Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Just Stop Oil - I couldn't care less

504 replies

savannahowl · 28/09/2024 16:22

Those protestors actually make me feel even less bothered by climate change. I genuinely don't give a shit anymore.

Have they managed to convince anyone?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
15
SodaFountainMountain · 29/09/2024 13:00

Puzzledandpissedoff · 29/09/2024 12:55

You're forgetting the script, Windchimesandsong ... when the activists do something damaging to the environment we get "It's not about individual actions but driving governmental/systemic change", and the hypocrisy of telling other individuals what they should be doing or caring about gets brushed aside

Edited to add the same applies to the script about the apocolypse being upon us. When activists say this it's supposed to be regarded as if carved in stone, whereas others using it are told they're dissuading folk from making necessary changes

As usual with extremist causes the whole thing falls apart upon even the mildest enquiry, but it's not going to end while it remains catnip for the funders

Edited

Everyone is a hypocrite in some area of their life. It’s the part of the human condition. Unfortunately them being hypocritical doesn’t change the perilous state the planet and it’s inhabitants are in.

SodaFountainMountain · 29/09/2024 13:05

NewGreenDuck · 29/09/2024 12:44

Thank you so much for your sympathy. I'll let them know of your concern when we next dash to hospital in a life or death situation.

Sorry if that sounded like I don’t care. I absolutely do. Truly. And I’m not commenting on the rights or wrongs of JAOs actions.

But not caring about climate change and not doing anything about it is far worse than your child’s current concerns.

That’s true for us all. Whatever our current struggles climate breakdown is going to make things unimaginably worse. Not caring about it is nonsensical.

SodaFountainMountain · 29/09/2024 13:14

Toiletbrushdisaster · 29/09/2024 12:51

Was thinking the same but you put it so much better than I could.
When you see what a mess we are making of our own environment with litter ,graffiti, anti social behaviour ( dangerous cars,electric bikes and scooters risking safety of children,the elderly and disabled) and terrible violence it would be nice to see JSO organising something productive like picking up litter!
Most of us care very much about wildlife ,displaced people and the planet. But I do not need some time wasting , self righteous toaster ( dry ,crusty and keeps popping up? ) who in many cases appear not to have contributed much to society yet, lecturing me.
And if they use their prison time to lecture most of their fellow prisoners and the over worked stressed out,under paid staff ,well good luck with that !

Litter and electric scooters really are not the issue in terms of climate breakdown. I’m not commenting on the rights and wrongs of JSOs actions but I really do think you’ve been sucked into believing that climate change is a small inconvenience or something that will only impact other people.

Climate breakdown is already happening. More extreme weather events happening across the globe. Including Europe and the U.K.

More and more of the planet will become uninhabitable. Food and water more and more scarce. Mass climate related migration. Instability and more wars.

It’s already happening. Honestly, caring about the environment doesn’t mean picking up litter and doing a bit of recycling.

In the U.K. climate related mortality and morbidity is already increasing.

The more carbon we release, the worse it’s going to be.

Regardless of our feelings about JSO this is a devastating predicament we are all in.

Sorry.

Yamantau · 29/09/2024 13:29

SodaFountainMountain · 29/09/2024 13:05

Sorry if that sounded like I don’t care. I absolutely do. Truly. And I’m not commenting on the rights or wrongs of JAOs actions.

But not caring about climate change and not doing anything about it is far worse than your child’s current concerns.

That’s true for us all. Whatever our current struggles climate breakdown is going to make things unimaginably worse. Not caring about it is nonsensical.

But also the days of Galileo, we also need to be aware that just because it seems like climate change is bad, doesn't automatically mean everyone is correct

Lentilweaver · 29/09/2024 13:31

"Seems like" climate change is bad?😐

theresabluebirdinmyheart · 29/09/2024 13:35

savannahowl · 28/09/2024 16:32

They're ruining stuff that has actual human value.

Why don't they blow up a polyester factory or something actually damaging to the environment?

They're so annoying.

Yeah China and India cause the most pollution apparently. But they never carry out their “protests” there because that shit wouldn’t fly in China, they wouldn’t dare.

SodaFountainMountain · 29/09/2024 13:39

Yamantau · 29/09/2024 13:29

But also the days of Galileo, we also need to be aware that just because it seems like climate change is bad, doesn't automatically mean everyone is correct

Please get better informed. I mean, I wish you were right, and that I am concerned about nothing. But I know too much to be able to believe that. Anyway, surely it’s better to prepare for the worst but hope for the best?

SodaFountainMountain · 29/09/2024 13:42

theresabluebirdinmyheart · 29/09/2024 13:35

Yeah China and India cause the most pollution apparently. But they never carry out their “protests” there because that shit wouldn’t fly in China, they wouldn’t dare.

China are protecting themselves by investing heavily in green renewable power. As should we. If we stopped buying unnecessary crap, China’s emissions would reduce. We need our own legislation and policy that looks after our own interests. So of course the protests are here. I mean, regardless of the rights or wrongs of what they do, you can see how illogical your argument is can’t you?

Childfreecatlady · 29/09/2024 13:48

Peonies12 · 28/09/2024 16:24

I hope you haven’t reproduced. Do you not care about the future of the planet?

Exactly this. So many parents posting things like this. I'm sure they do nothing to help, only contribute to the destruction of the planet and then get upset at the people actually trying to make a difference. Shocking.

Toiletbrushdisaster · 29/09/2024 13:49

SodaFountainMountain · 29/09/2024 13:14

Litter and electric scooters really are not the issue in terms of climate breakdown. I’m not commenting on the rights and wrongs of JSOs actions but I really do think you’ve been sucked into believing that climate change is a small inconvenience or something that will only impact other people.

Climate breakdown is already happening. More extreme weather events happening across the globe. Including Europe and the U.K.

More and more of the planet will become uninhabitable. Food and water more and more scarce. Mass climate related migration. Instability and more wars.

It’s already happening. Honestly, caring about the environment doesn’t mean picking up litter and doing a bit of recycling.

In the U.K. climate related mortality and morbidity is already increasing.

The more carbon we release, the worse it’s going to be.

Regardless of our feelings about JSO this is a devastating predicament we are all in.

Sorry.

No I'm aware of the implications of climate change and it's outcomes.
I just feel that caring about anything , demonstrating about anything has to start somewhere and be perceived as useful to those already living at the bottom even in this country
I live in what many would call a rough area. There are some residents who try very hard to maintain a decent life for them and their neighbours. They are fighting a losing battle with sections of society who are threatening ,criminal and are turning their environment (Here . Now.) Into a slum. Supporting the stupid stunts of self publicising people would be far from their minds.
I understand that addressing climate change,world poverty,disease and all the other ills is vital for the world .i know picking up a bit of litter won't save us and that climate change is a very serious issue. But for many people who can't afford to travel on planes, who spend their whole lives poverty right now watching vandals attacking works of art does not convince them of JSO s case. I wonder if the activists themselves think they are going to change anything this way ?

theresabluebirdinmyheart · 29/09/2024 14:01

SodaFountainMountain · 29/09/2024 13:42

China are protecting themselves by investing heavily in green renewable power. As should we. If we stopped buying unnecessary crap, China’s emissions would reduce. We need our own legislation and policy that looks after our own interests. So of course the protests are here. I mean, regardless of the rights or wrongs of what they do, you can see how illogical your argument is can’t you?

I don’t actually give that much of a toss tbh hun

SodaFountainMountain · 29/09/2024 14:13

Toiletbrushdisaster · 29/09/2024 13:49

No I'm aware of the implications of climate change and it's outcomes.
I just feel that caring about anything , demonstrating about anything has to start somewhere and be perceived as useful to those already living at the bottom even in this country
I live in what many would call a rough area. There are some residents who try very hard to maintain a decent life for them and their neighbours. They are fighting a losing battle with sections of society who are threatening ,criminal and are turning their environment (Here . Now.) Into a slum. Supporting the stupid stunts of self publicising people would be far from their minds.
I understand that addressing climate change,world poverty,disease and all the other ills is vital for the world .i know picking up a bit of litter won't save us and that climate change is a very serious issue. But for many people who can't afford to travel on planes, who spend their whole lives poverty right now watching vandals attacking works of art does not convince them of JSO s case. I wonder if the activists themselves think they are going to change anything this way ?

I agree and to be honest, I don’t think those with the least are the people that really need to change. They are the people that will be the worst impacted though.

SodaFountainMountain · 29/09/2024 14:14

theresabluebirdinmyheart · 29/09/2024 14:01

I don’t actually give that much of a toss tbh hun

About climate breakdown or the fact that your argument is illogical?

bergamotorange · 29/09/2024 14:15

NewGreenDuck · 29/09/2024 12:26

And I care about my adult child who has various chronic health issues and has to get to hospital very quickly at times. But I suppose that doesn't matter to some?

An ambulance is far more likely to suffer delays due to traffic, flooding, road repairs or accidents than anything JSO do.

Every day there is gridlock in my town.

Shakeoffyourchains · 29/09/2024 14:25

MiriamMay · 28/09/2024 16:32

I care about the climate.
However, JSO are turning people against the cause. Their actions have achieve absolutely nothing apart from making people less inclined to engage with the issue of climate change.

Anyone with even the most basic understanding of climate change won't be put off by JSO and the type of person who claims to have been turned against it by JSO was never with it in the first place.

Tbh the latter type of person is irrelevant, they'll be dragged along by policy changes or the direct impacts of climare change whether they like it or not.

Toiletbrushdisaster · 29/09/2024 14:33

SodaFountainMountain · 29/09/2024 13:42

China are protecting themselves by investing heavily in green renewable power. As should we. If we stopped buying unnecessary crap, China’s emissions would reduce. We need our own legislation and policy that looks after our own interests. So of course the protests are here. I mean, regardless of the rights or wrongs of what they do, you can see how illogical your argument is can’t you?

Yes ,yes,yes to the stop buying ( and dumping and discarding ) unnecessary crap ! Has the wastage of our resources ,the destruction of our natural world ,the lack of care for the less fortunate,the lack of respect for those who are " different" ,the lookism,the ageism and most other ISMS, the grab ,grab grab I'm alright Jack attitude, the shallow focus an appearance and photo opportunities risen with the use of social media, advertising and so- called influencers.? Ignore me ,I'm probably just grumpy as I was woken by a fight outside in the early hours . Like many others ,I do my bit but at a loss to know how to make a difference . Just think that vandalism wont change minds . Sorry about your child's health NewGreenDuck . Must be a constant worry

DdraigGoch · 29/09/2024 14:36

ChocolateLemons · 28/09/2024 17:03

Our children and grandchildren's generation will appreciate their attempts (and many already do!) and will wonder why their futures matter so little to you.
I'm wondering if now.
Tell me why you don't care if they don't 'figure it out'? Genuinely keen to understand. Would something change your mind - what do you think just stop oil do should do?

What should they do? Impound the superyachts of Russian oligarchs. Those things emit more than small countries (and their owners are implicated in Putin's war which must have emitted nearly a billion tonnes by now).

Chaining themselves to some private jets wouldn't go amiss either, rather than hitting ordinary people.

cookiebee · 29/09/2024 14:50

So we are all pretty much stuck on a treadmill, we have to go to work, drive, get transportation, go to hospital, have heating on etc. Here we all are, bickering with each other on our phones and laptops, with our heating on, cars parked outside, and most of us have to get up tomorrow and live life to pay our bills and stay alive. We don’t have time or the sick/holiday pay packages to go and protest, I imagine everyone who is actively able to help climate change doesn’t use technology, so won’t be here commenting.

So to all those who are shouting at us lot who are pissed of with these public school tossers interrupting our lives that we are trapped in, what EXACTLY DO YOU WANT US TO DO ABOUT CLIMATE CHANGE? I’ve seen no suggestions, and I’ve got work tomorrow because there is no option for me and others to do anything differently!

SodaFountainMountain · 29/09/2024 14:51

cookiebee · 29/09/2024 14:50

So we are all pretty much stuck on a treadmill, we have to go to work, drive, get transportation, go to hospital, have heating on etc. Here we all are, bickering with each other on our phones and laptops, with our heating on, cars parked outside, and most of us have to get up tomorrow and live life to pay our bills and stay alive. We don’t have time or the sick/holiday pay packages to go and protest, I imagine everyone who is actively able to help climate change doesn’t use technology, so won’t be here commenting.

So to all those who are shouting at us lot who are pissed of with these public school tossers interrupting our lives that we are trapped in, what EXACTLY DO YOU WANT US TO DO ABOUT CLIMATE CHANGE? I’ve seen no suggestions, and I’ve got work tomorrow because there is no option for me and others to do anything differently!

https://www.imperial.ac.uk/stories/climate-action/

9 things you can do about climate change

With so many experts on climate change here at Imperial, many people ask us what they personally can do about it?

https://www.imperial.ac.uk/stories/climate-action

Lentilweaver · 29/09/2024 14:52

cookiebee · 29/09/2024 14:50

So we are all pretty much stuck on a treadmill, we have to go to work, drive, get transportation, go to hospital, have heating on etc. Here we all are, bickering with each other on our phones and laptops, with our heating on, cars parked outside, and most of us have to get up tomorrow and live life to pay our bills and stay alive. We don’t have time or the sick/holiday pay packages to go and protest, I imagine everyone who is actively able to help climate change doesn’t use technology, so won’t be here commenting.

So to all those who are shouting at us lot who are pissed of with these public school tossers interrupting our lives that we are trapped in, what EXACTLY DO YOU WANT US TO DO ABOUT CLIMATE CHANGE? I’ve seen no suggestions, and I’ve got work tomorrow because there is no option for me and others to do anything differently!

I don't have to drive so I don't.
I don't have to eat meat so I don't.
I buy very few clothes.

This is what I do differently.

SodaFountainMountain · 29/09/2024 14:53

DdraigGoch · 29/09/2024 14:36

What should they do? Impound the superyachts of Russian oligarchs. Those things emit more than small countries (and their owners are implicated in Putin's war which must have emitted nearly a billion tonnes by now).

Chaining themselves to some private jets wouldn't go amiss either, rather than hitting ordinary people.

I am not commenting on the rights or wrongs of JSOs actions but surely you can see that they don’t have the ability or authority to impound a yacht? And getting close to an aircraft should be impossible for obvious reasons.

Whatever you think of their actions, you must be able to see that your ideas are daft?

grumpypedestrian · 29/09/2024 15:06

I’m waiting for the ‘but my child can’t get to a hospital’ people to explain why it’s ok for their future relatives to not be able to access hospitals due to climate change.

What will you do when roads are unusable due to flooding now and you need to get to hospital?

I don’t support JSO but it’s wrong to say they’re the ones who are causing the most damage and inconvenience.

Perhaps if politicians made long term plans it could help, but to just say ‘future generations’ will sort it out is disgusting.

PinkyFlamingo · 29/09/2024 15:16

StolenChanel · 28/09/2024 16:31

I’ll admit I don’t really understand those who are so opposed to their methods. Protests aren’t meant to be neat or convenient. Surely their long-term goals are more important than the material things they ruin on the way?

You mean like stopping people getting to hospital?

thepariscrimefiles · 29/09/2024 15:18

NewGreenDuck · 29/09/2024 12:26

And I care about my adult child who has various chronic health issues and has to get to hospital very quickly at times. But I suppose that doesn't matter to some?

How often has your adult child been prevented from getting to hospital quickly by Just Stop Oil? Are the road blockages always in your area and so frequent that they post an imminent and constant danger to your child?

I think the over-burdened NHS and ambulance service probably pose a great risk.