Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My mum hates me trying my best to look after my child

154 replies

Tryingtobeagoodmummy · 06/07/2024 19:00

Background. I've a weird realtionship with my mum which, looking back, involved me walking on eggshells and her seeming to think I'm a bit of an idiot.

now im married to my lively DH and we have a 2 year old son. I always wanted to be a mum and try to be the best mother I can be. I don't see my mum very frequently but when I do she literally never has anything nice to say about how I look after my child.

We went to stay with her recently and my son was a bit funny with her as he hasn't seen her in a while. He wouldn't go to her and she started seeming annoyed, pulling faces or making a fake crying noise when he started to get a bit upset if he thought I was leaving the room. I tried to just ignore it as I didn't want an argument and we are leaving soon. She kept saying how I was 'never like that' and was I sure there wasn't something 'wrong with him'? (SEN). As it happens, I have no concerns and neither does his health visitor or his nursery.

I have been making my own little breakfast bars with oats, mashed banana, peanut butter etc etc and she saw them sitting on the side, cooling. I thought it was a good, healthy way to get some fruit and fibre into him. She asked what they were and I explained. She pulled a face and said 'it looks like a pile of crap'. For some reason I froze and felt my eyes fill with tears and I just walked out of the room so she wouldn't see me crying. I felt a bit embarrassed about my little bars.

Ds has been practising nursery rhymes with me and in nursery and can do a really cute version of 'Twinkle Twinkle'. I started singing with him to see if he would do it for my mum. He didnt but was very into his toys at the time. He was very excitable that days and afterwards, i mentioned to mum that he had been quite hyper that evening. She pulled a face and said 'do you know what his problem is? Far too much stimulation. Constantly singing songs and talking to him. Is it any wonder he is wired to the moon?'

She keeps trying to give him chocolate and I'd prefer he just gets a treat after he has had enough fruit and veg for the day. There isn't a ban on treats but I'd rather he had some chopped apple or strawberries first. Part of this is that he is prone to constipation and when I said that she said 'well you can just give him a laxative then'. I explained that I think it's better for a child to get their fibre from real fruit and veg first, and then use a laxative only if that didn't work. She just looked at me like I had ten heads.

I'd also rather he just enjoyed water and didn't get accustomed to squash, partially because I have a weird reaction to the sweeteners in squash and would just rather he preferred water. I decided to let it go and go with the flow a bit more but it's just glass after glass of strong squash. I said can you just give him water and she said 'it's not right to give children water' and she makes a big deal out of how 'yucky' water is ("mean mummy" etc)

Ds started to warm up to her and was making us fake ice creams. I did the whole 'oh yum, vanilla, my favourite etc etc'. He gave her an imaginary ice cream and she said 'am I supposed to pretend to eat this? I don't do that'. Ds didn't notice but I thought it was totally weird and made excuses to go and give him a bath.

I asked him if he wanted to go to the park or stay inside with toys a few days ago, and she said it was clear I never told him no and he had far too much choice (absolutely not true!!!). Then the following day I was very firm with him about something and she said 'didn't mummy use a horrible, mean voice with you'.

She does this thing where she ruffles his hair for longer than necessary and he really doesn't like it. I can see him wincing and pulling his shoulders up. I told her that he doesn't seem to like that and she said 'oh for God's sake, you are far too fussy with him!' I actually don't think I'm too fussy, I can just see that he really dislikes that. My mother in law never annoys me with any way she interacts with my child, in fact she is great and he is much more relaxed around her. So its not me being the impossible to please precious first time mum.

My mum seems to really resent every time I try my best to be a good mum. It seems to really, really bother her. I thought she would be proud of me for being a good mum; strangers have literally come up to me to say things like 'I just saw you with your child and you're so loving towards him, it's lovely to see' etc. Why oh why does it bother her so much? She has form for absolutely going off on one and I want to get through the next few days without a fall out. However my instincts are saying that this isn't normal and I need to rethink our relationship and visiting arrangements for the next time.

I've always has an odd relationship with her but thought that she would see me in a new light when I had kids and not see me like a silly little girl any more, but she seems to absolutely despise me now! I know I need to re evaluate things and to be honest I'm absolutely gutted to finally realise who my mother actually really is.
Wibu to reduce contact further if this continues?

OP posts:
ClawdeenWolf · 06/07/2024 19:26

RedHelenB · 06/07/2024 19:23

Why are you parading your dc like a performing bear to try to shoe your mum how superior a mum you are? Just parent your child your way, without looking for approval.

I think when you've had a domineering, critical parent you don't easily lose the habit of trying to please them.

OP, you sound brilliant. Your DM sounds awful. I would reduce the contact even further, she's undermining your (I think excellent!) parenting choices. I bet she's always made you feel like shit about yourself. Pure jealousy.

Limer · 06/07/2024 19:26

She's jealous of you, and she hates you.

Step Away.

Babadook76 · 06/07/2024 19:28

I think you’ve hit the nail on the head here, and at least you’re very aware that the issues are your mums failings, not yours. I have an issue with mine, where when we were little she didn’t believe in spending money on us. Now every time we’re all out together she’s pulling faces and tutting every time I buy my children an ice cream, or something small out of a gift shop. I’d say yours is even worse in that it’s crossing into abuse imo. I’d seriously consider cutting contact with her as she is damaging your son

Tryingtobeagoodmummy · 06/07/2024 19:30

I just don't know what to say because I feel so upst that I'm just realising what a toxic person she is. I do think she is very jealous actually. I see my mother in law back all of our decisions and it feels very normal and while MIL isn't full of outright praise (that's definitely not her style!) it all seems very natural and affirmative. When I'm with my mum, it all seems so confrontational and negative. Every little thing seems like it's a big deal.

When she was going on about how my child is over stimulated because I sing to him and how she read an article that kids need to be bored (which I totally agree with, in the right context, btw) I felt like I'd been punched in the stomach. Because I put my heart into mothering my son and I pour my heart into every aspect of raising him. I thought she would be proud. I don't mean idolising my child, or putting him on a pedestal, by the way, as that isn't in the child's best interests, but just how seriously I take my job as a mother and what a privilege i find it to be blessed with a child. She wants me to think I'm an over the top, neurotic, annoying performative parent, I think. I feel stupid interacting with my son around her now, or offering him water or fruit, or singing a song or anything normal!!!

OP posts:
MammaTo · 06/07/2024 19:30

It sounds like your holding a mirror up to her and how she treated you as a kid. She’s being resentful because by the sounds of it she wasn’t a very nice mum and seeing you with your little one is showing her up.

Tryingtobeagoodmummy · 06/07/2024 19:32

Oops sorry I don't have a recipe, I just throw mashed bananas, peanut butter, an egg, oats, any random fruit about to go off and a cup of flour into a lined baking dish and hope for the best! It normally comes out ok!

OP posts:
MartyFunkhouser · 06/07/2024 19:32

She sounds really awful. You need to stand up to her, there’s no way I’d allow her to give him chocolate or squash. Squash is just crap.

I think I’d be keeping contact to a minimum.

Createausername1970 · 06/07/2024 19:32

You sound like you are doing just fine.

Keep your interactions with your mum to a minimum, and brace yourself for inevitable stupidity when you do see her, but do not take it to heart.

plainjayne8282 · 06/07/2024 19:35

Your mum sounds like a dick.

My guess is that she's jealous.

Tryingtobeagoodmummy · 06/07/2024 19:35

RedHelenB · 06/07/2024 19:23

Why are you parading your dc like a performing bear to try to shoe your mum how superior a mum you are? Just parent your child your way, without looking for approval.

Why am I is right. I don't know. Im pathetic, that's why.

OP posts:
AnnaMagnani · 06/07/2024 19:37

You are absolutely not pathetic.

You have been brought up by a mum who trained you to want to please her.

Now you are a mum, you are still trying to please her but the scales are falling from your eyes as actually everything she'd like you to do is bullshit.

solsticelove · 06/07/2024 19:37

As someone else pointed out, your excellent parenting is holding a mirror up to hers. She’s triggered (to use modern psychology term!). Sorry you have a mum like this 😞

FWIW, you do NOT need to justify your parenting choices to her or to anyone x

YourMommaWasASnowblower · 06/07/2024 19:37

Tryingtobeagoodmummy · 06/07/2024 19:30

I just don't know what to say because I feel so upst that I'm just realising what a toxic person she is. I do think she is very jealous actually. I see my mother in law back all of our decisions and it feels very normal and while MIL isn't full of outright praise (that's definitely not her style!) it all seems very natural and affirmative. When I'm with my mum, it all seems so confrontational and negative. Every little thing seems like it's a big deal.

When she was going on about how my child is over stimulated because I sing to him and how she read an article that kids need to be bored (which I totally agree with, in the right context, btw) I felt like I'd been punched in the stomach. Because I put my heart into mothering my son and I pour my heart into every aspect of raising him. I thought she would be proud. I don't mean idolising my child, or putting him on a pedestal, by the way, as that isn't in the child's best interests, but just how seriously I take my job as a mother and what a privilege i find it to be blessed with a child. She wants me to think I'm an over the top, neurotic, annoying performative parent, I think. I feel stupid interacting with my son around her now, or offering him water or fruit, or singing a song or anything normal!!!

She doesn’t sound like a mother who would ever be proud of anything or anyone - she is most definitely toxic.
And yes, she does likely want you to think you are neurotic and all the other things you say because that way you will stop being your fantastic self and it will make her feel better about herself, and also will make her feel back in control of you. Do NOT stop being the fantastic mother you are, Do NOT give her the satisfaction of her winning. You are the better mother, remember that.

stayathomer · 06/07/2024 19:38

‘If you don’t have anything nice to say don’t say anything at all’. Hopefully something that simple does it! And all parents parent differently, just tell her that’s how you do it!

TimoteiChaletpants · 06/07/2024 19:38

You sound fab
she Sounds awful

MrsClownland · 06/07/2024 19:39

Tryingtobeagoodmummy · 06/07/2024 19:35

Why am I is right. I don't know. Im pathetic, that's why.

You're not being pathetic at all. But I think you're looking for something from her that isn't in her nature to give. She does not sound very nice. Hopefully as you gain more confidence in your role her behaviour will wash off you more.

godmum56 · 06/07/2024 19:40

Tryingtobeagoodmummy · 06/07/2024 19:35

Why am I is right. I don't know. Im pathetic, that's why.

I don't think you are pathetic but she has got you trained good. Its time to step up, set your boundaries and protect your son. Tell her that if she can't comply with your rules then she can't be with you and your child and if she is with you and she can't comply then she will leave your house. PS I can't tolerate any kind of artificial sweetener either.

Epicaricacy · 06/07/2024 19:43

OP, hats off to you for being such a caring and lovely mum when you have grown up with such a bully and you have had an awful example.

It's amazing you are doing exactly the right thing and sound like an amazing mum.

No, YANBU to distance yourself. It's awfully sad, but she's damaging you, and that's not fair. Both you and your child deserve better.

ALPHAFEMALESINCEBIRTH · 06/07/2024 19:48

it sounds like its not liked that you don't need her for anything

a lot of people desperately need people(usually their grown children) to "need" them some way
even if its just general parenting advice
when its not even asked they then pick at healthy parenting so you feel you doing wrong

if its your mother then you problem been brought up like this so you don't realise its wrong

it takes a strong person to noticed this and nip it in the bud straight away

and when your happy and healthy and do your own thing
boy its not liked and they do all they can to get you to need them

in your case i would be bringing it up loudly and with a tone every time that she's wrong and its not acceptable behaviour

then go very low contact as its not healthy for your baby

doesn't matter who the person is
if they are toxic or no good for you
protect yourself and your baby and go low contact or no contact

these people need to know this behaviour/bullshit is not going to be tolerated and accepted

what you described is emotional blackmail to a baby who don't even under stand emotional blackmail and belittling you because you don't need or want her advice

i take zero shit off anyone and the first comment it would have been nipped in the bud straight away to the point they know not to even try it again

but my family know not to try anything or mess with me

Tryingtobeagoodmummy · 06/07/2024 19:51

I also think that she doesn't like that now I have someone in my life that I will 100 percent put above her. I have never called her out on so many things since I had my son, but she has never been as critical of me. It's actually devastating that she is so poised against me in a way like never before, at a time in my life when I thought we would be brought closer together by motherhood. I don't know why she is so against me. I'm a nice person, with lots of friends, I get on with everyone, I think I'm kind amd thoughtful, have worked hard, have a good job, nice home, never in much trouble in my teens, kept my head down, was studious etc. My husband once said that she talks to me like I'm stupid sometimes. I don't know why she has such a low opinion of me. Your parents are the ones who know you the best and I often think that if she thinks I'm annoying, then I probably am because she knows me better than anyone. I'm just so sad that I think she really is actually jealous of me, and I've thought that before, if I'm honest. It's a horrible, unsafe feeling. I'm quite gutted to be honest.

OP posts:
LittleBitAlexisLaLaLaLaLa · 06/07/2024 19:55

You sound like a great mum. Your mum… not so much. And maybe she feels inferior to you and so behaves in the pathetically twatty way she does. Not excusing her behaviour and you shouldn’t change a thing about your parenting. It’s her that has the problem here, it’s not you. Don’t let her undermine you. Wanting to engage with your child and feed them right and encourage them to drink water and not squash is not being precious or weird. Totally normal. Watch her though. The older your child gets the more obvious her spiteful attitude will be noticed by him and affect him.

AnnaMagnani · 06/07/2024 19:56

Your parents are the ones who know you the best

They really really aren't.

For starters your mum still seems to think you are a child not a grown woman with a husband and a baby of her own. She still talks to you as if you are a child, and not even one she likes very much.

I think she has absolutely no idea who you are at all.

notnorman · 06/07/2024 19:56

AnnaMagnani · 06/07/2024 19:37

You are absolutely not pathetic.

You have been brought up by a mum who trained you to want to please her.

Now you are a mum, you are still trying to please her but the scales are falling from your eyes as actually everything she'd like you to do is bullshit.

This!!!!!!!
There are many parallels here in my life and I totally understand where you are coming from xx

Irridescantshimmmer · 06/07/2024 19:57

She's jealous as sin.

itsmylife7 · 06/07/2024 19:57

You're not pathetic but your Mum is.

You really don't need ANYONE to tell you what a great Mum you are because YOU know you are.