Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My mum hates me trying my best to look after my child

154 replies

Tryingtobeagoodmummy · 06/07/2024 19:00

Background. I've a weird realtionship with my mum which, looking back, involved me walking on eggshells and her seeming to think I'm a bit of an idiot.

now im married to my lively DH and we have a 2 year old son. I always wanted to be a mum and try to be the best mother I can be. I don't see my mum very frequently but when I do she literally never has anything nice to say about how I look after my child.

We went to stay with her recently and my son was a bit funny with her as he hasn't seen her in a while. He wouldn't go to her and she started seeming annoyed, pulling faces or making a fake crying noise when he started to get a bit upset if he thought I was leaving the room. I tried to just ignore it as I didn't want an argument and we are leaving soon. She kept saying how I was 'never like that' and was I sure there wasn't something 'wrong with him'? (SEN). As it happens, I have no concerns and neither does his health visitor or his nursery.

I have been making my own little breakfast bars with oats, mashed banana, peanut butter etc etc and she saw them sitting on the side, cooling. I thought it was a good, healthy way to get some fruit and fibre into him. She asked what they were and I explained. She pulled a face and said 'it looks like a pile of crap'. For some reason I froze and felt my eyes fill with tears and I just walked out of the room so she wouldn't see me crying. I felt a bit embarrassed about my little bars.

Ds has been practising nursery rhymes with me and in nursery and can do a really cute version of 'Twinkle Twinkle'. I started singing with him to see if he would do it for my mum. He didnt but was very into his toys at the time. He was very excitable that days and afterwards, i mentioned to mum that he had been quite hyper that evening. She pulled a face and said 'do you know what his problem is? Far too much stimulation. Constantly singing songs and talking to him. Is it any wonder he is wired to the moon?'

She keeps trying to give him chocolate and I'd prefer he just gets a treat after he has had enough fruit and veg for the day. There isn't a ban on treats but I'd rather he had some chopped apple or strawberries first. Part of this is that he is prone to constipation and when I said that she said 'well you can just give him a laxative then'. I explained that I think it's better for a child to get their fibre from real fruit and veg first, and then use a laxative only if that didn't work. She just looked at me like I had ten heads.

I'd also rather he just enjoyed water and didn't get accustomed to squash, partially because I have a weird reaction to the sweeteners in squash and would just rather he preferred water. I decided to let it go and go with the flow a bit more but it's just glass after glass of strong squash. I said can you just give him water and she said 'it's not right to give children water' and she makes a big deal out of how 'yucky' water is ("mean mummy" etc)

Ds started to warm up to her and was making us fake ice creams. I did the whole 'oh yum, vanilla, my favourite etc etc'. He gave her an imaginary ice cream and she said 'am I supposed to pretend to eat this? I don't do that'. Ds didn't notice but I thought it was totally weird and made excuses to go and give him a bath.

I asked him if he wanted to go to the park or stay inside with toys a few days ago, and she said it was clear I never told him no and he had far too much choice (absolutely not true!!!). Then the following day I was very firm with him about something and she said 'didn't mummy use a horrible, mean voice with you'.

She does this thing where she ruffles his hair for longer than necessary and he really doesn't like it. I can see him wincing and pulling his shoulders up. I told her that he doesn't seem to like that and she said 'oh for God's sake, you are far too fussy with him!' I actually don't think I'm too fussy, I can just see that he really dislikes that. My mother in law never annoys me with any way she interacts with my child, in fact she is great and he is much more relaxed around her. So its not me being the impossible to please precious first time mum.

My mum seems to really resent every time I try my best to be a good mum. It seems to really, really bother her. I thought she would be proud of me for being a good mum; strangers have literally come up to me to say things like 'I just saw you with your child and you're so loving towards him, it's lovely to see' etc. Why oh why does it bother her so much? She has form for absolutely going off on one and I want to get through the next few days without a fall out. However my instincts are saying that this isn't normal and I need to rethink our relationship and visiting arrangements for the next time.

I've always has an odd relationship with her but thought that she would see me in a new light when I had kids and not see me like a silly little girl any more, but she seems to absolutely despise me now! I know I need to re evaluate things and to be honest I'm absolutely gutted to finally realise who my mother actually really is.
Wibu to reduce contact further if this continues?

OP posts:
Jinglesomeoftheway · 06/07/2024 20:41

@Tryingtobeagoodmummy You sound like a lovely, lovely mum doing all the right things for your toddler

And she sounds like a nightmare!

She won't change. So you either have to bite the bullet and ignore these comments, or stop seeing her. It's going to really impact your life until you accept you won't get her validation from her on your parenting.

You sound like an amazing mum, and it's a shame you're being made to feel like this.

thecatsthecats · 06/07/2024 20:43

AnnaMagnani · 06/07/2024 20:09

If you can appreciate that your mum had a traumatic childhood that sadly made her not a very good mum you are halfway there.

The next bit is accepting that you love her, despite her not really being able to be the mum you deserve. And when she starts up her criticism just thinking 'mum's off again' rather than taking it all as the truth.

This.

I'm there - my mum had an awful childhood and went from that to an abusive first marriage. She just wasn't capable of great parenting. She looks at my sister and I askance when we're showering our children with love.

But when she makes off comments, I either brush it off with a sassy or neutral reply depending on how I feel, or just think, "that's nice dear" in my head.

(Funnily enough her parenting style is far closer to mine than my MIL's is, but even though my MIL is constantly suggesting things I don't agree with, she's far more affirmative than my mum.)

NadjaofAntipaxos · 06/07/2024 20:43

Would you consider therapy at all? Not for a second because I think there is anything "wrong" with you. You sound like a lovely person and definitely not pathetic! But because I think it could make you happier by supporting you to draw boundaries with your mum. It could help you to work through her treatment of you and how dysfunctional it is and to make peace with her being the issue and that nothing you can do will successfully result in the relationship with her you want and indeed deserve.
It's so easy as outsiders for us all to say "your mum is hideous, cut her out". Brilliant if you can actually do that because she does sound utterly repellent, but you have a lifetime of her to unpick and process. And you are clearly a wonderful mum.

AnnaMagnani · 06/07/2024 20:48

Thanks @thecatsthecats

My DM also had a truly awful childhood. She tried to be a better mum than hers, but she is a very damaged person. When she didn't know any better, this wasn't her choosing to be crap or abusive.

I was lucky enough to have a shitload of therapy and I am sure this is the reason we aren't NC now.

OP you absolutely need some boundaries around your mum. Whether these boundaries are so high you don't see her at all is your choice. But they should involve seeing her less and expecting her to respect you as an adult.

Pocketfullofdogtreats · 06/07/2024 20:50

If you have him squash, she'd want to give him water. She sounds jealous. How pathetic. Yes, limit your time with her and don't let her drag you down or doubt yourself. The comment about the cereal bars was really nasty. (My DS turned into a little devil if he had squash with sweetener. You're not wrong there!)

AngryLikeHades · 06/07/2024 21:02

Your mum is a silly bitch. You're an amazing mum and for whatever reason she is treating you badly.
My thoughts are that she is probably feeling like she sub par in her parenting and she's trying to make herself feel better due to her own failings.
She probably doesn't know she feels this way and the way she is treating you is probably not concious.
However, this doesn't mean for one minute that it is ok behaviour.
I don't know how you would move forward after talking to her.
If she changes and listens to you, then good but it doesn't look as if she would.

Tryingtobeagoodmummy · 06/07/2024 21:06

AnnaMagnani · 06/07/2024 20:48

Thanks @thecatsthecats

My DM also had a truly awful childhood. She tried to be a better mum than hers, but she is a very damaged person. When she didn't know any better, this wasn't her choosing to be crap or abusive.

I was lucky enough to have a shitload of therapy and I am sure this is the reason we aren't NC now.

OP you absolutely need some boundaries around your mum. Whether these boundaries are so high you don't see her at all is your choice. But they should involve seeing her less and expecting her to respect you as an adult.

I agree with you. My mum made a big effort to be a better mother to me than hers was to her but I think the trauma has actually damaged her so much and left her with so many wounds that she isn't operating from a full cup. I think I've always known this. I have a lot of very happy memories of her, and I really do member absolutely adoring my mum and feeling loved and cared for. Things changed as I got older but even then there were hard times when she supported me and held my hand as I cried about something. I remember crying about something and I remember her eyes filling with tears too, as she was so sad for me, and I knew in that moment that she trying to be strong for me. And then there are these moments where she has spoken to me like crap, fallen out with me over small things, given me the silent treatment for weeks, sent nasty texts etc and I don't know how to slot it in amongst the warmth and support through the years. There is someone whom I love in there amongst all of the brokenness, so it's just terribly confusing. Many times, I've thought she's a complete bitch but then other times have been happy. She is my mother and I do love her but she has hurt me a lot through the years. Acknowledging that she has done her best and literally can't love me properly has been quite helpful.

OP posts:
StaunchMomma · 06/07/2024 21:14

You've put up with her crap your whole life, OP. Not your fault, you were primed to do so, but NOW your job isn't just to look out for you, it's to advocate for your child, too.

You do NOT have to allow her to interfere, belittle or upset you in front of your child. You do NOT have to visit her at all, never mind for prolonged periods.

She will instil in your child the same feelings she put on you, but only if you let her.

You can leave, at any point. You can speak up, at any point. You can criticise her back, at any point.

Stand up for your little one, OP. Let her know her bullying years are over. Whatever need she meets by being such a cow she can go and find someone else to fulfil for her!

StaunchMomma · 06/07/2024 21:17

When she was going on about how my child is over stimulated because I sing to him and how she read an article that kids need to be bored (which I totally agree with, in the right context, btw) I felt like I'd been punched in the stomach.

She's irritated because she didn't do any of those things with you. You are showing her her failures as a mother by being a better one.

Stop turning all of her bad points in on yourself.

Fridgetapas · 06/07/2024 21:18

God she sounds SO mean!! You sound like an absolutely brilliant mum.

thecatsthecats · 06/07/2024 21:20

AnnaMagnani · 06/07/2024 20:48

Thanks @thecatsthecats

My DM also had a truly awful childhood. She tried to be a better mum than hers, but she is a very damaged person. When she didn't know any better, this wasn't her choosing to be crap or abusive.

I was lucky enough to have a shitload of therapy and I am sure this is the reason we aren't NC now.

OP you absolutely need some boundaries around your mum. Whether these boundaries are so high you don't see her at all is your choice. But they should involve seeing her less and expecting her to respect you as an adult.

Gosh, with you there on the "trying hard to be better than her own mum" bit.

A lot of it comes out when the grandkids arrive, I think. My mum slips out that she was "done with making bottles and pushing prams by age 11" from looking after her younger siblings. Though she was also told off for trying to comfort her baby siblings. So she doesn't do grandkid stuff very naturally.

Although she did parent very differently from her own mum, I think it hurts her to see natural affection.

Doesn't sound like OP's mum is as cognisant of her own trauma though tbh.

Tryingtobeagoodmummy · 06/07/2024 21:21

She pulled a face and said 'do you know what his problem is? Far too much stimulation. Constantly singing songs and talking to him. Is it any wonder he is wired to the moon?'

This was in my OP but I forgot to mention that she looked absolutely delighted to be saying it. Like she was revelling in each word and was hoping it made me feel as stupid as possible. Her face was so expressive and I could see a glint of sheer delight in her eye. I was sort of lying down and she was standing over me and she gave off an air of feeling incredibly empowered by telling me that I thought i was doing a great job, but guess what, im not.

I could always sense her thinking 'YESSSS!' as she said it. It was horrible.

OP posts:
StaunchMomma · 06/07/2024 21:21

Tryingtobeagoodmummy · 06/07/2024 19:35

Why am I is right. I don't know. Im pathetic, that's why.

See how you agree with all perceived criticism and automatically blame yourself?

In all likelihood, your upbringing did that to you.

Don't let her do it to your little one, too.

Carebearsonmybed · 06/07/2024 21:25

She sounds like a terrible parent!

Houseshmouse · 06/07/2024 21:31

She sees everything you do differently as an insult to her.
Lay down some ground rules, stand up for yourself and stand up for your child.

Undethetree · 06/07/2024 21:32

You sound like a truly lovely mum. Your mum doesn't. I did some pretty batshit things with my PFB and my mum never said a word that wasn't encouragement or praise. I suspect she rolled her eyes and bit her lip constantly when I wasn't looking!!!

I'm sorry your mum is not supportive. I think you need to be around her as little as possible because you sound very confident in your parenting (rightly so!) and it would be a shame for her to chip away at that. Surround yourself with friends and people like your MIL who make you feel good.

Also...the oatbars sound ace and you SHOULD be proud - I'm proud when I soft boil an egg perfectly, I literally ask everyone in the house to admire it 😄

Greentapemeasure · 06/07/2024 21:32

You’re a good mum, your mum sounds horrid. Everyone has different ideas about parenting but even if she didn’t agree with the things you do unless you’re actually putting him in danger she should just roll her eyes and let you get on with it, that’s what my mum does.

StrongandNorthern · 06/07/2024 21:33

Blimey! You sound like an amazing mum!
Just keep following your instincts - your parenting style/activity ideas/food choices all sound great.
I'm a granny now - my daughter in law does things in a very similar way you you ... I love the way she is bringing up my grandchildren..
Don't doubt yourself.
She sounds very difficult. Please keep doing things your way, and try not to let her upset you.😘😘

Houseshmouse · 06/07/2024 21:35

It sounds like you are an adult child of emotionally immature parents.
When I found this term it was a lightbulb moment!

OhcantthInkofaname · 06/07/2024 21:37

How about you just plain tell her that you don't need a running commentary on how you parent your child. Quit allowing her to give your child what we in the US call junk food. Stand up to her and don't allow her to make you doubt you knowledge. If you have to go no contact do it.

ttcat37 · 06/07/2024 21:41

Have you tried telling her to fuck off?

Crazycatlady79 · 06/07/2024 21:41

God, she sounds vile.
But, you're letting her walk all over you AND your child.
Don't let her.

flipflopsandsun · 06/07/2024 21:41

YourMommaWasASnowblower · 06/07/2024 19:06

You sound like a fantastic mum to me.

I am willing to bet it’s one thing that is the root cause of her behaviour - jealousy.
I bet you are a much better parent than she was and it’s making her feel uncomfortable feelings about herself.
Ignore her comments, limit your time with her and leave her stew in her bitterness.

This are my thoughts exactly.

Cherrysoup · 06/07/2024 21:47

Are you still at her house? Leave, she’s being horrible. Yo7 do sound like you desperately want her approval, let me tell you a secret, you don’t need it, you’re doing fine. I certainly wouldn’t be making the effort to spend time with her, she doesn’t respect your boundaries and undermines you, why would you see her?

Seagrassbasket · 06/07/2024 21:50

Christ OP she sounds awful. In fact that’s a bit unfair - she sounds really damaged. The post where you described she looked delighted to be telling you your son was ‘wired to the moon’ because you were singing to him whilst she stood over you made the hairs stand up on my neck a bit.

You sound like a bloody great mum. Keep going with your singing and your oat bars etc it all sounds just lovely and so positive for your son.

I don’t really know what to say about your relationship with your mum going forward. What do you want? What does your husband say?