Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To wonder if all those gleeful about PIP cuts are going to welcome people with serious mental health conditions as colleagues and employees?

821 replies

Somethingthecatdraggedin7 · 19/03/2025 09:39

Given the amount of ableisism I see on MN I think the likelihood of people welcoming people with serious mental health conditions into their workplace is pretty low.
And yes, these people will very likely now be forced to try to work even though their condition makes it impossible. We are not just talking about some lazy twenty year old who expects to sit at home gaming due to his “anxiety” as many people seem to believe is the case. It will be people with significant impairments to social functioning.
Even if they get support to apply for jobs, and even if they then get the position (doubtful) how accommodating will colleagues or customers be if the person seems a bit odd, or gets adjustments workmates deem unfair?
This is going to be a total shit show.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
LadyKenya · 05/05/2025 19:56

XenoBitch · 05/05/2025 19:49

I attend a few support groups. Does that mean anyone who goes there can work??
It is ridiculous.

No, of course not. The problem is some people have no idea of the struggles some people are facing daily. Be it a physical, or mental health disability. They refuse to listen to people who patiently explain why they cannot do xyz, coming back with their own ignorant suggestions. Going to support groups is a positive self help action. That does not equate to being able to work full time, or even part time, for some people.

XenoBitch · 05/05/2025 20:01

LadyKenya · 05/05/2025 19:56

No, of course not. The problem is some people have no idea of the struggles some people are facing daily. Be it a physical, or mental health disability. They refuse to listen to people who patiently explain why they cannot do xyz, coming back with their own ignorant suggestions. Going to support groups is a positive self help action. That does not equate to being able to work full time, or even part time, for some people.

Absolutely. I can't understand the mindset of someone who gets in a "Twitter war" with someone who is just trying to live their life as best they can despite their struggles. It is almost like they want anyone sick/disable to be hidden away.

But, you see it on MN too. "You can post on MN so can work". It is bollocks.

WoodlandLove · 05/05/2025 20:10

@XenoBitch Flowers
As someone with a history of mental health issues, I just wanted to show you support. I do work now. But, there have been periods of time when I simply couldn't. Unfortunately MN does have an excess of posters who don't understand how utterly crippling and overwhelming serious mental illness can be. I have absolutely no interest in judging any benefit recipients, as it's simply not my business how or why they claim. As if those unable to work due to illness, of any kind, don't have enough to worry about as it is. When I had a complete breakdown, I can honestly say getting through each day (when I couldn't go to work in the classic sense) was the hardest work I've ever done.
You take lots of care x

LadyKenya · 05/05/2025 20:12

Agreed@XenoBitch. I wonder if they would say any of this to someone in rl, or is it just online, where they can remain anonymous. They really must feel that something is being taken from them personally, when people with profound disabilities are just trying to live, as best that they can.

XenoBitch · 05/05/2025 20:56

WoodlandLove · 05/05/2025 20:10

@XenoBitch Flowers
As someone with a history of mental health issues, I just wanted to show you support. I do work now. But, there have been periods of time when I simply couldn't. Unfortunately MN does have an excess of posters who don't understand how utterly crippling and overwhelming serious mental illness can be. I have absolutely no interest in judging any benefit recipients, as it's simply not my business how or why they claim. As if those unable to work due to illness, of any kind, don't have enough to worry about as it is. When I had a complete breakdown, I can honestly say getting through each day (when I couldn't go to work in the classic sense) was the hardest work I've ever done.
You take lots of care x

Thank you so much x
I do say I do work... my job is trying to get through each day safely. Thank you for understanding.

XenoBitch · 05/05/2025 20:59

LadyKenya · 05/05/2025 20:12

Agreed@XenoBitch. I wonder if they would say any of this to someone in rl, or is it just online, where they can remain anonymous. They really must feel that something is being taken from them personally, when people with profound disabilities are just trying to live, as best that they can.

Yep, they are hiding behind a keyboard. Because of my history and the groups go to, pretty much everyone is in the same boat as me. We don't judge each other at all. We share each other's small victories. In my groups, if I have managed to have a shower after 10 days, I am told I did great. On here... I am fucking disgusting and there is no excuse unless you have no limbs and no access to water. And, I managed to shower, so I can clean someone in a care home.. or some other shite.

Seventree · 05/05/2025 21:02

I have a family member this is likely to affect. If he by some miracle managed to get a job, his colleagues would hate working with him. I love him and it's not his fault, but his mental health condition makes him very very demanding of other people and completely unreasonable in his demands. The more this was challenged, the more stressed he'd feel and the worse his behaviour would be.

He won't get a job though. He'll struggle in poverty with the help of family where possible. His mental health condition makes it impossible for him to move out of his comfort zone or be in situations he cannot control. I honestly think he'd starve rather than cope with work if it came to it, he can barely leave his house.

LadyKenya · 05/05/2025 21:19

It is good that you have an outlet, and are around people who understand, and are not judging you, at these meetings@XenoBitch. Small wins, and all that!

ThisOldThang · 05/05/2025 21:35

XenoBitch · 05/05/2025 19:37

@JenniferBooth

That poster and another were tag teaming each other and accusing me of all sorts on another thread (I can't remember what one but it filled up and was vile... not just to me but a couple of other very vulnerable posters too).

For starters, I am on UC (LCWRA) so not a job seeker. UC has not been around for 15 years. I started claiming end of 2017. I was on no benefits at all for 7 years previous to that. I was forced out of my job due to ill health in 2010. I had to claim them in 2107 as my relationship broke down and I was facing homelessness. Before 2017 I was at uni.
That poster and the other vile person kept going on and on about how I should start up a business as a coffee van, because they apparently know someone who does. They said I think I am above serving coffee. I told them I am not interested in it, asked where I would get the money from to start one.... oh and one simple fact they kept ignoring was that I am not allowed to drive
They accused me of getting medication and binning it so I could lie and claim benefits. They said I can post on MN so clearly don't have MH issues (ignoring the fact there is a whole MH board on this site.... people often post on there from psych wards). Oh, and I do post but NC.

When I see their names, my heart actually sinks because I know they are going to start on me and drag stuff up. I really wish there was a way to block posters on here.

Oh and right now I am under the Home Treatment team and they are helping me apply for PIP. They were shocked I was not already on it. I have years and stacks of evidence. My old CPN went on at me for years about applying. I am too fragile for the process.... nothing to do with not being eligible. A lot of people that would be eligible are put off by how intrusive it can be.

I tagged you and not anyone for the simple reason I don't want them engaging with me at all. I am not well and their unfounded accusations are going to push me over the edge. If they see this, then please respect my wishes and leave me the fuck alone... and get a life.

You are massively misrepresenting that thread and seem to have major issues in that department.

That poster and the other vile person kept going on and on about how I should start up a business as a coffee van, because they apparently know someone who does.

Firstly, I'm pretty sure i never commented on that person's suggestion that a small business / coffee van might suit your declared conditions of 'good and bad days'. Secondly, as per the screenshot, that poster was incredibly polite. They also didn't 'keep going on about it'.

Later in the thread you misrepresented what they'd written.

"Thank you. I am no longer going to engage with that poster... I mean, a fucking burger van. Ok, I will just pull one out my ass and go set it up somewhere. It is that easy when you have no money, no knowledge of business, the laws and regulations about catering etc., and no desire to have one anyway."

It's a bit of a running theme with you, isn't it? Why would anybody believe your narrative?

To wonder if all those gleeful about PIP cuts are going to welcome people with serious mental health conditions as colleagues and employees?
XenoBitch · 05/05/2025 21:39

ThisOldThang · 05/05/2025 21:35

You are massively misrepresenting that thread and seem to have major issues in that department.

That poster and the other vile person kept going on and on about how I should start up a business as a coffee van, because they apparently know someone who does.

Firstly, I'm pretty sure i never commented on that person's suggestion that a small business / coffee van might suit your declared conditions of 'good and bad days'. Secondly, as per the screenshot, that poster was incredibly polite. They also didn't 'keep going on about it'.

Later in the thread you misrepresented what they'd written.

"Thank you. I am no longer going to engage with that poster... I mean, a fucking burger van. Ok, I will just pull one out my ass and go set it up somewhere. It is that easy when you have no money, no knowledge of business, the laws and regulations about catering etc., and no desire to have one anyway."

It's a bit of a running theme with you, isn't it? Why would anybody believe your narrative?

Ah, that was the other poster. Both of you continued on another thread about it too... and quelle surprise... here you are again.

Please leave me the fuck alone.

ThisOldThang · 05/05/2025 21:51

You have repeatedly made completely false allegations about what I've written - e.g. I accused you of binning medication. That simply never happened.

Perhaps if you want to be left alone you shouldn't repeatedly engage in brigading based upon lies and misrepresentations of what people have written?

As per that screenshot, the person was very polite and didn't 'keep going on about it'.

You repeatedly do this in order to cast yourself as a victim of terrible bullying that has simply never happened. You then use these fabricated events as a justification for your insults and toxic behaviour.

But of course, it's never you that's the problem, is it?

XenoBitch · 05/05/2025 21:53

ThisOldThang · 05/05/2025 21:51

You have repeatedly made completely false allegations about what I've written - e.g. I accused you of binning medication. That simply never happened.

Perhaps if you want to be left alone you shouldn't repeatedly engage in brigading based upon lies and misrepresentations of what people have written?

As per that screenshot, the person was very polite and didn't 'keep going on about it'.

You repeatedly do this in order to cast yourself as a victim of terrible bullying that has simply never happened. You then use these fabricated events as a justification for your insults and toxic behaviour.

But of course, it's never you that's the problem, is it?

Edited

What is your point here? You have come on this thread with made up bullshit about my life history. UC has not even existed for 15 years. Why the obsession with me?

It may have been the other poster that accused me of binning meds. You both made me feel awful so it stands to reason I got you mixed up.

0ohLarLar · 05/05/2025 21:54

You have to understand right? It can be difficult for working people to empathise when it feels there's a narrative that "work" is the only thing people say they can never manage.

You will get a poster who will patiently explain that they can manage (with x, y, z supports etc)

  • holidays
  • parenting
  • hobbies
  • socialising
  • posting online/using computers

And will give 55 reasons why they can manage these things sometimes etc but can

never manage work

But maybe a change of mindset would help, I think maybe some people who've been out of the workplace a while (or maybe never got there to begin with) don't realise how much things have changed. Mental health and neurodiversity are embraced, the culture is to support people and ask what they need, and provide it.

You need an employer that is flexible about wfh because you are autistic and can't really cope with the noise of the team? Got it - i have a chap in my team like this.
You need mental health support? Got it. Every single team in my company has a wellbeing champion, access to helpline & face to face support, private health. In my experience this is quite common in large corporates.
You need part time work? Fab. We've got people at all levels, including up to the level below c-suite, working part time.
You're going to have some organisation issues? Ok. We'll look at how we can support you, we often get extra software packages or assistive technology. We'll ask you what helps you function, and we'll listen.
You need a quiet space to bolt to for a time out? There's a dedicated space on every floor of the building.

ThisOldThang · 05/05/2025 21:58

@XenoBitch Nobody accused you of binning medication. You completely made up the allegation.

Firefly1987 · 05/05/2025 22:15

@0ohLarLar so what exactly would you "allow" out of work people to do? Absolutely bloody nothing by the sounds of it. Maybe just sit in a dark room rocking back and forth...

ThisOldThang · 05/05/2025 22:23

@Firefly1987 That's a disingenuous question. OohLarLar was clearly referring to those people that declare themselves to be 'too ill to work', but can manage holidays, childcare, hobbies, socialising and posting/using a computer.

Being out of work, isn't the same as declaring yourself unfit to work.

suntrees · 05/05/2025 22:33

My son is autistic and will come across as very rude and direct if he’s working with the general public like retail but due to learning disabilities he doesn’t have much education and will probably be forced to do just that and be sacked immediately because he would cause outrage to customers with his lack social skills, he’ll offend someone and probably end up in the media for saying something outrages but truthful and give the company a bad name or worse sued.

0ohLarLar · 05/05/2025 22:37

thisoldthang thank you

Exactly. For that group of people who clearly do have some functioning capability, it seems there can be a mindset of assuming a workplace simply won't offer any/enough of the concessions or supports that they rely on to manage other areas of life. I'm saying be open minded as actually these days workplace must & do offer far more concession to make work possible for people with additional challenges.

I work for a large corporate & my role gives me exposure to others. You might be surprised how many people manage work around mental health issues, children with severe disabilities, neurodiversity. Many find that work actually helps.

0ohLarLar · 05/05/2025 22:43

Suntrees why do you assume a customer facing role is likely? There are less and less of those.

More likely is something like a logistics role packaging goods in a delivery company, cleaning work. Does he do well with heavy work? There are roles in logistics around delivery of heavy goods etc.

I do think however, that cognitive/severe learning disabilities are probably the biggest barrier to work. Someone who's able bodied but lacks the capacity to master even relatively simple tasks, who perhaps will never be able to read or recognise numbers, is always going to require support.

XenoBitch · 05/05/2025 22:43

0ohLarLar · 05/05/2025 22:37

thisoldthang thank you

Exactly. For that group of people who clearly do have some functioning capability, it seems there can be a mindset of assuming a workplace simply won't offer any/enough of the concessions or supports that they rely on to manage other areas of life. I'm saying be open minded as actually these days workplace must & do offer far more concession to make work possible for people with additional challenges.

I work for a large corporate & my role gives me exposure to others. You might be surprised how many people manage work around mental health issues, children with severe disabilities, neurodiversity. Many find that work actually helps.

They would have to get a job to start with.

For someone who is disabled and high skilled, their employer will make adaptions and concessions. For some unskilled NMW job.... they will employ the people most capable with no adaptions. So not the disabled.

ThisOldThang · 05/05/2025 22:47

My local Sainsbury's has a number of differently abled staff. The guy that collects the trolleys has zero social/customer skills (he's really quite rude and I've witnessed him shouting at people looking for trolleys). There are people working within the store who are (to my layman's eyes) almost certainly autistic.

Plenty of people, with a variety of disabilities, can and do find work.

JenniferBooth · 05/05/2025 22:51

XenoBitch · 05/05/2025 22:43

They would have to get a job to start with.

For someone who is disabled and high skilled, their employer will make adaptions and concessions. For some unskilled NMW job.... they will employ the people most capable with no adaptions. So not the disabled.

Absolutely. When an employer pays NMW what they are really saying is "i would like to pay you less but i cant get away with it" They are hardly going to be scrambling to do adaptations or reasonable adjustments

Firefly1987 · 05/05/2025 22:55

Jjjjyy · 05/05/2025 17:10

I remember once having a twitter fight with someone who was unemployed for years , "couldn't work" or "couldn't find work" but had time to dress up in silly superhero costumes and go to conventions.

Well time isn't the issue is it? Some people just can't deal with the stress and expectations of work. Having to complete work in a certain amount of time and having to keep a cool head under stress. Having to think outside the box and problem solve, these are all things above some people's skillset. I don't see how going to a convention occasionally has any relevance to anything. You could take a toddler to a convention doesn't mean they can hold down a fulltime job either...

Firefly1987 · 05/05/2025 22:56

ThisOldThang · 05/05/2025 22:47

My local Sainsbury's has a number of differently abled staff. The guy that collects the trolleys has zero social/customer skills (he's really quite rude and I've witnessed him shouting at people looking for trolleys). There are people working within the store who are (to my layman's eyes) almost certainly autistic.

Plenty of people, with a variety of disabilities, can and do find work.

And you think customers being abused on a daily basis by this guy is a happy medium? Probably not happened to you yet so it's fine...

Itsoneofthose · 05/05/2025 22:59

You are so right OP. There’s been a lot of effort in reducing stigma of mental illness, but just by raising ‘awareness’. ‘It’s ok not to be ok’ and all of that…. But people in general don’t have a scooby do what to do and how to react if someone has a panic attack for example, or behaves in any which way outside of social norms. Even people who consider themselves really switched on and aware seem to describe pretty low level depression and anxiety and parade themselves as experts in mental health or so called wellness coaches. They wouldn’t have a single clue about anything more serious and probably couldn’t spot it a mile off . I hope it back fires greatly, but sadly, again, the most vulnerable in society pay the price. It’s extremely awful and sad. We are no near good enough at understanding mental illness, addiction? Forget it. We’re in the dark ages.