Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be in love with my adoptive brother?

478 replies

orangesandlemonssaythebellsofstclements · 05/09/2024 13:33

Sorry for the clickbait title - this is actually just a fun thread.

Take the plot of a book and turn it into a AIBU

I'll start.

AIBU to want to marry my adoptive brother that my dad found somewhere and instead of just doing it, acting like a total bitch to him and everyone else even after I'd died?

OP posts:
Notamum12345577 · 08/09/2024 22:08

LettyToretto · 05/09/2024 13:35

Hi Cathy!

Gonna go run around the world with a ring that corrupts everyone who touches it when, actually, a simple solution would be to let a mouse wear it and then carry the mouse

You have been reading fan ideas on Facebook about Lord of the Rings! 😁

AmiablePedant · 09/09/2024 00:48

I really hate my mum for having decided what name to give me by asking a bunch of strangers on Mumsnet to say which name was better between Fred and an unwieldy Biblical name that people often mis-spell, They told her to choose the unwieldy one and all my peer group laugh at it. Would I be unreasonable to run away from home and sign up to serve on a whaling ship?

Grimgrump · 09/09/2024 01:07

DramaLlamaBangBang · 06/09/2024 08:43

Also, make sure he keeps away from your little sister!

Oh I’ve met her little sister; don’t worry, she’s more than capable of looking out for herself!

viques · 09/09/2024 03:02

AmiablePedant · 09/09/2024 00:48

I really hate my mum for having decided what name to give me by asking a bunch of strangers on Mumsnet to say which name was better between Fred and an unwieldy Biblical name that people often mis-spell, They told her to choose the unwieldy one and all my peer group laugh at it. Would I be unreasonable to run away from home and sign up to serve on a whaling ship?

You do that Ishmael, I think you will quickly rise to great heights. Just try to keep a balance between hunting for whales and hunting for revenge……

Miffylou · 09/09/2024 10:51

AmiablePedant · 09/09/2024 00:48

I really hate my mum for having decided what name to give me by asking a bunch of strangers on Mumsnet to say which name was better between Fred and an unwieldy Biblical name that people often mis-spell, They told her to choose the unwieldy one and all my peer group laugh at it. Would I be unreasonable to run away from home and sign up to serve on a whaling ship?

Go for it. I’ve heard they do good coffee.

Miffylou · 09/09/2024 10:54

Beansandneedles · 08/09/2024 20:58

Bloody great book!

What is it? (Always looking for recommendations.)

Meditationgame · 09/09/2024 10:59

Miffylou · 09/09/2024 10:54

What is it? (Always looking for recommendations.)

The unlikely pilgrimage of Harold Fry by Rachel Joyce. It's also a film.

Miffylou · 09/09/2024 11:01

Meditationgame · 09/09/2024 10:59

The unlikely pilgrimage of Harold Fry by Rachel Joyce. It's also a film.

Thanks. I’m an idiot - already read it but didn’t recognise it!

ClockwiseHoneysuckle · 09/09/2024 11:07

Snoopsteandcooper · 06/09/2024 18:38

AIBU to think my husband’s boss is a miserable old git?

So, it’s Christmas Eve, and my DH's boss, Mr. S, is the absolute worst. He’s been underpaying DH for YEARS, making us all scrimp and save while he hoards his money and sits alone in his cold, creepy house. DH is working all hours, we can barely afford a decent Christmas dinner, and our youngest DS is sick, but does boss care? No!

Anyway, DH comes home today and tells me Mr S has reluctantly let him have Christmas Day off – surely this should be a given?! I'm concerned that DH is being exploited?

Any advice welcome!

I'd give it a bit of time, you never know, the boss might have a total change of heart and decide to give you a full Christmas dinner.

ClockwiseHoneysuckle · 09/09/2024 11:10

IthinkIsawahairbrushbackthere · 06/09/2024 18:32

AIBU to send DD (8) to boarding school in Europe while my husband and I travel to India and the colonies. Although she only speaks English at the moment she will be expected to learn German and French as lessons will be taught in those subjects. The school is run by a lovely lady and her daughter is one of the pupils.

We may not get to see her until the end of next year but the school seems to specialise in girls whose parents work abroad so would take care of her through Christmas and all the holidays.

Go for it. If your DD runs away and catches some near-fatal illness, the proprietor's sister will sing to her and make her better. In later life your DD will no doubt marry a doctor and have hordes of children and send her daughters to the same school.

Beansandneedles · 09/09/2024 11:21

Miffylou · 09/09/2024 11:01

Thanks. I’m an idiot - already read it but didn’t recognise it!

Not an idiot at all! Been a great thread for reading inspiration though :D

Miffylou · 09/09/2024 11:24

ClockwiseHoneysuckle · 09/09/2024 11:10

Go for it. If your DD runs away and catches some near-fatal illness, the proprietor's sister will sing to her and make her better. In later life your DD will no doubt marry a doctor and have hordes of children and send her daughters to the same school.

I always thought the adult Jo was an unpleasant goody-goody.

MidYearDiary · 09/09/2024 11:25

ClockwiseHoneysuckle · 09/09/2024 11:10

Go for it. If your DD runs away and catches some near-fatal illness, the proprietor's sister will sing to her and make her better. In later life your DD will no doubt marry a doctor and have hordes of children and send her daughters to the same school.

Totally go for it. Despite crowding together in very cold conditions a whole bunch of girls who are only in the vicinity because they're a close family member of someone who has TB, and/or at risk of developing it themselves, magically no one at the CS (or the 'delicate girls' Annexe) ever actually gets TB, despite continually running away/falling into lakes etc. Presumably because that would make Dr Jem, Jack and the rest of the heroic team, look fallible, when what they should be doing is marrying CS old girls right left and centre.

MidYearDiary · 09/09/2024 11:27

Miffylou · 09/09/2024 11:24

I always thought the adult Jo was an unpleasant goody-goody.

She became absolutely dreadful. Disappointingly, no 'difficult' girl ever arrived at the Swiss CS said 'No, I don't want to go to tea with that swivel-eyed loon with the earphones, and I'm more into HP Lovecraft than school stories, thanks. And I'm fine with my hair and name just as they are.'

Miffylou · 09/09/2024 11:30

MidYearDiary · 09/09/2024 11:27

She became absolutely dreadful. Disappointingly, no 'difficult' girl ever arrived at the Swiss CS said 'No, I don't want to go to tea with that swivel-eyed loon with the earphones, and I'm more into HP Lovecraft than school stories, thanks. And I'm fine with my hair and name just as they are.'

Quite! (And I was always uneasy that saying a prayer would apparently always result in the desired outcome.)

MidYearDiary · 09/09/2024 11:34

Miffylou · 09/09/2024 11:30

Quite! (And I was always uneasy that saying a prayer would apparently always result in the desired outcome.)

Clearly there were a lot of CS girls kneeling in their cubicles sending up 'Send me a doctor who will impregnate me annually and drug me in a lordly way if I'm ever mildly upset about something, like falling into a packing case!' prayers.

ClockwiseHoneysuckle · 09/09/2024 11:39

Talking of schools -

I have six daughters and two sons. My DH is in the navy and away a lot of the time, oldest son is also in the navy, oldest daughter gave up her place at Oxford to marry an academic. We live on a farm my DH inherited and which second DD runs. All the girls have been to the same boarding school, youngest DS is also in a boarding school. I am a SAHM but spend a lot of time riding, and of course we have staff to help with the house.

The problem is that money is getting a bit tight and it would really help to lose at least one batch of school fees. Third and fourth DDs are working for GCSEs and A levels, fifth and sixth DDs are twins. Youngest twin is an aspiring actor and a bit ditsy so probably needs to stay where she is, plus I don't think I could cope with the tantrums if I made her leave. Older twin is more sensible and would make less of a fuss about it, but it seems a bit mean to use that as an reason for picking her to be the one to leave. WIBU to go for older twin anyway as the least troublesome option?

MargaretThursday · 09/09/2024 13:01

ClockwiseHoneysuckle · 09/09/2024 11:39

Talking of schools -

I have six daughters and two sons. My DH is in the navy and away a lot of the time, oldest son is also in the navy, oldest daughter gave up her place at Oxford to marry an academic. We live on a farm my DH inherited and which second DD runs. All the girls have been to the same boarding school, youngest DS is also in a boarding school. I am a SAHM but spend a lot of time riding, and of course we have staff to help with the house.

The problem is that money is getting a bit tight and it would really help to lose at least one batch of school fees. Third and fourth DDs are working for GCSEs and A levels, fifth and sixth DDs are twins. Youngest twin is an aspiring actor and a bit ditsy so probably needs to stay where she is, plus I don't think I could cope with the tantrums if I made her leave. Older twin is more sensible and would make less of a fuss about it, but it seems a bit mean to use that as an reason for picking her to be the one to leave. WIBU to go for older twin anyway as the least troublesome option?

Very mean. Let Nicola stay where she is with friends. She's always giving way to Lawrie for an easy life, so this time stand up for her.

Devilsadvocat · 09/09/2024 13:34

So I live in a big house and every night my DH goes out the electricity plays up and I hear noises in the roof. Also I put things away and when I go to get them they have disappeared. My Dh thinks I need a doctor. AIbu to think Im going mad.

AmiablePedant · 09/09/2024 14:08

Devilsadvocat · 09/09/2024 13:34

So I live in a big house and every night my DH goes out the electricity plays up and I hear noises in the roof. Also I put things away and when I go to get them they have disappeared. My Dh thinks I need a doctor. AIbu to think Im going mad.

Well, if you hadn't mentioned electricity I would definitely think you were being gaslighted!

HectorPlasm · 09/09/2024 16:04

"Send me a doctor who will impregnate me annually"

I need to get new glasses!

aliasname · 09/09/2024 18:10

I have a kid sister, who is, like SO annoying, she’s always telling lies but for some reason everyone thinks it’s cute. Like, for example, she does that thing where she pretends the cat is talking “oh Dinah says we didn’t give her any milk!” Plus I’m always having to babysit her, like, I’ve got better things to do than listen to her fairy tales?

I was reading, studying actually, I do have homework to do, and she fell asleep next to me and started snoring lol, I was like WTF and then threw some leaves at her. The brat then complains about me, but I was only like trying to shut up her snoring!

TBH she just thinks she’s so special, like we have an old family friend who comes to ‘play’ with us (what a creep, he’s got to be at least 50) and she’s always like sucking up to him and stuff. WIBU to push her in the river next time he takes us punting (not a euphemism) ?

viques · 09/09/2024 18:52

aliasname · 09/09/2024 18:10

I have a kid sister, who is, like SO annoying, she’s always telling lies but for some reason everyone thinks it’s cute. Like, for example, she does that thing where she pretends the cat is talking “oh Dinah says we didn’t give her any milk!” Plus I’m always having to babysit her, like, I’ve got better things to do than listen to her fairy tales?

I was reading, studying actually, I do have homework to do, and she fell asleep next to me and started snoring lol, I was like WTF and then threw some leaves at her. The brat then complains about me, but I was only like trying to shut up her snoring!

TBH she just thinks she’s so special, like we have an old family friend who comes to ‘play’ with us (what a creep, he’s got to be at least 50) and she’s always like sucking up to him and stuff. WIBU to push her in the river next time he takes us punting (not a euphemism) ?

I think that would be mean Alice, if I were you I would go off for a little walk to cool down, watch your step though , the rabbits round here dig huge holes and if you don’t look where you are going you might……. Alice? Alice, where are you? A………lice!

Sorry Mr D, I can’t find her, she was here a minute ago. A photograph? Of me! Oh yes please. How very exciting

GetBackInYourBox · 10/09/2024 23:19

InsolentNoise · 06/09/2024 20:46

My DD has a hare lip. She’s a pretty girl, apart from that. I keep meaning to get it fixed but something always seems to get in the way of it.
Well, we have no health insurance so I’m not sure what I’m supposed to pay for it with?
A sack of turnips?
Chance would be a fine thing.
In the meantime, I suppose she could just put her hand over her mouth? No one will notice, will they?

I would move heaven and earth to fix this for my girl, how cn you say she's pretty apart from that 🙄 Be a parent.

ClockwiseHoneysuckle · 10/09/2024 23:38

MargaretThursday · 09/09/2024 13:01

Very mean. Let Nicola stay where she is with friends. She's always giving way to Lawrie for an easy life, so this time stand up for her.

In my RL persona I've always wondered about the Marlow finances, given that they had this financial crisis at the point when they had on a mere five children in boarding schools and it's not that long since they had seven. They must really have been very well off given that, at today's prices, fees for seven children would have come to around £80-100K a term.