Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Reasons you wouldn’t move to US

1000 replies

Preiu · 10/07/2024 14:08

Dh has been offered a job in the US. The increase in salary would put us into a completely different wealth bracket but I really don’t want to move.

  • fear of home invasion with guns
  • school shooting - guns in general I guess
  • American exceptionalism attitude annoys me
  • Being away from family
  • Not having Europe on doorstep

Can I ask if you have any other reasons

OP posts:
Thread gallery
36
SerafinasGoose · 12/07/2024 10:05

they like different sports

As far as I'm concerned this can only be a good thing!

OVienna · 12/07/2024 10:59

Every once in a while I think, gosh what if I'd stayed in the US, and just kept working and working and never felt I could have kids because of the horrible maternity leave?

What if I never actually met someone? Never got on with US blokes, not sure why. But I have these Sliding Doors moments with some regularity where I can imagine I'd have stayed single somehow. Living in NYC and never actually meeting someone properly. Dating is hard there. My friends who are married now are actually with people they met a university - I didn't meet anyone!

Thinking of my two lovely DDs and I'm so happy I got on that plane.

DdraigGoch · 12/07/2024 12:43

The political bickering is annoying but you can tune out, and we have plenty of that in the UK too although granted it's not quite as divisive.
@muggart I rather get the feeling that since 175 P45s were handed out last week, we don't seem to have much in the way of political bickering in the UK at the moment. The new PM has made a few decent ministerial appointments and the feeling is that the grown-ups are back in charge.

By contrast, the US appears to be heading for a knife-edge election between an 81 year old who is losing his marbles and a 78 year old who never had any marbles to begin with.

YankSplaining · 12/07/2024 13:11

GogAndMagog · 12/07/2024 06:24

Guns. You can get them from a vending machine is some states.

Polarised society.

Abortion laws.

The food is very processed.

Many American accents grate on my nerves.

Alabama, Oklahoma, and Texas have recently gotten machines where people can buy ammunition. The machines scan someone’s driver’s license and use facial recognition software. I’m not sure how well they work, and I can see a lot of possible pitfalls.

But no, you cannot “buy guns from vending machines” in any state - not to mention the fact that OP isn’t considering moving to any of those states. Can we please stick to actual facts?!

RM2013 · 12/07/2024 13:24

My reasons would be
guns
healthcare
trump
biden
being so far from family and friends

DdraigGoch · 12/07/2024 14:42

YankSplaining · 12/07/2024 13:11

Alabama, Oklahoma, and Texas have recently gotten machines where people can buy ammunition. The machines scan someone’s driver’s license and use facial recognition software. I’m not sure how well they work, and I can see a lot of possible pitfalls.

But no, you cannot “buy guns from vending machines” in any state - not to mention the fact that OP isn’t considering moving to any of those states. Can we please stick to actual facts?!

If they're scanning driving licences then at least there must be some kind of check going on.

Of far more concern is the gun show loophole.

poetryandwine · 12/07/2024 14:58

YankSplaining · 12/07/2024 13:11

Alabama, Oklahoma, and Texas have recently gotten machines where people can buy ammunition. The machines scan someone’s driver’s license and use facial recognition software. I’m not sure how well they work, and I can see a lot of possible pitfalls.

But no, you cannot “buy guns from vending machines” in any state - not to mention the fact that OP isn’t considering moving to any of those states. Can we please stick to actual facts?!

Thank you. I had missed the bald statement from PP that one can buy guns from vending machines in America.

Some of the more bizarre statements on this thread are of the same order as utterances from the mouth of one Donald Trump. And being accepted by those who share the bias.

Yet they look down on Americans because (under half of) Americans accept Trump’s statements because they share his bias, and do not see the irony.

VeryQuaintIrene · 12/07/2024 15:45

To the poster who thinks love of British accents is patronizing - not at all, IMO - I find it charming, really, and it's got me further here than I deserve! Also, with regard to the teeth, you've never been in the South, have you?

CloudywMeatballs · 12/07/2024 15:49

Pandadunks · 11/07/2024 18:23

‘Would it be OK to say that I wouldn't want to go to England because of English people or Japan because of the Japanese, for example? Why is it OK to be so rude towards Americans?’

Except it’s not ‘ I hate Americans’ is it? It’s I don’t like that guns are readily available, I don’t like that the work culture is insane, I don’t like that you have to rely on cars so much etc…
As it happens I probably wouldn’t want to move to Japan, mainly because I don’t speak Japanese and it’s very far to get back to see family. I’m sure Japanese people
are fine…

There have been many posts on this thread (and I have no idea if yours was one of them) which listed "Americans" as a reason not to move to the US.

CloudywMeatballs · 12/07/2024 16:03

This thread continues to throw up blatant and ridiculous lies, which I assume come from people who have never spent much time in the country.

Cakes all come from packets.

Er, no. They don't. Yes, you can buy packaged cake mix, and no doubt there are people who use them. But you can buy delicious baked goods from high quality bakeries, and there are many people who bake cakes and other baked goods from scratch.

As for the poster who would prefer a person to have bad teeth and breath that smells like cheese and onion crisps rather than nice teeth and clean breath, that sounds like a you problem.

poetryandwine · 12/07/2024 16:27

CloudywMeatballs · 12/07/2024 16:03

This thread continues to throw up blatant and ridiculous lies, which I assume come from people who have never spent much time in the country.

Cakes all come from packets.

Er, no. They don't. Yes, you can buy packaged cake mix, and no doubt there are people who use them. But you can buy delicious baked goods from high quality bakeries, and there are many people who bake cakes and other baked goods from scratch.

As for the poster who would prefer a person to have bad teeth and breath that smells like cheese and onion crisps rather than nice teeth and clean breath, that sounds like a you problem.

Yes, I found that post a bit rich in the land of Bird’s. I had not known of the concept of powdered custard - or gravy stuff - until coming to the UK.

I don’t mind that some use Bird’s or the gravy stuff in the least. But this was another tiresome example of people living in glass houses throwing stones

meganorks · 12/07/2024 21:07

meganorks · 11/07/2024 09:07

For me, the whole work culture would stop me moving my family to the US. Workers don't have many rights. They can be sacked pretty easily. Sick leave and pay is virtually non-existent. Dito for maternity. They also have less holiday. I know a few friends who worked there who tried to use 2 weeks holiday in one go and people were shocked and told them they couldn't. (They did as it turned there was nothing in their contract to stop them)
The major worry for me is around healthcare insurance being linked to your job. The whole thing seems geared around 'you work, no matter what'. But what happens if you are too sick to work? Or what if a child is so sick you need to take care of them? I'm sure insurance will cover things initially. But I'm also sure there will be restrictions/limitations or things that aren't covered. Then what?
Also, healthcare being linked to your job makes leaving much more complex. What if you hate your job but have great healthcare? Would you/could you leave?
Then obviously guns
Plus
Shitty food standards
Car culture
Cult-like hero worship of the flag and country
And I wouldn't want my kids pledging allegiance to the flag and doing active shooter drills

So just seen this today. I guess this is the sort of thing I was worried about when I said I hated the idea of medical insurance being linked to your job

Reasons you wouldn’t move to US
YankSplaining · 13/07/2024 00:32

poetryandwine · 12/07/2024 14:58

Thank you. I had missed the bald statement from PP that one can buy guns from vending machines in America.

Some of the more bizarre statements on this thread are of the same order as utterances from the mouth of one Donald Trump. And being accepted by those who share the bias.

Yet they look down on Americans because (under half of) Americans accept Trump’s statements because they share his bias, and do not see the irony.

Being bored at the moment, I’m trying to come up with equally false and ridiculous “reasons” why Americans shouldn’t move to the UK. Like…

”The Church of England is their official state religion, so no one is allowed to have a different one. They think that once someone becomes king or queen, that person magically gets a second birthday. Because of the NHS, you can only see a doctor when the government tells you that you can. There are no dentists. I know Hermione’s parents were dentists in Harry Potter, but those are fantasy novels.

”In Scotland, all of the meat is haggis. It’s named after Paul Haggis, the director, who co-wrote two James Bond movies. Small villages have a particularly high homicide rate; we know this because of Midsomer Murders. And every thirteen hours in Northern Ireland, the IRA blows someone up.”

TrishM80 · 13/07/2024 01:02

The whole gun culture, while I hate it, wouldn't overly concern me as much as the below:

  • Crippling cost of healthcare, especially for serious illnesses;
  • practically non-existent workers' rights;
  • Astronomical college fees;
ForGreyKoala · 13/07/2024 01:38

TrishM80 · 13/07/2024 01:02

The whole gun culture, while I hate it, wouldn't overly concern me as much as the below:

  • Crippling cost of healthcare, especially for serious illnesses;
  • practically non-existent workers' rights;
  • Astronomical college fees;

Oh I know - it's a wonder anyone lives there isn't it?

Poor downtrodden things, going bankrupt from being ill, no-one being able to attend college because it's too expensive, and they must all hate their 24/7 jobs.

Meanwhile, in the real world, all the Americans I know are living their best lives and not spending their time on forums moaning about how hard life is and how the government should do something about it.

Carouselfish · 13/07/2024 01:59

Trump, Biden, Guns
Piss poor maternity leave
Christianity being more of a thing there.
Price of university
The fact that it's just isolated pockets of malls and housing estates and nowhere to really walk unless you live in a city.
No right to roam. Dogs only get walked in dog parks not even allowed off lead in National Parks so unless you have a lot of private land, seems kind of rubbish for them.
Bigger divide between rich and poor so living up against some serious frightening areas of poverty.
Spiders. (sound silly, but Arizona has dinner plate sized ones).
Fresh food being more expensive.

wordler · 13/07/2024 02:10

The college fees are insane - it was a huge eye opener for me when my DSDs went to college.

Even non Ivy, not the famous ones like Harvard, Stanford etc cost $40-50,000 a year! And the courses are 4 years long!

However - a bit like the healthcare service there are several different ways regular people make this work.

  1. Go to a university in your own state (the state university) and get local resident fees - significantly lower. Works if you have a really good state university which is good for whatever you want to study.
  2. Have a parent or stepparent who is employed by a university - often means practically free fees for the university the parent is employed at, but also counts for discounts at other universities - we are talking knocking $10-20K off the bill.
  3. Apply for scholarships - there are tens of thousands available and you can stack them - so with a bit of prep you can shave another 10-15K off or for some people a lot more. Sometimes they even apply the discounts for you without asking.

So you can get it down to fairly managable levels - it just takes a bit of preparation.

There's also a lot more flexibility in how to graduate for most students - they collect credits to graduate so can work harder in the early years and finish earlier which makes it cheaper, and it's easier to switch to a different university without losing your credits - it's a lot more flexible that the UK system.

Carouselfish · 13/07/2024 02:14

Oh and the lack of recycling! Jesus! Nobody has recycling bins. They use polystyrene and plastic one-use cups like it's the latest fashion. Am talking big companies as well as private individuals, big restaurants and small.

wordler · 13/07/2024 02:18

Carouselfish · 13/07/2024 02:14

Oh and the lack of recycling! Jesus! Nobody has recycling bins. They use polystyrene and plastic one-use cups like it's the latest fashion. Am talking big companies as well as private individuals, big restaurants and small.

Lots of US cities have weekly recycling collection with council provided recycling bins. Washington DC is a good example of that.

If you live outside one of the cities that offer this there are still municipal recycling depots where you can take your paper, glass and plastics.

Again the USA is the size of Europe - each state determines law and policy and public health campaigns differently depending on their population etc.

Why do you think you can make a determination about the whole of the USA's recycling habits in one fell swoop?

Can you determine the recycling habits of Finland by looking at what they do in Portugal????

BlueskysandWind · 13/07/2024 02:26

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Carouselfish · 13/07/2024 02:43

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Charming. It's what I've experienced in: TN, MT, FL, SC, NC. In private homes, in restaurants, in tourist attractions.
I'm sure there might be options for doing your own recycling and some liberal East and West coast areas where the gov makes it more of a habit, but there's much more of a cultural and industrial not giving a shit. If we're talking about shit.

candyisdandybutliquorisquicker · 13/07/2024 03:05

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I agree. I'm in the Midwest and we recycle everything- even to the point in casual restaurants or coffee shops the bins are divided up into compost/recycle/landfill and everyone stands there looking a bit stumped figuring out where everything should go 😄

knitnerd90 · 13/07/2024 03:14

Both places I have lived in have recycling and most people I know elsewhere do too, and they don't all live in liberal coastal areas. There are rural areas where you have to take your own trash to the dump and I suppose they might not. Although now that China doesn't want plastics, it's becoming questionable about how worthwhile plastic recycling is. Green bin programs are more variable.

A quick google says 91% of the US population has access to recycling. Actual rates vary with the highest rates being in the Northeast and the West Coast. The best states for recycling are the ones with bottle deposit laws (they charge you 5 or 10¢ per bottle or can when you purchase and then you get it back when you return the empties). Hence, Iowa, which has a bottle bill, is a standout recycler.

wordler · 13/07/2024 03:36

Carouselfish · 13/07/2024 02:43

Charming. It's what I've experienced in: TN, MT, FL, SC, NC. In private homes, in restaurants, in tourist attractions.
I'm sure there might be options for doing your own recycling and some liberal East and West coast areas where the gov makes it more of a habit, but there's much more of a cultural and industrial not giving a shit. If we're talking about shit.

Again it's very state specific - you are talking way too broadly about a country the size of the European continent. Think of each state like a different country in Europe and you'll be more accurate.

Interestingly the states you reference are all some of the lowest recyclers across the whole USA so perhaps that's why you got that impression. The states at the top end of the table actually have higher recycling rates than the UK.

www.oberk.com/packaging-crash-course/states-best-worst-recycling

Appalonia · 13/07/2024 03:46

This thread is bloody hilarious, I've stayed up much too late reading it!😂

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread