Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be shocked at the net migration figures currently being discussed

1000 replies

Feelingathomenow · 28/11/2024 11:06

Yesterday’s figures discussed by the Tories stated that since 2010 the net migration figures to the UK has equalled the size of the population of Wales. Today we were told the figures to June 2023 showed a net migration figure of nearly 1 million for that year, for the year to June 2024 this had reduced to a mere 3/4 of a million. The numbers coming in of the boats per year alone is equal to a large town. AIBU to think this has to stop. We need to immediately crack down on people allowed into this country- limit it to urgently needed highly skilled jobs and start offshore processing (or similar) of the people who are here illegally (basically like many other countries).

We just can’t cope with those numbers. - no wonder our infrastructure is collapsing, we have a housing crisis etc.

I want to hear from the government how they are going to tackle it. We have heard from the Tories now it is over to Starmer.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
21
Feelingathomenow · 28/11/2024 15:58

Triffid1 · 28/11/2024 15:54

Reporting on this is so poor. So 750,000 more people came in than left. okay. I have a lot of questions.
1 Who were the people who left?
2 of the people who came in - includig the 750,000, how many are coming over on boats or illegally? Who are the rest and where are they coming from.

How can anyone get het up abot imigration without wanting to know the basic answers to these questions is beyond me. I mean, how can anything be addressed if we don't know the answers to these questions. Do these 750000 people bring increased productivity, skills and GDP? Are they all benefit scroungers? Where are they moving to? Is that a good thing or a bad thing? The people who are leaving - why are they leaving? how many of them are leaving - is this number up or down? Do we want those wh oare leaving to leave or would we rather they stayed?

You can find all this information online

OP posts:
OctoberOctopus · 28/11/2024 15:58

TheGander · 28/11/2024 15:56

I’m not pretending anything but nonetheless a vast amount was spent trying to reform the society, many lives were lost and there’s precious little to show for it. This gives some flavour of the cultural values ingrained in Afghanistan ( Afghan men) and I’d argue they are not terribly compatible with European values.

Indeed, they aren't welcome here until they value women and girls and education and equality of the sexes.

ContactNightmare · 28/11/2024 15:59

It is ridiculous and legal migration is by design. What a bloody disaster. I hope the Labour government end this model where foreign labour with dependents is effectively preferred. The Conservatives have just exploited this for money, all the time. Replacing one form of temporary migration which was highly qualified with migration which is dependent, lesser qualified and paid less, in greater numbers. The Tory Party spent all its time going on about Rwanda as if no one would notice the legal migration fiddle they put in post Brexit.

TheGander · 28/11/2024 15:59

Brexit was idiotic, with some exceptions European migrants are more likely to integrate and to be productive. We have had to bring in migrants from other parts of the world to fill the vacuum when Europeans left.

Cornettoninja · 28/11/2024 16:00

TheGander · 28/11/2024 15:52

Climate change is going to be the next reason the left deploys to justify millions pouring in.

Well yes. The fact this can be seen well in advance would suggest there’s more behind it than just ‘justification’.

the climate is shifting and that will inevitably lead to migration. I suppose you should just hope you’re not in an area that would lead you to have to make that choice.

ToBeOrNotToBee · 28/11/2024 16:00

Tabitha005 · 28/11/2024 15:56

Abso-fucken-lutely. Nailed it.

Primates, big cats, wolves, some whale species and even your garden robin has territory.
Borders aren't unique to humans. They are a way of keeping safe.

Feelingathomenow · 28/11/2024 16:00

Alicecatto · 28/11/2024 15:51

Why were Ukranians welcomed, but Afghanis not? Couldn't we have argued that they all should stay there and fight and sort themselves out? Of course not.

I don't think any of use who have not been in a Taliban like government or a war zone can blithely say...oh, something for you lot to sort out.

We can agree to disagree about that.

the vast majority of people coming from Ukraine were women and children the men stayed to fight. The vast majority of those from Afghanistan are men leaving their wives under the Taliban

OP posts:
Tabitha005 · 28/11/2024 16:00

OctoberOctopus · 28/11/2024 15:58

Indeed, they aren't welcome here until they value women and girls and education and equality of the sexes.

Edited

... because, of course, ALL British men do.

ContactNightmare · 28/11/2024 16:01

TheGander · 28/11/2024 15:59

Brexit was idiotic, with some exceptions European migrants are more likely to integrate and to be productive. We have had to bring in migrants from other parts of the world to fill the vacuum when Europeans left.

It was done by a bunch of exploitative employers and Tories who could not wait to have a system that meant they could employ foreign labour at cheap rates, and employ non unionised staff in public services. Suited them down to the ground.

Feelingathomenow · 28/11/2024 16:01

Tabitha005 · 28/11/2024 16:00

... because, of course, ALL British men do.

But as a whole, yes they do, that is the norm on British culture. We develop words like misogyny and chauvinism to indicate this. There will always be outliers

OP posts:
quantumbutterfly · 28/11/2024 16:01

ExtraOnions · 28/11/2024 12:17

…so who is going to do the “low skills” jobs that have been filled by migrant labour? Fruit Picking, Factory work, Hospitality etc? (Apologies for the term “low skilled”). Do you have people in your immediate circle who would do these jobs.

You are never going to stop people coming over, we are a nation built in immigration. When it comes to illegal immigration, or asylum seekers etc, we need more staff to process claims.

We have an ageing demographic and need young people.. we should be encouraging them over to make their homes here

So you approve of this exploitative system ? You're happy not to pay a living wage to people who do essential jobs.

TheGander · 28/11/2024 16:01

Cornettoninja · 28/11/2024 16:00

Well yes. The fact this can be seen well in advance would suggest there’s more behind it than just ‘justification’.

the climate is shifting and that will inevitably lead to migration. I suppose you should just hope you’re not in an area that would lead you to have to make that choice.

Well, that remains to be seen but there’s no guarantee that life here won’t be highly negatively affected.

IhaveanewTVnow · 28/11/2024 16:03

Cockwomblers · 28/11/2024 14:04

People are living in their small villages etc completely clueless, champagne socialists.

wait until you live in somewhere like East London where literally nobody speaks English, every sign is in Bangladeshi language etc. I too was a former leftie who didn’t believe it till I saw it whilst visiting

Illegal immigration is an issue but so is the legal, people bringing in tonnes of dependents (usually women) who don’t work and have no intention of doing so. Over 50% of women in London’s Tower Hamlets borough don’t work. 30% of the borough is economically ‘inactive’.
these are people who don’t even want to contribute anything to a British society or values, they want to live completely seperately but have all the perks of our country’s generous welfare system. It’s heartbreaking, really. These people don’t speak any English yet somehow have brand new build council properties, PIP, other benefits etc, how? Why are gov and council departments supporting this?
we are an island and have to start protecting and supporting British born people.

people are literally stupid if they don’t see what’s happening here and we are sleepwalking in to a disaster, which I sadly fear may already be too late.

Not just London. Visit Maidstone. Gangs of lads hanging around outside hotels. Is changing the make up of the town.

OctoberOctopus · 28/11/2024 16:03

Tabitha005 · 28/11/2024 16:00

... because, of course, ALL British men do.

But they are already here. Why welcome more men that don't value women! Seriously it's not rocket science, we have x number of men who don't value women already, let's not increase those numbers 🙄

Feelingathomenow · 28/11/2024 16:04

ToBeOrNotToBee · 28/11/2024 16:00

Primates, big cats, wolves, some whale species and even your garden robin has territory.
Borders aren't unique to humans. They are a way of keeping safe.

Exactly. Humans are tribal, they always have been. I’m always absolutely astounded by the number of people who seem to think John Lennon songs are a blue print for society

OP posts:
DoraGray · 28/11/2024 16:04

This thread is a reflection of real life.
Two thirds of people who voted agree with you @Feelingathomenow but many of the actual posts on this thread are those of the minority who are unable to join the dots.

So, those who shout loudest may think they carry the day but the majority are not with them. Unless those in power realise this, pretty quickly, then we are finally going to do what a lot of Europe has already done and a truly Far Right government-who make Farage et al look like kittens-will be voted in.

Let;s not forget that the reason the Tories lost the election was because so many were angry at their handling of immigration and went to Reform. That feeling is not going away any time soon.

To be able to bark racist at anyone who feels- as the majority of those who voted on this thread do- that we have a problem has been the default position for some time and- for some time- it was very effective in silencing those who can see that there is a problem.

The term is starting to lose its potency however and many people are now no longer frightened of being called racist if they think there is a problem with immigration. Of course, the old dinosaurs-many who have posted here- have not realised this and continue to throw the term about.

They have not yet realised that it is no longer an effective weapon in shutting people up. They are behind the zeitgeist of the majority-70% on this thread and a similar number throughout the country.

If to make negative remarks about i immigration is to be racist then so-many say-be it.

PlopSofa · 28/11/2024 16:04

ArticWillow · 28/11/2024 12:38

Due to the falling birth rates we actually need migration.

Because who will do all the jobs in decades to come?
And more importantly, who will buy stuff to keep the forever upwards trend of the economy?

The is a flawed premise - we cannot grow exponentially forever... are we just to continue to explode the population within this small densely populated country forever?

genesis92 · 28/11/2024 16:04

ExtraOnions · 28/11/2024 12:17

…so who is going to do the “low skills” jobs that have been filled by migrant labour? Fruit Picking, Factory work, Hospitality etc? (Apologies for the term “low skilled”). Do you have people in your immediate circle who would do these jobs.

You are never going to stop people coming over, we are a nation built in immigration. When it comes to illegal immigration, or asylum seekers etc, we need more staff to process claims.

We have an ageing demographic and need young people.. we should be encouraging them over to make their homes here

The problem is that mass unskilled migration just lowers wages in these types of jobs. If people are paid enough, they will do these jobs

OctoberOctopus · 28/11/2024 16:05

IhaveanewTVnow · 28/11/2024 16:03

Not just London. Visit Maidstone. Gangs of lads hanging around outside hotels. Is changing the make up of the town.

It's awful. Not working just hanging around. Of they are legal getvthem working, if not be gone.

louddumpernoise · 28/11/2024 16:05

ChubbyBubbyBoo · 28/11/2024 15:57

The problem is the predominately white, left wing middle class, living in their little bubble of whiteness - maybe they have a few black friends or a polish cleaner - who say immigration is not a problem and support large scale immigration. They aren’t directly affected by it! They aren’t stood in the park with their kids as the only British family there, feeling isolated and excluded in their own country! Their child isn’t the only white child in their class at school. They aren’t feeling unsafe by foreign men shouting at them and leering at them in the street. They are comfortably housed and aren’t having to compete for the council homes dwindling stock to house their family.

The almost 1m migrants coming here was under a Tory Government.

275k came from India alone.... that trade deal

Sorry but its since 2019, under a Tory Govt that migration has gone from 219k to 906k....

Migration has always hovered around 200k, so why did the Tories allow to go to 900k ???

Its happened under a right wing Govt.... Labour now have to deal with this, alongside everything else the Tories fucked up.

JudgeJenny · 28/11/2024 16:05

97% of the figures released today came here through legal immigration. Just saying.

genesis92 · 28/11/2024 16:05

Mylifeisamesssuchamess · 28/11/2024 12:29

You do realise that people actually leave the country too.

That's why it's called "net migration" 🙄

Seriously, come on

midgetastic · 28/11/2024 16:05

We all share the same planet

The natural tribe size of around 25 people isn't viable - we have to live as part of a bigger society - so we have tribes within tribes within tribes to make things function

Why can't that biggest level of society encompass the whole ?

Feelingathomenow · 28/11/2024 16:06

IhaveanewTVnow · 28/11/2024 16:03

Not just London. Visit Maidstone. Gangs of lads hanging around outside hotels. Is changing the make up of the town.

Maybe that’s the answer. Plonk a load of caravans around Home Counties commuter belt naice villages and move the immigrants there

OP posts:
1dayatatime · 28/11/2024 16:06

@Hunglikeapolevaulter

"what is it really that bothers you about migration"

A very good question so from my perspective it is:

Seems ridiculous for taxes to be paying for UK nationals to be economically inactive and then import cheaper labour to do the jobs that UK nationals are not willing to do for the salaries on offer. A similar set up was used for the sugar plantations in the West Indies except they called it the slave trade.

Increasing the population increases pressure on the existing infrastructure, causes environmental damage, pressures on healthcare, education etc

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.