbySmallpiece · 31/07/2025 14:18

Bruminbrum · 31/07/2025 13:54

As this is a lease there is no balloon payment at the end.
there would be, as you said a surcharge if you go over the mileage.

if I took a 50k loan? As that’s the cost of the car new. Car finance the apr is usually sky higher but unlikely to get a 50k unsecured loan, so that would be additional borrowing on a mortgage. Probably £300 a month depending on term and rate.

my cars need a little bit of work, but they are looking a bit old (well aware this is a status and vanity thing)

50k loan, yeah tough one. I wouldn't buy a 50k car. I mean I have more than enough cash in the bank to buy one but I still wouldn't get a 50k car. I wouldn't finance a 50k car either. 😀

But I appreciate plenty of people would. I'm quite happy being the person driving the Ford when all my mates have got Mercs! I always laugh and say I have the worst car in the car park at the health club.

MooseAndSquirrelLoveFlannel · 31/07/2025 14:28

Most people i know seem to lease their cars, my work does a similar scheme to you.

But im old school and I like knowing that after x date my car payments end and I own the car. I just finished paying mine off after 5 years and im over the moon as I adore my car. It's nothing fancy but it was the first big thing I bought myself when I returned to work after 10yrs as a sahm. I plan on keeping it for as long as possible.

Car prices these days scare me. My car is 7 years old and worth more now than I bought it for which is bonkers! It's not a "cheap" car but not a luxury car either.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page