Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Telling off someone else’s child

124 replies

Drummend01 · 31/07/2024 21:50

So this week I have been camping with my boyfriend and his family which includes his brother, SIL and their children. One particular child is known for being quite impulsive and a poor listener. They are 9. The mum, dad, nan, uncles have all made comments about the child’s poor behaviour during the trip.

I lent their family multiple camping items which included a blow up bed that belongs to my parents. The child had been told at the start the beds are for sleeping only, they can pop etc. He was warned by his dad again the following day as he was doing rolly pollys on it. On the third day I watched the child do a big jump on the bed (he was sleeping in a bedroom of our tent) and I said “please don’t jump, you’ve been told already it will pop. If you break it then you can give my parents the money to replace it”

Did not raise my voice, was not being sneaky and hushing my tone, just said it aloud and obviously his parents heard. They did not say anything at the time, dad told the kids to come out of the tents, but SIL was quiet and moody and told my boyfriend later she was annoyed at me and that I shouldn’t tell other peoples children off. Boyfriends mum told her she was being unreasonable and she declared that I could not speak directly to her kids anymore and if I wanted to ask them something I ask her first.

The rest of the camping was a bit awkward, she never said anything directly to me and I considered apologising but boyfriend said it would cause further arguing. They mostly did their own thing from then on.

I feel bad that I’ve caused a rift in the family but I also feel strongly that children should respect things, especially when they belong to someone else. Was I in the right to say something? Or did I overstep?

OP posts:
Whynottrythis · 06/08/2024 20:20

Sounds reasonable to me.
I have told other children off before.
I have also had other people tell off my child before. The way I feel about it really depends on the exact situation and the person - sometimes I have been fully supportive of the other adult, and other times it's really annoyed me.

AllyArty · 06/08/2024 20:24

Reprimanding someone else’s child is always a fine line. Would probably have been best if you had just asked the child to stop in case they hurt themselves or damage the bed and left it there. I kind of see why the child’s mum wasn’t best pleased with the bit about repaying your parents. But overall I think you were right.

cockadoodledandy · 06/08/2024 20:46

YANBU but agree ‘you’ll have to pay my parents’ was a bit much.

However, I do see it a bit weird that you refer to them as ‘their family’ and ‘the child’. Not that this is your own extended family and the child is your nephew.

bakebeans · 06/08/2024 21:04

YANBU.

TessTimoney · 06/08/2024 21:33

Of course children need to learn that naughty behaviour has consequences otherwise there is no good reason for them to stop what they are doing Consequences like; 'If you break that then your parents will need to pay for it. " certainly worked when I was a kid. Obviously the previous" without conseqences" warnings had no affect. You did the right thing and his Mother knows it!

ApplesOrangesBananas · 06/08/2024 22:22

OldChinaJug · 06/08/2024 15:22

Nonsense. Children have more of a concept of money and a direct material consequence than they do of two people they dont know and have never met being 'sad'.

And the child is 9. Not 3.

Edited

It’s about encouraging empathy and not teaching children that they can just throw money at a problem.

jasminocereusbritannicus · 07/08/2024 14:56

You did nothing wrong. People are so strange about other people telling children off.
As a TA, I spend much of the day explaining/ telling children not to do stuff and what the consequence might be… it is very difficult to turn this off in the holidays!!! But, if I see someone doing something dangerous or inconsiderate, I WILL say something. They usually look so shocked that someone has actually told them that they do stop!
I would have had no problem with someone telling one of my three kids off… then they would have got a telling from me as well. Luckily, they were generally well behaved, and thought about others and their surroundings/property.

Mummyto2boyz · 07/08/2024 16:40

I think its good for other people to tell your kids off once in a while. Mine rarely bat an eyelid when I tell them off but if their uncle does they listen. It's not like you're some random strange which would obviously piss anyone off. You're family. I wouldn't worry about it. She'll get over it.

lovenotwar149 · 07/08/2024 16:50

I think you are fine to tell the child not to do that. Possibly better if you had left out If you break it then you can give my parents the money to replace it” as I dont think it is your place to stipulate what the consequences would be as that would be the parents decision. Something more sensitive/tactful like " it cost .... and if it breaks it will need to be replaced, that would be a shame. It would be so lovely if you jumped somewhere else , shall we go and jump somewhere else together?" Thats my approach when I am in your situation...works well. Parents dont then 'feel' like bad parents, and in my experience they usually jump RIGHT in!

lovenotwar149 · 07/08/2024 16:54

Funny story ....
my son , who was 5 at the time was in a car with my brother in law & SIL. He apparently said to my SIL 'why do u have a nose like a witch?' As a 5 yr old ...thats what he saw. My brother in law called me , seemed rather appalled (they dont have kids) that these words came out of my sons mouth. Oh dear!

misskatamari · 07/08/2024 16:56

She’s a fucking idiot! You were completely reasonable and she’s doing her kid no favours behaving like this! The parents should have heard you tell the kid that, and bloody well come and backed you up and reiterated the rules. Absolutely ridiculous behaviour from them

FloatyBoaty · 07/08/2024 16:59

It’s the money thing that’s annoyed her, id guess. Because it would annoy me, and I have absolutely no issue with other people telling off my child if they see something I don’t and it needs correcting.

I’m not sure why it would annoy me, tbh. But it would. The first bit wouldn’t at all. Perhaps I feel like that’s something I would rather was said to me? So by all means, tell my child to quit it- tell me I’m responsible for paying for their breakages (not that I need telling, but you know what I mean).

FTMaz · 07/08/2024 19:27

I probably wouldn’t have said he can give your parents the money he’s 9! Wouldn’t it be great if we only needed to tell kids something once and they got the message. You’re not in the wrong for asking him not to jump on the bed but you probably could have been softer with it.

WorriedMama12 · 08/08/2024 15:06

You did nothing wrong. She's probably thoroughly embarrassed at her shit parenting and rightly so.

WorriedMama12 · 08/08/2024 15:08

lovenotwar149 · 07/08/2024 16:54

Funny story ....
my son , who was 5 at the time was in a car with my brother in law & SIL. He apparently said to my SIL 'why do u have a nose like a witch?' As a 5 yr old ...thats what he saw. My brother in law called me , seemed rather appalled (they dont have kids) that these words came out of my sons mouth. Oh dear!

I have a 5 year old niece and nephew. Both would know that this was rude. I'd be explaining to my own kid that it was rude to comment on people's appearances like that.

lovenotwar149 · 08/08/2024 15:23

Yes I did that of course. But my brother in law didn't appreciate the authentic nature of a young child.

lovenotwar149 · 08/08/2024 15:24

He got highly offended, apparently his wife cried after the comment too. She had a nose job too as her nose was a VERY sensitive issue. My son SAW the nose as clearly something unusual and in his child like way said what he was thinking

lovenotwar149 · 08/08/2024 15:26

I got my son to apologise too but the story still makes me smile ....yrs on

lovenotwar149 · 08/08/2024 15:27

Maybe my brother in law thought the same

Hunglikeapolevaulter · 08/08/2024 15:40

I got my son to apologise too but the story still makes me smile ....yrs on

You smile at the memory of your son reducing a woman to tears over something she was clearly very sensitive about?

BeLoyalCoralHiker · 08/08/2024 15:52

Drummend01 · 31/07/2024 21:50

So this week I have been camping with my boyfriend and his family which includes his brother, SIL and their children. One particular child is known for being quite impulsive and a poor listener. They are 9. The mum, dad, nan, uncles have all made comments about the child’s poor behaviour during the trip.

I lent their family multiple camping items which included a blow up bed that belongs to my parents. The child had been told at the start the beds are for sleeping only, they can pop etc. He was warned by his dad again the following day as he was doing rolly pollys on it. On the third day I watched the child do a big jump on the bed (he was sleeping in a bedroom of our tent) and I said “please don’t jump, you’ve been told already it will pop. If you break it then you can give my parents the money to replace it”

Did not raise my voice, was not being sneaky and hushing my tone, just said it aloud and obviously his parents heard. They did not say anything at the time, dad told the kids to come out of the tents, but SIL was quiet and moody and told my boyfriend later she was annoyed at me and that I shouldn’t tell other peoples children off. Boyfriends mum told her she was being unreasonable and she declared that I could not speak directly to her kids anymore and if I wanted to ask them something I ask her first.

The rest of the camping was a bit awkward, she never said anything directly to me and I considered apologising but boyfriend said it would cause further arguing. They mostly did their own thing from then on.

I feel bad that I’ve caused a rift in the family but I also feel strongly that children should respect things, especially when they belong to someone else. Was I in the right to say something? Or did I overstep?

I wouldn’t lend out something that wasn’t mine, I think it makes you hyper aware and then your comment about paying for it was a bit OTT. I don’t have a problem with people telling my children off but there is a way to do it, and realistically whether you are right or not you have to accept it can cause bad feeling and whether or not it’s worth it to you to take a stand. I’m not saying SIL is right but it’s just one of those things that you have to look at the actuality of, not the “in principle”. SIL probably felt stressed and defensive, and then her MIL sticking the boot in too, and being on your side probably didn’t make her feel great. But I could also be projecting as I have a son with ADHD and often get family judgement from those were not as close to who are not too understanding!

lovenotwar149 · 08/08/2024 16:10

Hunglikeapolevaulter

No I smile at the authenticity of a child

lovenotwar149 · 08/08/2024 16:13

a 5 year old isn't responsible for a grown woman's insecurity about her nose and her emotional state. He acted like a 5 yr old. The parents of the 5 yr old ( me and my husband) explained that was NOT what to say and got him topologies thereafter. He didn't repeat the mistake. He acted like a 5 yr old, b/c he was a 5 yr old

Hunglikeapolevaulter · 08/08/2024 16:35

No I smile at the authenticity of a child

Dotingly, I'm sure,

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread