Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you give up your ideal of a relationship for this alternative?

105 replies

Togivepp · 21/01/2025 21:10

I had a baby at 35, now 38 with a three year old. I was in a relationship when I became pregnant early on in the relationship and this man left me as he took a job hundreds of miles away and said he couldn’t cope being a dad etc. I was devastated. He supported financially but didn’t see dd until she was 1.

The last two years he’s been a totally dedicated father despite living the other side of the country. He travels weekly to see dd and books leave to spend extra time with her. He gives more than he needs to finance wise and has been kind to me, ensures I get rest at the weekend and if I want time on my own he takes dd and if I want to spend time with her too he will totally accept that and is entirely flexible with what I want to happen.

Over the last two years I have put my all into putting the past behind me for DD’s sake. It’s not always been easy and we’ve had times where we’ve argued by in the main it has often felt like we are just a normal family. We had a lovely relationship (before he upped and left!) and we get on well. I have never once indicated I wanted us to be together again for obvious reasons.

So the issue… recently he has started talking about the future and suggesting we live in the same home together. By this he means we move to him and we are a family, in a relationship. I have of course asked him many times why he left and he says he regrets it and he was not coping with changes at work (he is in senior surgical role in nhs). He says I was putting pressure on him to not take the job he had worked all his life for (consultant) and that had meant he just ran away and he regrets it. It’s not strictly true that I told him not to take the job but I didn’t cope well with the surprise pregnancy and looking back I was panicking and probably didn’t help with his panic too.

When he first indicated he wanted us to consider being together I was firm in my mind that it was no. One of the issues is that he rarely wanted sex and I missed that a lot, I know that wouldn’t change so I would essentially be signing up to a largely if not completely sexless life. But as time has gone on I wonder if I am making a mistake. I have my own home and I work but it’s a slog. I am constantly stretched. Being with him would give me options. I could easily work part time and still pay my mortgage or even rent out my home and continue to save. He wouldn’t expect me to contribute to the running of the home where we were living. We get on well, DD would be delighted. I would have freedom to see friends and family more. I know a lot of it sounds materialistic but it’s actually not that (he’s not one to splash cash on a handbag!)… it’s more that I could finally relax a bit. I would have my home still and still have my pension etc but day to day life could be filled more with seeing friends and family. He is supportive, I enjoy his company, I could have some nice holidays and someone to cuddle up to each night. Someone who makes me laugh. But it’s not exactly a fairytale is it?

what would you do? Just wonder if I’m making a huge mistake in digging my heels in out of principal because he left me, despite what good stuff has happened since. I know I could meet someone else but i never feel really inclined to get out there and try it.

OP posts:
NeedSomeComfy · 21/01/2025 21:16

You are not digging your heels in out of principle. This man LEFT YOU WHILE PREGNANT to raise a baby for a year on your own. How fucking dare he? And now he regrets it and wants to waltz right back into your life in just the way he wants it? Maybe there is a possibility for the two of you to get back together and be a family but it seems to me there's a LOT more grovelling that needs to be done, and some serious chats about how he will truly never dream of anything so selfish and outrageous ever again, before you should trust him.

Mopsy567 · 21/01/2025 21:28

I think if you don't feel love for this man it would be hard to tolerate him everyday. Love makes us forgive annoying habits or mistakes, but living without love can make you wonder 'what if' you found someone else whilst you are in that situation. I'm not sure you could ever be happy like that, especially knowing he abandoned you once.

Alternatively you could try living together for three months as a trial period. I'm sure you will get your answer then.

mumofoneAlonebutokay · 21/01/2025 21:34

Why doesn't he want sex? I'd want to mske sure he's not secretly gay but hasn't met the right man to make him accept it

Otherwise, I don't think you'd be unreasonable either way. Being a working mum is tough and it would allow you to enjoy life

But tbh I'd prefer to be alone. Could you ask him for more financial support so you can go part time?

You sound like you've done amazingly well, op x

MyProudHare · 21/01/2025 21:36

Is he planning to move closer to you, or will you need to move across the country? I'm not sure I would leave my family and friends for him (presuming you have them close by... or are they not?).

Behindthethymes · 21/01/2025 21:38

He seems deeply selfish. And this proposal doesn’t put him out in anyway does it. Yet you’d be uprooting yourself, and dd, leaving behind whatever support systems you have, maybe changing job. You can rent out your house and that’s great but you would have to find somewhere else to live if it doesn’t work out.

I can see why you’re considering it. My values changed a lot through having dc.

username299 · 21/01/2025 21:42

I don't see anything positive here. You don't know him very well; you got pregnant early in the relationship and then he moved far away.

Since then he's been long distance and visited once a week. He ran away and left you when the going got tough. He's offering a sexless relationship and is a flight risk.

He's never experienced the grind of bringing up a child. He expects you and your daughter to uproot yourselves and move to him.

Willyoujust · 21/01/2025 21:46

Absolutely no way I could trust someone who did that to me.

healthybychristmas · 21/01/2025 21:47

No way on this earth! He didn't give you a second thought when he cleared off, did he? He thought he couldn't cope, well how did he think you could cope? He left you to cope completely on your own while he lived the life of a single man. I'm glad he is a good father now but he really wasn't man and I wouldn't be able to forgive that.

Ikeameatballs · 21/01/2025 21:48

Did you post on here at the time of your pregnancy? Some of your situation sounds very familiar.

As to what you should do now, what would make you happy? Personally I can see little harm in moving in with him and seeing how it works out.

Togivepp · 21/01/2025 21:48

Thanks for the replies! @Behindthethymes @Mopsy567 @Mopsy567 @mumofoneAlonebutokay @MyProudHare

To answer some questions I have often raised the abandoning with him and over time I have I suppose come to understand him more as a person and do believe he is genuinely regretful. I will of course never be able to forget it though.

When I look at friends’ relationships I can see that he is a decent man by most standards (the abandoning to one side…). He does far more for me and dd that most dads I know.

I am not worried about security if it didn’t work out as I would never be stupid enough to give up work etc but it’s true that by living with him I would actually be more financially secure and as crass as it may sound, that does count for a lot. I should say though that I would not consider this for a second unless I did genuinely get on with him and have some sort of connection with him.

We share a lot of similar values and in terms of bringing up dd it’s been plain sailing on that front as we are very aligned.

I really do no think he is gay as he is clearly turned on if we are next to each other on the sofa or the few times we have hugged etc. But I just know sex would not feature much. He’s always been that way.

I am so conflicted. I almost feel like we are an old married couple anyway so why aren’t we just sharing the load and enjoying the wider parts of life

OP posts:
Porkyporkchop · 21/01/2025 21:50

its a difficult one but you need to think long and hard about this. I had a similar offer many years ago, but I just didn’t love him and I didn’t want to just have a comfy life without the love. I ended up struggling for years, and often regretted it at that time when things were so hard, but in the end I met my dh and he is the light of my life (alongside our kids). I am so pleased I didn’t pursue the easy route as honestly I wouldn’t have been happy long term.

Togivepp · 21/01/2025 21:51

Ikeameatballs · 21/01/2025 21:48

Did you post on here at the time of your pregnancy? Some of your situation sounds very familiar.

As to what you should do now, what would make you happy? Personally I can see little harm in moving in with him and seeing how it works out.

@Ikeameatballs if I am honest I am pretty happy around him. It almost annoys me as it would be easier to hate him. And I did hate him for a very long time. I do know he is sorry, he has been in tears many times and explained his regret. I suppose I just think life is short and whilst I don’t think this is anything close to a fairytale, what he is offering means I would have more freedom in every sense and that would certainly enhance my life.

OP posts:
Talulahalula · 21/01/2025 21:52

You would be the one moving to him, if I read this correctly?
So it makes his life easier, I think, and moves you from where your life is.
Or have I misunderstood?

Togivepp · 21/01/2025 21:52

Porkyporkchop · 21/01/2025 21:50

its a difficult one but you need to think long and hard about this. I had a similar offer many years ago, but I just didn’t love him and I didn’t want to just have a comfy life without the love. I ended up struggling for years, and often regretted it at that time when things were so hard, but in the end I met my dh and he is the light of my life (alongside our kids). I am so pleased I didn’t pursue the easy route as honestly I wouldn’t have been happy long term.

@Porkyporkchop thank you for sharing, this is my other thought too… I know I could probably have another sort of love that would be more fulfilling. But then I do have dd with this man and we have had some lovely times as a three.

OP posts:
Togivepp · 21/01/2025 21:53

Talulahalula · 21/01/2025 21:52

You would be the one moving to him, if I read this correctly?
So it makes his life easier, I think, and moves you from where your life is.
Or have I misunderstood?

@Talulahalula yes. If he stays earning the money he is on then he couldn’t move further north. I can easily move. I would actually love to live where he is based so I am not fazed by that but part of the understanding between us would have to be that I can travel and use the income to be able to go back and forth as i wanted

OP posts:
Talulahalula · 21/01/2025 21:59

Togivepp · 21/01/2025 21:53

@Talulahalula yes. If he stays earning the money he is on then he couldn’t move further north. I can easily move. I would actually love to live where he is based so I am not fazed by that but part of the understanding between us would have to be that I can travel and use the income to be able to go back and forth as i wanted

What are his reasons for wanting you to be a family together?

To some extent, having been a single parent most of my DC’s life with very little financial and practical support, I can see why you are considering it. It is not simple to meet someone else and certainly not easy to introduce them to your DC.

I also don’t think that you need to necessarily be having mind-blowing sex and a lot of chemistry to have a lasting and strong relationship.

But I do wonder what he thinks he is offering you. Does he intend this to be a convenient set up for practical reasons where he would not have to travel and can see his DD more regularly? Or does he love you and intend to be with you for the long haul? And what do you think?

AelinAG · 21/01/2025 22:00

I don’t think I would do it, but I wouldn’t blame you for doing it

Togivepp · 21/01/2025 22:03

Talulahalula · 21/01/2025 21:59

What are his reasons for wanting you to be a family together?

To some extent, having been a single parent most of my DC’s life with very little financial and practical support, I can see why you are considering it. It is not simple to meet someone else and certainly not easy to introduce them to your DC.

I also don’t think that you need to necessarily be having mind-blowing sex and a lot of chemistry to have a lasting and strong relationship.

But I do wonder what he thinks he is offering you. Does he intend this to be a convenient set up for practical reasons where he would not have to travel and can see his DD more regularly? Or does he love you and intend to be with you for the long haul? And what do you think?

@Talulahalula i actually don’t know whether he thinks I’m ’the love of his life’ or something like that. He’s not your most conventional person, he’s quite serious and often reserved, but we have a similar sense of humour. I do know that he cares and he’s spent time choosing lovely gifts for Mother’s Day and birthdays etc. I know that’s an easy win to some extent but I can just tell he’s put thought into it and that he does enjoy my company, he will often suggest a trip away for example.

i do think some of it is convenience on his part but then that’s exactly why I am considering what he’s said. I expect he feels similar to me… perhaps there is someone or something else that would have been a great relationship but this thing between us isn’t nothing and we both enjoy it.

OP posts:
BlanketLanyard · 21/01/2025 22:07

Have you posted about this before or am I having deja vu?

Octavia64 · 21/01/2025 22:09

I would be very concerned that if anything negative happened - DD became ill etc then he would just run away again.

I wouldn't necessarily reject the idea on that basis but I would always always have back up plans.

teenmaw · 21/01/2025 22:15

OP it sounds like he regrets his shitty behaviour and had made up for it as much as he can (it's partly unforgivable) Having left an awful marriage that I stayed in for the kids, what you're being offered here does sound appealing. It's a much better setup than I had and sounds like you'll have the means to duck out if you decide later it's not for you. But then I now live my peace and freedom. If he's keeping you going with cash and free time when you know dd is well looked after, that's a good option too. I'd say you're in a win win situation here with two good options. Are you looking for security or true love? (With the risk you may never find it)

Talulahalula · 21/01/2025 22:17

I don’t think he needs to be the love of your life, but I do think you need some more clarity about the offer on the table and his motivations for it. You are considering moving your DD and yourself so what you ‘expect’ he feels or thinks is not really good enough. Honestly, you should be able to have this conversation of what your and his expectations and feelings are. I think that is more important than whether he ran away for the first year, you need a really good sense of where he is at now.
I think it is important to be able to be open and honest with each other, and build a sense of mutual understanding, if you are going to consider this.

EveryOtherNameTaken · 21/01/2025 22:23

BlanketLanyard · 21/01/2025 22:07

Have you posted about this before or am I having deja vu?

I thought the same.

OCDmama · 21/01/2025 22:29

If you have an escape plan and you're able to extricate yourself if this goes tits up, then I say do it.

Love grows, and he sounds remorseful.

You can lead a happy life with a companion by your side. I think we put too much stock in stupid Hollywood movies - finding the right partner should take into a lot of practical elements.

Togivepp · 21/01/2025 22:34

OCDmama · 21/01/2025 22:29

If you have an escape plan and you're able to extricate yourself if this goes tits up, then I say do it.

Love grows, and he sounds remorseful.

You can lead a happy life with a companion by your side. I think we put too much stock in stupid Hollywood movies - finding the right partner should take into a lot of practical elements.

@OCDmama i could definitely leave if needed. I have my own security on that front and would never leave employment.

I do have concerns that dd would be uprooted but perhaps the risk is worth it if it did work. I do keep telling myself the right partner isn’t always Hollywood style but am I just pretending to be ok with it, I don’t know? I just want the pressure off and to feel like part of a unit. Is it sad to forgo sex and have to forgive fully what he did? I don’t know if that’s actually really sad. It’s so confusing as we operate as a family in practice

OP posts: