Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Do some mums just not like working?

1000 replies

Dragontooth · 10/09/2024 21:03

I know this sounds awful, and judgey but I'm trying to understand. I am not a benefit basher and I used to be on benefits, also a single parent.
I'm on a lot of 'being skint' forums, I was on UC but now I have quite a lot of experience in various things so I like to try to help.
There are a number of mums who were previously on legacy benefits who are terrified by UC and the work search appointments. Lots who are unemployed and some who do very part time jobs, 10 hours or less.
I don't understand why they are so resistant to finding work or better paid work. Having been on benefits, it is a horrible existence. I was paid £850 per month. Clearly it would only take a MW part time job to make me so much better off. And they pay for childcare/ holiday club.
It literally changes your life. You can pay for things to have a better, easier life like driving lessons. Not only that but you are back in the work place so it's not such a shock when your children leave home.
I feel these women are so anxious, they can't see how their lives could look with more money/ options. Not only that but a lot of them have their heads in the sand about retirement, will we even get a state pension? Then there's the fact that it's so much harder getting back into employment after five or ten years out, I think that's what UC wants to avoid. I'm not saying it's a kind or person centred system but in reality is taking years out of the workplace really in these women's best interests either?
Disability/ disabled children obviously excluded.

OP posts:
BettiG · 11/09/2024 06:23

It doesn’t matter what anyone thinks about mums who don’t work, everyone has a choice to work or not to work who has the right to have a say on anyone else’s business. Nobody knows what is going on in anyone else’s life.

IVFmumoftwo · 11/09/2024 06:24

WhiteLily1 · 11/09/2024 00:52

Don’t claim any benefits. Made sure I wanted to have kids with a very stable partner and enough money / house first before having any kids. No family handouts either.

Sounds like you have just had good luck.

JudithOx · 11/09/2024 06:25

hollylou · 10/09/2024 21:49

I'm a nurse in a GP practice, I often have requests for sick notes for mums with children who just don't feel able to work due to "anxiety and stress" I find it very hard to be sympathetic sometimes as I have a young child and have worked full time from the moment my maternity leave ended. We have no option but to put him into child care before and after school, it's shit and I feel such guilt in the evenings when he asks for me to sit with him just for a 5 minutes but giving up work or reducing hours just isn't an option or justifiable, to be a functional member of society you need to contribute and im sure lots of these mums would be so much better physically and mentally if they found a job.. I pay so much tax and NI a month it breaks my soul looking at my wageslip.

Completely agree with this. Life is much more fulfilling with a job. Too many people using the labels 'anxiety and/or depression' as an excuse not to work.

Perfect28 · 11/09/2024 06:26

Just loving the people here saying motherhood is hard and work is shit, well yeah. Tell us something we don't know 🙃

Most of us crack on anyway.

IVFmumoftwo · 11/09/2024 06:29

blueshoes · 10/09/2024 22:53

Another smoke screen. Convenient to blame big companies who keep people in jobs rather than blame the work shy who avoid whatever job is offered to take free money from the government instead.

It is a different issue.

What about the ones who don't give you shifts? Are they nice?

heinzseight · 11/09/2024 06:32

This thread is both depressing and (I think) unintentionally hilarious - Air bnb lady and white lily especially. I choose not to work because I have a lot of assets and cash - wouldn't we all!

Tumbleweed101 · 11/09/2024 06:33

I think it’s a money vs time thing. If you work you have more money, if you don’t you have the time to care for your family and yourself in a far more relaxed way.

I’m a single mum, when mine were little I worked term time hours. I lived on less money but it was far less stressful as I had time at home when it was needed. Although mine are older now I find working full time a lot more stressful because I am time poor.

60andraring · 11/09/2024 06:36

My worry if I didn't work (60s here) is the impact on financial security in old age. Many might think not paying very much into an occupational pension won't matter as they can rely on their partner's salary (but couples can separate, trust me) or state pension (looking very unlikely).

heinzseight · 11/09/2024 06:48

heinzseight · 11/09/2024 06:32

This thread is both depressing and (I think) unintentionally hilarious - Air bnb lady and white lily especially. I choose not to work because I have a lot of assets and cash - wouldn't we all!

To quote myself - I don't mean I have lots of assets and cash, I was paraphrasing the other posters (before I get jumped on!) sadly I have no choice but to work 40 hours a week to pay for, you know, the stuff we live on and live in.

liveforsummer · 11/09/2024 07:00

Tbf I was better off on benefits. It's not just the income payment but all the things that go with it such as uniform grants holiday food payments, free school meals, council tax and housing benefit (legacy obviously for the latter) glasses, dentist no commuting costs the list goes on. I've now been working 2 jobs for several years, I'm exhausted and skint. I can see the attraction tbh

liveforsummer · 11/09/2024 07:01

liveforsummer · 11/09/2024 07:00

Tbf I was better off on benefits. It's not just the income payment but all the things that go with it such as uniform grants holiday food payments, free school meals, council tax and housing benefit (legacy obviously for the latter) glasses, dentist no commuting costs the list goes on. I've now been working 2 jobs for several years, I'm exhausted and skint. I can see the attraction tbh

Oh and i didn't even mention childcare costs

Willyoujustbequiet · 11/09/2024 07:05

Gummybear23 · 10/09/2024 21:19

Work is a necessity.
Not working is a luxury.😊
X

Edited

No it's really not.

Some people have no choice.

Beezknees · 11/09/2024 07:09

liveforsummer · 11/09/2024 07:00

Tbf I was better off on benefits. It's not just the income payment but all the things that go with it such as uniform grants holiday food payments, free school meals, council tax and housing benefit (legacy obviously for the latter) glasses, dentist no commuting costs the list goes on. I've now been working 2 jobs for several years, I'm exhausted and skint. I can see the attraction tbh

I definitely wasn't. I'm nearly £1000 better off per month working.

Beezknees · 11/09/2024 07:10

theresabluebirdinmyheart · 11/09/2024 05:05

Yes exactly, if you have few or no school qualifications, the only jobs realistically on offer to you are care or support work… if you have your own children with ASD, why go and be a support worker for someone else with that condition when you are needed by a loved one with the same issues?
Many, indeed most, care or support type jobs involve working with people with challenging behaviour, not everyone can handle the risk of being hit or attacked or spat on as just a daily part of the job. Most of the smug, university educated, “I work from home so why can’t everyone else?” would not last two minutes in these sort of roles.

Not true, I have no qualifications and I wfh 3 days a week, customer services job.

Notmynamerightnow · 11/09/2024 07:10

ZanyPombear · 11/09/2024 01:16

@Fleeceyhat are you not worried about having your children removed by social services?

What on earth?!
Do you feel better about yourself for typing that?

Gummybear23 · 11/09/2024 07:11

Willyoujustbequiet · 11/09/2024 07:05

No it's really not.

Some people have no choice.

As I said, work is a necessity
not having to work is luxury.

JustMarriedBecca · 11/09/2024 07:11

Lifeofthepartay · 10/09/2024 21:29

But that is if you are on universal credit right? If you were working more hours = making more money = no UC = no childcare paid for! It's idiotic

I completely agree. That's my point.

But it doesn't explain people who are on UC using childcare as an excuse.

Beezknees · 11/09/2024 07:13

Ohhbaby · 11/09/2024 06:07

The world would still function if just one gender worked?? Ie only men or only women(although this would be impossible)
There were many years in history where it was almost exclusively men that worked outside the home. So no I don't think mums not working for a period of time causes problems in the greater scheme of the world. Quite the contrary actually

Working class women have ALWAYS worked. It's simply not true that most women stayed at home in the past, that has always been a luxury for those who could afford it.

IVFmumoftwo · 11/09/2024 07:14

JustMarriedBecca · 11/09/2024 07:11

I completely agree. That's my point.

But it doesn't explain people who are on UC using childcare as an excuse.

Who says it is an excuse? The lack of availability is a real issue.

JustMarriedBecca · 11/09/2024 07:15

Mama2many73 · 10/09/2024 22:25

None of the schools around here offer that level of wrap around care. most are 8am til 5.30. One of the schools don't have their own care but a private company work from there (costs more than school based care)

8am to 5.30pm is still adequate for a working week if you work 4.5 days spread over 5 or condense your hours to work only 30 minute break times.

I have a 12 hour a day job and between my husband and I, we use before and after school club. I pick up and then work from home.

I just get bored of people saying because there isn't an absolutely perfect solution provided by the Government or a subsidised private contractor that they won't use it. Life isn't perfect but we make do with what we have and try and change the offering.

Beezknees · 11/09/2024 07:19

JustMarriedBecca · 11/09/2024 07:15

8am to 5.30pm is still adequate for a working week if you work 4.5 days spread over 5 or condense your hours to work only 30 minute break times.

I have a 12 hour a day job and between my husband and I, we use before and after school club. I pick up and then work from home.

I just get bored of people saying because there isn't an absolutely perfect solution provided by the Government or a subsidised private contractor that they won't use it. Life isn't perfect but we make do with what we have and try and change the offering.

I get what you are saying but a few key things - you have a husband (not everyone does) you can wfh (not everyone can) and not all jobs offer perfect condensed hours. There definitely are barriers. I'm a lone parent and I've been extremely lucky to find flexible work, when DS was younger I had simply nobody to help, I don't own a car either so had to walk and use public transport to work.

Willyoujustbequiet · 11/09/2024 07:20

Gummybear23 · 11/09/2024 07:11

As I said, work is a necessity
not having to work is luxury.

Repeating it doesn't make it true.

For some of us not working is the opposite of a luxury and being able to work is a privilege.

RosesAndHellebores · 11/09/2024 07:21

mathanxiety · 10/09/2024 23:54

Of course none of these people are busy during their "time off" taking care of older parents or supporting children because it will be years before their children get an appointment with a mental health HCP, or an appointment tondisgnose learning disabilities, and their elderly parents have nobody else to help them with grocery shopping, showering, cleaning their homes, or doing their laundry.

Of course none of them are burned out and unsupported at work, dealing day or night with awful people, sucking up abuse from students or patients, or heading home to face into hours of marking or planning.

The ones I know of certainly aren't, no.

IVFmumoftwo · 11/09/2024 07:21

JustMarriedBecca · 11/09/2024 07:15

8am to 5.30pm is still adequate for a working week if you work 4.5 days spread over 5 or condense your hours to work only 30 minute break times.

I have a 12 hour a day job and between my husband and I, we use before and after school club. I pick up and then work from home.

I just get bored of people saying because there isn't an absolutely perfect solution provided by the Government or a subsidised private contractor that they won't use it. Life isn't perfect but we make do with what we have and try and change the offering.

My child's school only has a breakfast club (before you say why did I choose that school. It was the best in the area) and no proper after-school care. Just 45 minutes clubs. One nursery does offer it but there is a big waiting list. Before you dismiss other people's reasons consider that many areas don't have the provision that yours does.

IdgieThreadgoodeIsMyHeroine · 11/09/2024 07:22

It's definitely not just mums. My childless brother hasn't worked for seven years.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.