Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think these riots are about anti-muslim feeling more than immigration....

401 replies

SaltAndVinegar2 · 08/08/2024 00:08

...and to wonder what the rioters actually think the solution is?

I mean there are plenty of Christian immigrants and no-one is attacking churches. Inner city churches are often mostly made up of ethnic minority and immigrant people

Just watched Ed Balls interview with Zarah Sultana.
ZS: "it's important to call out these riots for being islamophobic because mosques and muslims are being targetted"
EB: "do you agree we need to control immigration"
followed by constant interruption and not allowing her to actually say anything. He came across terribly. There have been 8000 complaints about this interview!

https://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/tv/news/ed-balls-gmb-zarah-sultana-riots-b2591311.html

These rioters want to get rid of muslims whether British or immigrant - that is the unpalatable truth. It's not about immigrants in general at all, and only partly about the ones in the hotels. It's scarily reminiscent of what I've read about the early days of the 1930s in germany before Hitler came to power.

GMB viewers criticise Ed Balls for ‘callous’ Zarah Sultana interview

Balls has been branded ‘incredibly patronising’ for his ‘reckless’ interview method

https://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/tv/news/ed-balls-gmb-zarah-sultana-riots-b2591311.html

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Buddysbunda · 08/08/2024 11:05

Kendodd · 08/08/2024 11:00

Is Huw Edwards even a Christian? Or are you just making that assumption because he's white?

He is a regular church goer and described as 'devoted to his faith'.

idontwannabeanythingotherthanwhativebeentrynabe · 08/08/2024 11:05

mids2019 · 08/08/2024 10:48

@idontwannabeanythingotherthanwhativebeentrynabe

In France there are bans on hijab in certain forums such as schools as part of the French constitutional element of separation of church and state. I think people living in France should respect this and it would in my mind be successful integration i.e. respecting the laws and norms of my body country

I would not expect to go to Iran and wander around in a crop top and shorts, beer in hand munching a bacon sandwich with a LGBT badge. There may be a bit of a response to this failure to observe cultural norms?

And Jewish women who wear wigs or scarfs?
Or Jewish men who wear a kippah?

Are they also not integrated, or respecting laws?

I just personally can’t get behind this, I believe people should be allowed to freely wear what they want.

Midnightalready · 08/08/2024 11:06

Izzymoon · 08/08/2024 09:28

Why would other Muslims feel a responsibility based on how someone else acts who has nothing to do with them other than the fact that they either share the same religion or the same ancestry?
Do you take responsibility for how Tommy Robinson behaves because you are both white?
As a white NI catholic I certainly don’t feel any responsibility for how nationalist paramilitaries act, are you saying I should based on some shared, loose religiously based cultural background?
Or is it only Muslims who should feel responsible for the actions of others?

Edited

Surely this thread is an example of many white people taking responsibility for how Tommy Robinson behaves? White people everywhere are calling him out and condemning incitement to violence. Where is the equivalent in other communities?

Kendodd · 08/08/2024 11:06

Drogdab · 08/08/2024 11:01

I’ve got no idea but his religion wasn’t a motive for his actions.

Edited

I agree.

Toooldforthis36 · 08/08/2024 11:08

Muslims, immigrants, non whites, gypsies, travellers. These racist morons don’t really care which group they are directing hate at. As long as someone has told them their unsatisfactory situation in life is entirely down to a group of people they’ve never met, not their own laziness, stupidity or the shitty government they voted for.

I can’t help but think this stems from way way back in our education and welfare system. Allowing a groundswell of crap behaviour and poor performance in schools (and lack of engagement from parents) to be rewarded by an easy ride into existing on benefits rather than having to do the very jobs they now accuse others of ‘stealing’ from them.

This has been on the cards for years, it’s so depressing. And innocent, honest, hard working people are being targeted and made to feel like they don’t belong here because they aren’t the same as these knuckle draggers. It’s despicable.

Thank god for the immigrants who come to this country, encouraging their children to make the most of the education on offer, filling the jobs a lot of people turn their noses up at, and paying taxes whilst doing so. They enrich this country no end.

dottiehens · 08/08/2024 11:09

Izzymoon · 08/08/2024 09:28

Why would other Muslims feel a responsibility based on how someone else acts who has nothing to do with them other than the fact that they either share the same religion or the same ancestry?
Do you take responsibility for how Tommy Robinson behaves because you are both white?
As a white NI catholic I certainly don’t feel any responsibility for how nationalist paramilitaries act, are you saying I should based on some shared, loose religiously based cultural background?
Or is it only Muslims who should feel responsible for the actions of others?

Edited

The same way British people come out to support victims of racism and making sure people know they are not all like Tommy R and followers. You distance yourself and call it out.

Buddysbunda · 08/08/2024 11:10

Kendodd · 08/08/2024 11:06

I agree.

How do you know? If he grew up and lived his life surrounded by and 'devoted' to a church with a culture of child abuse and cover ups why are you so sure this didn't influence him?

RainyWoodland · 08/08/2024 11:11

Buddysbunda · 08/08/2024 11:10

How do you know? If he grew up and lived his life surrounded by and 'devoted' to a church with a culture of child abuse and cover ups why are you so sure this didn't influence him?

Motive is not the same as influence.

Drogdab · 08/08/2024 11:12

Exactly

@Buddysbunda you must have some better arguments?

Anyotherdude · 08/08/2024 11:12

No. I think they are racist through and through but for warped reasons of contorted “justification”, they think that radicalisation and terrorism carried out by a tiny minority of Muslims (even elsewhere) makes it somehow more acceptable to attack Muslims and their Mosques, and in the process, to also attack all people who are brown, regardless of their religion.
Exactly as the first responder to the OP said…

RainyWoodland · 08/08/2024 11:13

Do Hindus and Sikhs have the equivalent of ‘jihad’, ‘fatwas’ or perceiving those who don’t believe as ‘the infidel’?

Buddysbunda · 08/08/2024 11:15

RainyWoodland · 08/08/2024 11:11

Motive is not the same as influence.

So influence is ok? So in the UK being 'influenced' to commit crimes because of the culture of your religion is fine so long as the actual motive is not your religion? Right, the rules sure are complicated!

Kendodd · 08/08/2024 11:16

Drogdab · 08/08/2024 11:04

I also don’t think other newsreaders or BBC workers need to say not in my name re Huw.

Do you really not see the difference between somebody just committing a crime and somebody committing a crime or racist act in the name of Muslims/White people/other groups ? So a white person (for example, could be any) beating some random person up is no different to deliberately seeking out a black person, to beat up, as some sort of fight back on behalf of all white British people?

Jumpingthruhoops · 08/08/2024 11:16

These rioters want to get rid of muslims whether British or immigrant - that is the unpalatable truth.

That's not 'the truth' at all and anyone who thinks it is really hasn't been paying attention.

I'm not aware of anyone who has an issue with any Muslims - or anyone else for that matter - who have chosen to make Britain their home, who want to work, study, do whatever they can to better themselves and contribute to society and, probably most importantly, social cohesion.

However, there's no getting away from the truth - as in the actual truth - that there are groups across the UK who have zero interest in doing this. And the govt's answer to that is... to accept more of it.

THAT is the issue. Yet somehow that's turned into 'People Hate Muslims'. It's BS!

RainyWoodland · 08/08/2024 11:17

Buddysbunda · 08/08/2024 11:15

So influence is ok? So in the UK being 'influenced' to commit crimes because of the culture of your religion is fine so long as the actual motive is not your religion? Right, the rules sure are complicated!

Edited

Influence is a very broad word. People can draw upon an infinite number of influences. Motives, however, tend to be much narrower- one or two.

FiddlyDiddlyDee · 08/08/2024 11:18

dottiehens · 08/08/2024 11:09

The same way British people come out to support victims of racism and making sure people know they are not all like Tommy R and followers. You distance yourself and call it out.

But that's a flawed comparison because British people aren't EDL supporters by definition. You would have to have EDL supporters calling it out for it to be comparable.

By the same token, if I can criticise a supporters of a political philosophy that has a history of extremism and violence who are not extreme or violent, why can't I criticise followers of a religion for the same thing?

Drogdab · 08/08/2024 11:19

@Kendodd Im not sure you meant to reply to my post?

Kendodd · 08/08/2024 11:21

Buddysbunda · 08/08/2024 11:10

How do you know? If he grew up and lived his life surrounded by and 'devoted' to a church with a culture of child abuse and cover ups why are you so sure this didn't influence him?

Ok, I give up.
I don't believe at any point HE has said he abused these children because he is Christian or in the name of Christians everywhere or as a fight against non Christians though.

JoyApple · 08/08/2024 11:22

blackcherryconserve · 08/08/2024 11:04

The rampant antisemitism in the UK and elsewhere began on October 8 immediately after the atrocities committed by Hamas.
There are videos aplenty filmed by the terrorists themselves of their actions and celebrations with Palestinians in Gaza then. I didn't notice any senior Muslim in the UK then condemning their actions nor calling on Hamas to release the remaining hostages. I suppose you think that's ok. Meanwhile Jewish people in the diaspora are vilified constantly about Israel's actions in Gaza.

Edited

The difference is that Muslim leaders in the UK have never supported Hamas.

The chief Rabbi and Jewish board of deputies have always supported Israel including when it has been commiting blatant crimes against civilians, including just a few weeks ago the chief rabbi and Jewish board of deputies requesting a meeting with Starmer because Starmer supported the ICJ ruling of war crimes against Nethanyahu.

You can't have it both ways. If you don't want to associate and be responsible for Israel's actions, stop openly supporting it. If you openly support Israeli government as a leading Jewish organisation in the UK with huge influence, and then remain silent when they commit war crimes, you are culpable.

No imam or Muslim leader in the UK has supported Hamas (they would be arrested anyways even if they did). They have nothing to criticise or apologise for.

mids2019 · 08/08/2024 11:24

@idontwannabeanythingotherthanwhativebeentrynabe

I think it's about respecting rules and laws as well. I. France if it is illegal to wear certain dress in certain circumstances don't you just simply obey the the law?

We had the crazy situation I. France of female women athletes refusing to compete simply because they were asked to not wear a head covering destroying their Olympic dreams.

Other religions seem to have a lot more allowance for flexibility of dress which aligns to the majority. Religious paraphilia is restricted often to significant cultural and religious events.

Drogdab · 08/08/2024 11:24

@Kendodd its not worth engaging in obfuscation.

JoyApple · 08/08/2024 11:26

Jumpingthruhoops · 08/08/2024 11:16

These rioters want to get rid of muslims whether British or immigrant - that is the unpalatable truth.

That's not 'the truth' at all and anyone who thinks it is really hasn't been paying attention.

I'm not aware of anyone who has an issue with any Muslims - or anyone else for that matter - who have chosen to make Britain their home, who want to work, study, do whatever they can to better themselves and contribute to society and, probably most importantly, social cohesion.

However, there's no getting away from the truth - as in the actual truth - that there are groups across the UK who have zero interest in doing this. And the govt's answer to that is... to accept more of it.

THAT is the issue. Yet somehow that's turned into 'People Hate Muslims'. It's BS!

I'm genuinely curious, who exactly are these people you are referring to who are not making it home and not contributing to society? Every single Muslim I know is contributing positively to society.

Auvergne63 · 08/08/2024 11:26

FinalInstructionstotheAudience · 08/08/2024 06:48

Oh please. Look at what has been done over millenia in the name of 'christianity'..
Kidnap of Australia's native people's children to live with 'christian' families
The genocide and subjegation of South American and African people's
The Crusades
The Spanish Inquisition
Explicit and condoned robbery of the poorest by guilting them into giving to the church
'Exorcisms'
Forced conversion to 'christianity' of many
No abortion, no contraception (some christian religions)
You cannot eat meat on Friday
You will go to church
Fundamental 'christianity' treating women as goods, subjegating them
How long have you got?
Christianity, as other religions, is an artificial construct, devised by men, to gaslight women, men and children into controlling and abusive behavious. Women are second-class citizens, despite the new 'women in church' movement

I couldn't have put it better myself.

FiddlyDiddlyDee · 08/08/2024 11:27

JoyApple · 08/08/2024 11:22

The difference is that Muslim leaders in the UK have never supported Hamas.

The chief Rabbi and Jewish board of deputies have always supported Israel including when it has been commiting blatant crimes against civilians, including just a few weeks ago the chief rabbi and Jewish board of deputies requesting a meeting with Starmer because Starmer supported the ICJ ruling of war crimes against Nethanyahu.

You can't have it both ways. If you don't want to associate and be responsible for Israel's actions, stop openly supporting it. If you openly support Israeli government as a leading Jewish organisation in the UK with huge influence, and then remain silent when they commit war crimes, you are culpable.

No imam or Muslim leader in the UK has supported Hamas (they would be arrested anyways even if they did). They have nothing to criticise or apologise for.

Edited

https://www.royalgreenwich.gov.uk/news/2023/statement-response-comments-made-imam-muhammad-abdullah-shakir

Statement in response to comments made by Imam Muhammad Abdullah Shakir.

A statement from the Leader of the Council Cllr Anthony Okereke and the Leader of the Opposition Cllr Matt Hartley in response to the comments made by Imam Muhammad Abdullah Shakir.“The Royal Borough of Greenwich stands together with sadness and disgus...

https://www.royalgreenwich.gov.uk/news/2023/statement-response-comments-made-imam-muhammad-abdullah-shakir

dottiehens · 08/08/2024 11:27

FiddlyDiddlyDee · 08/08/2024 11:18

But that's a flawed comparison because British people aren't EDL supporters by definition. You would have to have EDL supporters calling it out for it to be comparable.

By the same token, if I can criticise a supporters of a political philosophy that has a history of extremism and violence who are not extreme or violent, why can't I criticise followers of a religion for the same thing?

Edited

Just to clarify. Muslims should call out when atrocities are committed using their religion as a cover and distance themselves to show they are not all the same. In this country they are free to do that.