Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want a way to label the reasonable fear of the variety of Islam that wishes to impose Sharia law?

492 replies

Oodiks · 22/11/2024 19:40

I understand that there are different sects within Islam and that while some pose no concerns, others do. I am horrified at the type of Sharia law imposed in Iran, Saudi Arabia, and Afghanistan, which denies women human rights, but it's hard to talk about those reasonable fears without being labelled Islamophobic. It's not unreasonable to fear a religion that imposes such harsh lives on women.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
socialdilemmawhattodo · 22/11/2024 21:39

Noseybookworm · 22/11/2024 19:51

It's not the religion you fear but the people imposing an extreme version of that religion. This happens with all religions, including Christianity. Of course no sane person supports the insane control of women perpetrated in Iran and Afghanistan - moderate Muslims included.

But I don't believe I am seeing Muslim men stand up against this at all, and that does concern me. I do wonder, in all seriousness, just how misogynist the whole (and other organised religions) faith is?

Oodiks · 22/11/2024 21:41

Completelyjo · 22/11/2024 20:40

I am horrified at the type of Sharia law imposed in Iran, Saudi Arabia, and Afghanistan, which denies women human rights, but it's hard to talk about those reasonable fears without being labelled Islamophobic

Really? You’ve discussed being horrified at the regime in Iran and Saudi and people label it as Islamophobic? Somehow I doubt that.

There are some extremist Muslims in the UK who hide behind Islam to be homophobic, misogynistic and patriarchal limiting the rights of women, this is also seen in hardline Christmas groups and Hasidic Jews.

I think fearing sharia law will be placed on all UK citizens is crazy and unfounded though.

What no-one seems to realize is that Judaism is extremely insular; I'm not aware of any Jewish sect trying to convert anyone or impose Judaic law on others.

Christians, I'll give you, have a pretty dicey history on this.

OP posts:
LoremIpsumCici · 22/11/2024 21:41

T4phage · 22/11/2024 21:09

Hardly. It's logical to assume that a country with a rapidly falling birthrate and an influx of people coming from other countries will eventually be overtaken.

Not everything is a conspiracy theory even if some conspiracy theorists have adopted some parts of it and twisted it into their own belief system.

The lack of logic is the assumption that immigrants will all be Muslims.
Christianity is the most populous religion in the world. It is more likely that the majority of U.K. will go all Catholic again than Muslim or Hindu.

Oodiks · 22/11/2024 21:42

socialdilemmawhattodo · 22/11/2024 21:39

But I don't believe I am seeing Muslim men stand up against this at all, and that does concern me. I do wonder, in all seriousness, just how misogynist the whole (and other organised religions) faith is?

Most religion is paternalistic, ruled by men. Pre monotheistic religions are more likely to center women as connected to the universe's creative energy.

OP posts:
socialdilemmawhattodo · 22/11/2024 21:44

Tabitabtab · 22/11/2024 20:48

Sharia Law is just God's law as to how humans and society should behave

Sadly it really isn't. Sharia Law is a code, under the veneer of religion, that allows a few men to dominate and drive custom. It is so harmful to women.

Oodiks · 22/11/2024 21:44

LoremIpsumCici · 22/11/2024 21:41

The lack of logic is the assumption that immigrants will all be Muslims.
Christianity is the most populous religion in the world. It is more likely that the majority of U.K. will go all Catholic again than Muslim or Hindu.

Research suggests that Muslims are the fastest growing religion, so logic suggests that more immigrants will be Muslim.

The Future of World Religions: Population Growth Projections, 2010-2050 | Pew Research Center

The Future of World Religions: Population Growth Projections, 2010-2050

As of 2010, nearly a third of the world's population identified as Christian. But if demographic trends persist, Islam will close the gap by the middle of the 21st century.

https://www.pewresearch.org/religion/2015/04/02/religious-projections-2010-2050/

OP posts:
LoremIpsumCici · 22/11/2024 21:45

Pre monotheistic religions are more likely to center women as connected to the universe's creative energy.

Incorrect.

Oodiks · 22/11/2024 21:45

LoremIpsumCici · 22/11/2024 21:45

Pre monotheistic religions are more likely to center women as connected to the universe's creative energy.

Incorrect.

You want to say more? Back up your rebuttal?

OP posts:
soupfiend · 22/11/2024 21:45

Dariamar · 22/11/2024 20:08

I don't know why the Muslim religion attracts so many extremists...because on its own it's peaceful religion...not feminist but not violent. But with all the calls to Jihad, Sharia law...it is now something people fear. If even 40% of people In Gaza support Hamas, that is a lot of people following an extremist ideology and it will take a lot to get to peace from that start point for example.

Its a young religion, like medieval christianity, look at them they were fanatics. I see it at the same stage as that. Will it be able to evolve itself?

Slowwly · 22/11/2024 21:46

Oodiks · 22/11/2024 21:36

You don't think Muslims want to impose Sharia law?

I wish people like you wouldn’t say ‘Muslims’ like we are all the same. Many of us are liberal. Fully integrated. Part of diverse communities. Born here. Living in the UK, some married to non-Muslims, wearing whatever we want, eating what we want but still identifying as Muslims. Some of us would be as scared of sharia law as you are. The biggest threat the Taliban etc pose is to other Muslims. Not the West.

Please don’t stereotype us all like this.

soupfiend · 22/11/2024 21:48

Oodiks · 22/11/2024 21:41

What no-one seems to realize is that Judaism is extremely insular; I'm not aware of any Jewish sect trying to convert anyone or impose Judaic law on others.

Christians, I'll give you, have a pretty dicey history on this.

Islam and Christianity are evangelical, its gods work to try to convert people. Im not sure Judaism has that element

Womblingmerrily · 22/11/2024 21:48

UK Census data on religion although it is important to note the question was voluntary - 94% answered

There were increases in the number of people who described themselves as “Muslim” (3.9 million, 6.5% in 2021, up from 2.7 million, 4.9% in 2011) and “Hindu” (1.0 million, 1.7% in 2021, up from 818,000, 1.5% in 2011).

Religious composition, 2011 and 2021, England and Wales

LoremIpsumCici · 22/11/2024 21:49

Oodiks · 22/11/2024 21:44

Research suggests that Muslims are the fastest growing religion, so logic suggests that more immigrants will be Muslim.

The Future of World Religions: Population Growth Projections, 2010-2050 | Pew Research Center

Ok, but the study you linked projected the by 2050 “In Europe, Muslims will make up 10% of the overall population.”

Now, most of these will be secular Muslims and have no interest in imposing Sharia law. So how is such a minority going to force over 90% of the population to follow Sharia law?

soupfiend · 22/11/2024 21:49

LoremIpsumCici · 22/11/2024 21:41

The lack of logic is the assumption that immigrants will all be Muslims.
Christianity is the most populous religion in the world. It is more likely that the majority of U.K. will go all Catholic again than Muslim or Hindu.

I think statistically the majority of newcomers to the UK are not christian so Im not sure why or how the UK would convert to Catholicism

Oodiks · 22/11/2024 21:49

Slowwly · 22/11/2024 21:46

I wish people like you wouldn’t say ‘Muslims’ like we are all the same. Many of us are liberal. Fully integrated. Part of diverse communities. Born here. Living in the UK, some married to non-Muslims, wearing whatever we want, eating what we want but still identifying as Muslims. Some of us would be as scared of sharia law as you are. The biggest threat the Taliban etc pose is to other Muslims. Not the West.

Please don’t stereotype us all like this.

That's exactly what my original question is about, so I'll rephrase:

You don't think any Muslims want to impose Sharia law?

OP posts:
Slowwly · 22/11/2024 21:51

Oodiks · 22/11/2024 21:49

That's exactly what my original question is about, so I'll rephrase:

You don't think any Muslims want to impose Sharia law?

Yes I do think some extremist Muslims want to impose sharia law. And I bloody well hope they don’t. I can’t see it happening in reality; hope not anyway.

Oodiks · 22/11/2024 21:51

soupfiend · 22/11/2024 21:48

Islam and Christianity are evangelical, its gods work to try to convert people. Im not sure Judaism has that element

It really doesn't. From my understanding, it's traditional for would be converts to be turned away 3 times before they can even consider begin to learn more.

OP posts:
turbonerd · 22/11/2024 21:58

There are definitely muslim men trying to speak out against the very misogynistic elements in Islam. Then they are often met with «you are criticising Islam unfairly» and/or threats of violence against themselves and their families.
Both the muslim men and women who dare to talk about the huge, glaring problems in Islam in public are very Brave - which in itself shows a problem Islam has within its most fundamentalist countries and communities.

Christianity does not issue fatwahs, not anymore.

T4phage · 22/11/2024 21:59

LoremIpsumCici · 22/11/2024 21:41

The lack of logic is the assumption that immigrants will all be Muslims.
Christianity is the most populous religion in the world. It is more likely that the majority of U.K. will go all Catholic again than Muslim or Hindu.

Not true. Islam is the fastest growing religion in the world and Christianity is declining in the UK, as we well know.

LoremIpsumCici · 22/11/2024 22:00

soupfiend · 22/11/2024 21:49

I think statistically the majority of newcomers to the UK are not christian so Im not sure why or how the UK would convert to Catholicism

Actually most migrants to the U.K. are Christians.
ONS response to a FOIA on it for 2022

top 3:

219,017 Christians
152,933 No religion
74,218 Muslim

Ratio is 3 Christians immigrating to the U.K. for every 1 Muslim.

To want a way to label the reasonable fear of the variety of Islam that wishes to impose Sharia law?
LoremIpsumCici · 22/11/2024 22:02

Christianity does not issue fatwahs, not anymore.

An equivalent to a fatwah is a papal bull. Last one issued was just six months ago.

LoremIpsumCici · 22/11/2024 22:05

T4phage · 22/11/2024 21:59

Not true. Islam is the fastest growing religion in the world and Christianity is declining in the UK, as we well know.

What isn’t true in my post?

LoremIpsumCici · 22/11/2024 22:13

Oodiks · 22/11/2024 21:45

You want to say more? Back up your rebuttal?

I’d have to write a book. It would be much easier if you simply read up on different polytheistic religions. Patriarchy long pre-existed monotheism and is almost universal in all times, religions and places.

Even if you just looked at Greek, Roman, Norse, Celtic, Sumerian, Persian, Egyptian, Hindu, Chinese, Japanese, Māori, Aztec, Inca, Zapotec, Ethiopian, Zulu, Igbo, Zoroastrianism, Minoan, Phoenician, Phillistine, Etruscan, Mongol, Nepalese, Scythian ancient religions you’d find eh, polytheism with male gods firmly in charge and the centre of divine power and might.

LoremIpsumCici · 22/11/2024 22:17

Even the early version of my religion, Judaism, was polytheistic and patriarchal- Yahwism.

username8348 · 22/11/2024 22:18

Oodiks · 22/11/2024 21:51

It really doesn't. From my understanding, it's traditional for would be converts to be turned away 3 times before they can even consider begin to learn more.

I thought your husband was Jewish, is that not correct? I'm sure you wrote that on one of your many posts on the conflict in the ME.